3 ms·
My concern is, if we don't know what understanding is, how do we know it's not becoming a god of the gaps? Playing Go and writing poetry were canonical examples
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
My concern is, if we don't know what understanding is, how do we know it's not becoming a god of the gaps? Playing Go and writing poetry were canonical examples of things AI couldn't do without true understanding, right up until we wrote AIs that could do them.
- wahern 6y agoGo was never thought of in that way. Search Google books for "Go chess artificial intelligence computer" and use the 20th century time filter. It was only believed that Go was impervious to the brute-force search strategies employed by the most successful chess programs. The alternative was never "true understanding", but rather believed to be the application of knowledge engineering, expert systems, etc, none of which could be equivocated with "true understanding". Regarding poetry, the counter argument is that a modern neural network can't generate poetry any more than a Xerox machine can generate poetry. IOW, it can only replicate styles, not invent new ones. Though, that's often good enough as far as the vast majority of readers are concerned.
- perl4ever 6y ago>any more than a Xerox machine can generate poetry You assume, but are you sure...? https://www.theregister.com/2013/08/06/xerox_copier_flaw_means_dodgy_numbers_and_dangerous_designs/ https://www.theregister.com/2013/08/06/xerox_copier_flaw_mea...
- perl4ever 6y agoPlaying Go was a big deal because it could be done by a program that started from zero. Did somebody create a program that can write poetry without first consuming basically everything humans have ever written? Or even after consuming roughly what a well-read human might have read? I think it's reasonable to allow for the fact that humans must have a certain amount of information encoded by evolution, but I can't believe it's either qualitatively or quantitatively comparable to a database of all the text on the internet.