10 ms·
I said this about Firefox itself, but if they charged to directly sponsor MDN I would sign up. They can even create support tiers that don't really mean anythin
by giancarlostoro 6y ago
I said this about Firefox itself, but if they charged to directly sponsor MDN I would sign up. They can even create support tiers that don't really mean anything other than it gets appended to your user role, maybe badges per month per role or something so it stays immortalized.
What I said about Firefox Developer Edition: if they kept it free but added a paid version, I would pay for it just to directly support Firefox development.
It has to be 100% clear that all funds need to go towards MDN and Firefox Developer tools / Firefox itself in order for me to remain subscribed to either one.
Firefox has been my browser for decades now, and MDN has been my bread and butter since whenever I discovered how useful it was.
- eli 6y agoWhat else would the funds go to that you're worried about?
- giancarlostoro 6y agoYou may want to see why Thunderbird had to create their own foundation just to fund their project. Firefox makes most of its income from the search engine deal with Google it seems. Looking at the Mozilla Foundation (not to be confused with the corporation which is what maintains Firefox) their initiatives dont even mention Firefox. They really need to make it very transparent where your money ends up. They list a buncha awards and convention type events, that's not helping Firefox at all. https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/initiatives/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/initiatives/
- eitland 6y agoFrom what I understand Firefox is only a source of income, not a prioritized product. And yes: IMO this is kibd of backwards. Firefox has been their biggest contribution to the open web and it seems they are treating it as just an income source.
- eli 6y agoI don't see how that could be true given that they continue to roll out features to Firefox.
- giancarlostoro 6y agoWe're not saying Firefox isn't being maintained, we're saying donations don't go to Firefox, they go to the foundation which is also apparently funded by Firefox. Something really needs to change... We shouldn't have heard about basically what is crucial for developers being scrapped to keep the show running.
- eli 6y agoThe Foundation doesn't cover the payroll for the engineers working on Firefox?
- shock 6y agoMy impression from the layoffs thread from a couple weeks ago is that the Foundation does not employ engineers working on Firefox.
- giancarlostoro 6y agoI dont think its fair to downvote you for asking a question. But no it does not seem to be the case.
- thayne 6y agoNo, Firefox is developed by Mozilla Corporation, which is a for-profit company owned by Mozilla foundation. As I understand it, this opens up the possibility of revenue sources not available to a non-profit for Firefox, but otoh, means you can't donate to support Firefox.
- hvis 6y agoLast I saw the numbers, donations tally up to ~$10 million, and the search engine deal to ~$500 million. So I'm not sure what practical purpose you are aiming at.
- alphaomegacode 6y agoYou're very much on to something I think. I asked a question about the CEO & management soon after they announced the layoffs and the post had a few very good observations by others - then someone flagged the post and only my comments/responses. Maybe she or her umpteen executives were on a mission to be busy lol. You can see it here and some of the really good answers imo https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24171030 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24171030
- input_sh 6y agoLong story short, donations to the Mozilla Foundation go to the Foundation, while Firefox, MDN, and others are managed by the Mozilla Corporation (a subsidiary of the Foundation). You can donate to the Foundation, but you can only purchase products from the Corporation: Mozilla VPN (https://vpn.mozilla.org/ https://vpn.mozilla.org/), Pocket Premium (https://getpocket.com/premium https://getpocket.com/premium), and Firefox Private Network (https://fpn.firefox.com/ https://fpn.firefox.com/). You can't donate to the Corporation.
- vbezhenar 6y agoManagement salaries.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoLooking at https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2018/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2018/, e.g. the "Combating Misinformation" is not something that I'd consider one of the core tasks of Mozilla. I would also assume that there are conferences, grants/sponsorship/stipends, CEO pay, etc. The audited report lists conferences/conventions meetings and advertising/promotion, two items that some may not want to contribute to. I'm making no judgement regarding whether these expenses make sense or not, just pointing out something that someone who wants to finance Firefox and MDN may not want to contribute to. Of course, unless you trust the organization to actually honor the intent behind a donation for a specific purpose, such donations are moot as long as the organization receives enough general-purpose donations: They can just put 100% of the money tied to a specific purpose behind that purpose, but reduce the amount of "general-purpose" money that would otherwise have gone to that purpose by the same amount.
- mschuster91 6y ago> "Combating Misinformation" is not something that I'd consider one of the core tasks of Mozilla. Why? Misinformation is, this should have been proven by now, the greatest threat to democracy in recent history. Browsers, social networks and search engines are the entry point into the web, they have to act with the responsibility that comes with this position (and yes I know neither Facebook nor Google have done a good job the last years).
- ifmpx 6y agoIt's fine to think like this, but it's not fine to use donations for it if those donations were not made for that cause. This is why people don't donate to mozilla.
- worik 6y agoGolly. It is there in their annual report. In part it is what you are donating for. In a way it is MDN's mission
- wow_no 6y ago
- denschub 6y agoExactly this has been attempted for a limited time in 2018, https://hacks.mozilla.org/2018/10/a-new-way-to-support-mdn/ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2018/10/a-new-way-to-support-mdn/, and pretty much nobody actually paid.
- jbenner-radham 6y agoWow you weren’t kidding. I went to the payment page at https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/payments/ https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/payments/ and it says they only have 44 monthly supporters. I’m going to donate now though, thanks for the heads up on this. Edit: Unfortunately It appears that you can’t donate to MDN anymore because the “manage payments” page 404s.
- donaltroddyn 6y agoHave you found a way to donate? All the links on that page are dead for me.
- jbenner-radham 6y agoI have not. Apparently it was a limited time run. :(
- danpeddle 6y agohttps://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/ https://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/ ..? I put a note that I’m donating because of X when I do.
- denschub 6y agoThat was a limited time experiment, which got shut down after it didn't prove very successful. But from that, it's probably a fair guess that it would not perform well if rolled out again today. There are a few very vocal people who want to support MDN, and that's great, but that's probably not true for the bigger audience. :(