3 ms·
Doesn't all of that censorship make .pk internet access more expensive than it would be? Firewalls and maintaining them aren't free. Cheaper to let it all pass
by Scoundreller 6y ago
Doesn't all of that censorship make .pk internet access more expensive than it would be?
Firewalls and maintaining them aren't free. Cheaper to let it all pass through, especially when it isn't harmful to the network itself.
- amingilani 6y agoThey were doing the bare minimum at first. PTA would order the ISPs to censor resources which would implement the block alone and that's it. Easy to bypass with HTTPS, a 3rd party DNS server, or a VPN. They've since bought an $18.5m web monitoring system from Sandvine and centralized the censorship under PTA. The companies don't deal with it anymore: https://www.codastory.com/authoritarian-tech/surveillance/pakistan-nationwide-web-monitoring/ https://www.codastory.com/authoritarian-tech/surveillance/pa...
- skolsuper 6y agoAmortized over 100m customers, in a country where network engineers can be found for $250/month, they're pretty close to free. It's easy to underestimate how profitable it is to run a telco
- Scoundreller 6y agoSure, but that just means it's an irrelevant factor when comparing low vs. high telecom costs. Though my thinking is when selling censorship equipment to a country, you probably charge a country like .pk more because you know they'll find a way to pay for best-in-class.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoRunning a telco is not that expensive. The problem is that building out the infrastructure in the first place is hugely expensive. This is why most countries have only a few "real" operators that own and operate infra, and tons of virtual operators (MVNO) that run on top of others' gear.