3 ms·
I haven't used OpenSCAD yet but to me the workflow appears to be verry different from what e.g. FreeCAD is doing. There is some overlap but it's not that big.
by imtringued 6y ago
I haven't used OpenSCAD yet but to me the workflow appears to be verry different from what e.g. FreeCAD is doing.
There is some overlap but it's not that big. OpenSCAD is useful if you can describe your model as an algorithm. FreeCAD is useful when you want to define your model visually.
I don't think one can say either of them is strictly better than the other because they are not quite the same.
However it's easy to see how avoiding the need for a constraint solver significantly reduces the complexity of the software.
- elcritch 6y agoOpenSCAD appealed to me as a programmer. I needed to prototype some parts and openscad was simpler than any of the GUI tools. Not sure how but I have talent making SolidWorks blow up with non-invertible matrices. :/ But OpenSCAD’s approach hit a wall quickly for me. Trying to figure out the distances for new objects was a PITA. It would be nice to have a simple GUI tool for placing an item by inserting the proper code. Ideally you’d be able to link changeable parameters in the GUI to code variables and be able to do things like show/hide in the GUI, or even a repl.
- tgflynn 6y agoI don't have much experience with it myself but based on what you said it sounds like there's a real need to have the geometry definition language embedded within a full programming language, like the parent comment said. In the meantime another possibility might be to write a code generator for the scad language.
- justinclift 6y agoLooking through some of the AngelScript samples, they look reasonable. eg: https://github.com/arnholm/angelcad-samples/blob/master/rectangle_rounded.as https://github.com/arnholm/angelcad-samples/blob/master/rect... https://github.com/arnholm/angelcad-samples/blob/master/polyhedron_from_points.as https://github.com/arnholm/angelcad-samples/blob/master/poly... That being said, those are clearly "toy" level of complexity and I haven't tried it out.
- gerdesj 6y agoCAD is a funny area - very different. I'm still learning. It seems OpenSCAD excels when you can describe your object quickly. FreeCAD is for that as well (it has Python embedded) and when you can't describe it parametrically. That said, a recent post on Reddit in r/openscad mentioned designing an entire car to do the Pike Peak challenge in Colorado. We have a lot of tools and methodologies available. Picking the right one needs care and attention to detail. It's the same as the other "real world": I know my way around metal and wood working equipment and I can do simple welding. My carpentry is good first and second fix grade but not cabinetry, and I can weld stuff together, sometimes without melting both objects. I can design bridges and roads as well and they may work fine ...