8 ms·
Posted it in an other thread [0] but do we really want to go back to the medallion system? Pre-Uber, either the driver rented the car to a middleman who rented
by 908B64B197 6y ago
Posted it in an other thread [0] but do we really want to go back to the medallion system?
Pre-Uber, either the driver rented the car to a middleman who rented the medallion from a rich owner, or said owner was selling and financing (most banks won't touch these medallions!) a medallion at a ridiculous interest rate to a driver that planned to use it as his retirement savings (an extremely volatile asset and not very liquid).
The more I spoke to cab drivers the more it seemed their industry was a pyramid schemed aimed at helping established rent-seeker take advantage of often poor new immigrants. Uber brought a breeze of fresh air: Someone could simply buy a car, calculate the depreciation and it's value on the market (since unlike medallions cars are relatively liquid assets!) do rideshare and calculate their profits or loss. They can get out of the game at anytime, and they know exactly how much they are going to get for the car they have should they sell it.
Also, the argument on Uber/Lyft drivers not being contractors since they can't set their own rates and decide which ride they take strikes me as weird since medallion drivers were contractors, had to charge the price set by the city and could only pick-up customers in the (arbitrary) zones covered by their medallions.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24225648 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24225648
- thewebcount 6y ago> Posted it in an other thread [0] but do we really want to go back to the medallion system? No, but that doesn't preclude us from stopping Uber and Lyft. We can have a different system where there are no medallions, the number of cars aren't artificially constrained, but the companies running them need to obey existing laws.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> the companies running them need to obey existing laws Well let's not act like "existing laws" are the most important factor. The laws were changed here, after all! I'd like to see a system where drivers have a lot of control over when they work, and can be in both apps at once, but also have healthcare and the ability to access unemployment insurance. Even though as far as I'm aware it's not feasible under existing law.
- eschaton 6y agoThey weren’t, though! Uber and Lyft are being told that they should have been classifying drivers as employees all along because they’re treating them like employees. This has been plainly obvious from day one.
- tick_tock_tick 6y agoThey were not legally required too; or at-least never lost a law suite to the degree that they were required too. Only once AB 5 pass did it really become a true legal requirement.
- tenuousemphasis 6y agoEmployees are told when to work. Uber and Lyft drivers choose their own hours.
- 908B64B197 6y agoIn most places, the existing laws are the medallions. Which laws? Do they exist now?
- bobthepanda 6y agoWell, TFA is about how Uber and Lyft are leaving California because AB5 makes them pay drivers minimum wage, so I would hope they are leaving California because of a real, existing threat.
- stale2002 6y ago> We can have a different system where there are no medallions, the number of cars aren't artificially constrained, but the companies running them need to obey existing laws. The only reason why the laws changed at all was because of Uber and Lyft. Nobody would have changed the system if they didn't come in.
- wtvanhest 6y agoIt could be interesting to artificially constrain the number of cars and auction the slots on a rolling 12 Month basis so that the tax payers get the full value of the licenses rather than speculators
- LegitShady 6y agowelcome to the medallion system
- aeternum 6y agoIt should not be just cabs, it should be all cars
- anticensor 6y agoBut make them non-transferable.
- kofejnik 6y ago> artificially constrain the number of cars Why? Also, if we're doing this, let's also artificially constrain something else, maybe the amount of meat produced, and auction the right to sell meat to few highest bidders? After all, meat production has a lot externalities like methane emissions, etc etc., so why not constrain it? Then, we must prevent exploitation of poor underpaid workers in Bangladesh, so let's restrict clothes supply, to reduce harmful externalities. Two pairs of basic jeans and 3 shirts should be enough for everyone, right?
- kofejnik 6y ago> that doesn't preclude us from stopping Uber and Lyft. I really really hope that you fail. Thanks to Uber, my wife can enjoy safe and reliable transportation. But some whiteknighting woke people cannot tolerate that, I guess they hate women? Oh wait, my wife is an evil capitalist who's exploiting poor User drivers, right? How ironic
- no_wizard 6y agoHmm this makes it sound too easy to be so easy. I agree with disrupting the medallion system but the cost of rides fell dramatically and by most accounts I can find if drivers actually did their taxes correctly, they would be making less than minimum wage[0] [0]https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2018/03/02/uber-lyft-drivers-actually-earn-less-than-minimum-wage-mit-survey-suggests/389230002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2018/03/02/ub...
- 908B64B197 6y agoThat sounds like an oversupply problem. Why keep driving if the wages are so low? Also, in the medallion days it wasn't uncommon for drivers to end up in the red after a bad day, when factoring the costs of renting the medallion in the first place.
- bobthepanda 6y agoBecause drivers, generally speaking, are not well-informed of their costs. Generally speaking when considering their wages they don't count the costs of the maintenance and depreciation on their vehicles, because this is not something that a normal driver has to think about very hard, and they all used to be just normal drivers. But it's not very hard to hit 100k miles on a car when rideshare becomes your new profession.
- stickfigure 6y agoI don't think most Uber/Lyft drivers look at this as a career; at least, none of the ones I've met do. It's a way of making a few bucks without a lot of commitment while they prepare to do something else. You want to help these people out? Get rid of most occupational licensing.
- prostoalex 6y ago> Because drivers, generally speaking, are not well-informed of their costs. I dunno, going through some forum threads on UberPeople shows exact opposite - drivers meticulously track their take, expenses, etc. - there is even a cottage industry of tools giving them all sorts of data analytics in exchange for the ride data. Anecdotally, I’ve seen one driver keep a spreadsheet of various gasoline brands and his mpg (my destination was near Costco and I casually suggested he use it to refuel, and got an earful on how Costco was in his top 5, but not the best options to refuel).
- addicted 6y agoThen the medallion system needs to be improved. But the medallion system served a purpose of limiting the number of cars. Traffic in big cities has become much worse precisely because of Uber and Lyft. The cost of that to everybody is orders of magnitudes higher than the slightly higher cab fares people were paying.
- svrb 6y agoYes, yes, but medallions are regulated! By the government! That makes them obviously superior, and a more ethical choice. Imagine if we had unregulated doctors, or engineers, or software developers! It would be chaos, just like Uber/Lyft, and result in unfairness that never happens with the medallions.
- 908B64B197 6y agoYou are totally right. Medallion owners wouldn't try to lobby local governments to restrict the supply of medallions. Just like the AMA doesn't lobby at all to set an artificially low number of residency spots for aspiring doctors.
- refurb 6y agoExactly. HN loves to rally against regulatory capture and rent seeking and taxi medallions are a great example of both.