5 ms·
https://www.spaceflightinsider.com/conferences/vasimr-plasma-engine-earth-mars-39-days/ https://www.spaceflightinsider.com/conferences/vasimr-plasma... http://
by sandworm101 6y ago
https://www.spaceflightinsider.com/conferences/vasimr-plasma-engine-earth-mars-39-days/ https://www.spaceflightinsider.com/conferences/vasimr-plasma...
http://spacenews.com/vasimr-hoax/ http://spacenews.com/vasimr-hoax/
"Zubrin wrote in SpaceNews: “To achieve his much-repeated claim that VASIMR could enable a 39-day one-way transit to Mars, Chang Diaz posits a nuclear reactor system with a power of 200,000 kilowatts and a power-to-mass ratio of 1,000 watts per kilogram. In fact, the largest space nuclear reactor ever built, the Soviet[-era] Topaz, had a power of 10 kilowatts and a power-to-mass ratio of 10 watts per kilogram. There is thus no basis whatsoever for believing in the feasibility of Chang Diaz’s fantasy power system.”
Note the word used by spacenews: Hoax.
- sobellian 6y agoThe idea isn't ludicrous, although the torch-ship speeds of 39-day transits are definitely out of reach for now. The basic idea is, let's attach a nuclear reactor to an ion engine. Further, let's make the propellant hydrogen so we can refuel anywhere in the solar system. If we want to get serious about exploiting the solar system, we'll eventually have to give in and embrace nuclear technology, whether something like VASIMR or a nuclear-thermal design like NERVA. We already routinely park 100MW+ nuclear reactors in port for our navy, why not consider civilian use for space exploration? We already know many ways to mitigate risk for the launch of nuclear material. I think Musk, Zubrin, et al. analyze propulsion technologies from the perspective of how to enable a journey to Mars now. In that light, something like Raptor makes much more sense. You still need a chemical rocket engine to lift off from Earth or Mars, so in the near term a nuclear ion thruster just adds far too much complexity to justify its inclusion. Further, it's difficult to imagine SpaceX obtaining the political backing to put nuclear tech into space as a private company. This is also why Musk would rather power Martian propellant plants with fields of solar arrays instead of the much more mass-efficient space-rated nuclear reactors that NASA has been developing. But imagine if we actually developed a Mars colony with millions of people. The logistics of seeding a colony on Mars with chemical thrusters already boggle the mind. Economics would basically forbid meaningful interplanetary trade unless we develop new technology with much higher specific impulse. It would be even more impactful than moving from air-freight to container ships.
- heimatau 6y agoThis boils down to theoretical vs applied. The OP approx. stated that we're basically 1/100 of the way there and this theoretical drive is currently impossible to implement. I've changed my career path because of these problems. I was a Math Major and now EE. These are the problems we need to be focusing on. Instead of using outdated and faulty technology from the 1960s. IMHO, humanity is an inflationary species (for lack of a better term). We want to grow, spread and thrive. We aren't using a horse and a buggy. We (mostly) aren't shipping big chunks of ice around the world. We've made massive innovations happen and we should continue. It's nice that VASIMR is trying to push the envelop. Hopefully more of us can join together and tackle these big problems together.
- sandworm101 6y ago>>> The OP approx. stated that we're basically 1/100 of the way there But we really aren't 1/100th of the way. That's like saying a 90miles/gallon car is 1% of the way to getting 9000 miles/gallon. Getting from one to the other cannot happen through incremental improvements. It requires totally different, as yet unexplored, areas of science.
- heimatau 6y ago>> That's like saying a 90miles/gallon car is 1% of the way to getting 9000 miles/gallon. Yeah. I think that would be apt to say. If you're able to do some napkin math about the sheer amount of R&D to get to the other 99%, start a company ASAP because that is the billion (maybe trillion) dollar question. Getting there is different, yes, which was entirely my original point. I'd rather not shoot an idea down before we've even started. Let's stop with the nitpicking and actually build. Incremental is probably the only way that we will get there. Think like a builder, not a complainer. Will getting the other 99% look like how we got 1%? Of course not and if it does...then we're actually very close to a major breakthrough because we have a lot of the auxiliary technology already fleshed out. Every journey begins with one step and we already have made a few steps. Now onto making many more.
- Ductapemaster 6y ago
- ColanR 6y agoYour source is ignoring the fact that limitations on nuclear power in space are largely political. If we could put something bigger up there without concern it would be interpreted as a nuke, we would.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Gravityloss 6y agoCooling is hard in space. It is hard and expensive to get good power to weight ratios.
- ColanR 6y agoThere's a lot of hard problems in space, though. We've solved a few of them - enough, at least, so that talking about large nuclear reactors in space should not be dismissed as a hoax.
- Gibbon1 6y ago30 years ago as a student I tried calculating how big a space reactors cooling fins would need to be be. 1MW of power means 2 MW of heat you need to dissipate via radiation. I can't remember the numbers but I remember the result was dismal. The problem becomes yes you can use a reactor or nuclear battery to power and ion rocket, which fuel efficient, very energy inefficient, and sloooow. Or you can use a nuclear rocket which avoids the need for a radiator by tossing your waste heat out the back end. Better fuel efficiency than a chemical rocket, can go faster, difficulty gamma radiation. Between those there isn't anything in between that makes sense because a high power thermal power reactor is too heavy.