4 ms·
I don't agree that the judiciary is captured. The Stolen Valor Act, for example, was struck down despite unanimous approval in Congress.
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
I don't agree that the judiciary is captured. The Stolen Valor Act, for example, was struck down despite unanimous approval in Congress.
- sudosysgen 6y agoMy argument is that the judiciary has instantaneous independence but not real independence. If the DNC and the RNC decided that they really wanted it to be passed, they have to power to solely elect judges to the Supreme Court which would uphold it. If your standard is that a single act of minor importance refused by the judiciary is enough to mean indépendance of judiciary, an equal application of the standard results in the conclusion that the Chinese judiciary and judicial review process is independent. Which is a conclusion I disagree with, not only because I disagree with the standard.
- refurb 6y agoIf the DNC and the RNC decided that they really wanted it to be passed, they have to power to solely elect judges to the Supreme Court which would uphold it. Considering most judicial positions (with some exceptions where they are locally elected) are life time positions, yes, theoretically the gov't could nominate judges that are aligned with their view, that would be almost impossible to execute. In addition, they are nominated by the party in power, but need to be approved by a committee comprised of both parties.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoWhether it's independence in some cosmic sense doesn't seem like a tremendously interesting question. (Is anyone independent from anything on a scale of decades?)
- kelnos 6y ago> If the DNC and the RNC decided that they really wanted it to be passed, they have to power to solely elect judges to the Supreme Court which would uphold it. That's a bit of a stretch. First off, SCOTUS justices are appointed (through a nomination and confirmation process), not elected. In order for either the DNC or RNC, or both of them surprisingly working together, to pull this off, it'd wouldn't be trivial. Let's assume for a moment the "easy" case: out of 9 justices, 4 of them are in favor of this thing, 5 against. The DNC+RNC then have to get one of those 5 justices to retire, or they have to get lucky, and one of them dies. Then they have to get that appointee to the president. Next we have to assume that the president agrees with this thing they want. If so, cool, the president makes the nomination. Then it goes to the Senate. Does the DNC+RNC have 51 senators that agree? Ok, cool, justice gets confirmed. Issue goes to court, makes its way up to SCOTUS, and the ruling is 5-4 in favor of whatever the DNC+RNC wants... unless someone has changed their mind and switched sides during all this. I feel like that's already happened! If you believe that the RNC alone has managed to get Gorsuch and Kavanaugh on the court in order to do nefarious things, they've largely failed. Both justices have been reasonably moderate (so far, at least), when compared to what Trump and McConnell wanted. Now, this isn't a completely implausible scenario. I'll grant you that, certainly. But: if the DNC+RNC really want something this much, then they presumably have the support of a bunch of constituents and, critically, state legislatures. It would seem to maybe be a better idea to go for a constitutional amendment. In reality, I'd say that's crazy; the three-fourths of the states agreeing on something of constitutional importance is pretty unlikely. But if we're in this bizarro world where the DNC and RNC agree that something unconstitutional really needs to get passed, this is probably a better path to take than trying to engineer some light judicial subversion. So while I think your hypothetical is an interesting thought experiment, it's not really important in practice. SCOTUS is independent in the ways that actually matter. If there's bi-partisan support among government and citizens for something, it probably should be law. Yes, there's the possibility that this hypothetical unconstitutional thing they want to make into law is tyranny of the majority of the worst sort. But at the end of the day you can only make the system so robust, and I think our system is decently ok in that regard, the past 3.5 years notwithstanding.