5 ms·
It's hard to believe that this would be a cash grab. Even if there are 1M developers in the world, that's only $100M, which should not be worth the friction an
by kelnos 6y ago
It's hard to believe that this would be a cash grab. Even if there are 1M developers in the world, that's only $100M, which should not be worth the friction and cost to implement and maintain this scheme. Consider that Apple's most recent quarterly revenue was just under $60B. Apple made $260B in all of 2019; $100M is not even four hundredths of a percent.
Developer time to build out the signing and notarization features is not free, and running the notarization servers in a highly-available manner is also not free. As much as we all like to call out Apple sometimes for how they don't take good care of their developers, adding hoops for your developers to jump through is not a great idea.
So I think in some ways Apple really does it for the security aspects, and also probably just because Apple likes to maintain rigid control over their experience.
- PandaHug 6y agoNot exactly how it works though, in a corporation as big as Apple each business unit has it's own budget and profit/loss margins. Apple is simply too big and complex for someone or a group of someones to look at it in the way you are describing. So while $100M might not look like a ton to Apple as a hole, it might look like a lot to the business unit responsible for apps on macOS
- saagarjha 6y agoApple is fairly well known to not do P/L this way.
- tauwauwau 6y agoNot going to argue about the profit based motivations, I'm sure someone else would do it. How about the power that it gives Apple over developers, is that worth their time?
- cytzol 6y ago> As much as we all like to call out Apple sometimes for how they don't take good care of their developers, adding hoops for your developers to jump through is not a great idea. Why not? Apple has been pushing very hard lately to increase their 'services' revenue, by getting users to sign up for Apple Music, iCloud, etc. It makes perfect sense for Apple to force developers to jump through hoops, not because it makes the developers' lives worse, but because it gives Apple a leg up! Some examples: • When launching Chrome for the first time, you have to opt-in to Chrome notifications, but macOS pops up its own notification telling you to use Safari instead. • Similarly, Apple News notifications are allowed by default, but you have to explicitly opt-in to notifications from other news websites. • Again, similarly, you'll get Apple Music adverts through push notifications, something that's explicitly disallowed in the App Store guidelines. • System Preferences gets an obnoxious (1) badge next to it, because I haven't signed in to iCloud. I use SyncThing, rather than iCloud Drive. It definitely benefits Apple to waste the SyncThing developers' time and money keeping up with things the iCloud Drive team doesn't need to deal with — do you really think the sort of company that pulls shit like the above would do anything different?
- dwaite 6y ago> • When launching Chrome for the first time, you have to opt-in to Chrome notifications, but macOS pops up its own notification telling you to use Safari instead. Link to a screenshot of this Safari notification when Chrome is run? > Similarly, Apple News notifications are allowed by default, but you have to explicitly opt-in to notifications from other news websites. Reference to an article about this? > • System Preferences gets an obnoxious (1) badge next to it, because I haven't signed in to iCloud. This is something other apps can't display...?
- saagarjha 6y agoNot when Chrome is run, it shows up at some point after you start using your Mac.
- cytzol 6y ago> Link to a screenshot of this Safari notification when Chrome is run? https://danieljwilson.me/2019/10/16/a-catalina-double-standard/ https://danieljwilson.me/2019/10/16/a-catalina-double-standa... > Reference to an article about this? It's this article: https://mjtsai.com/blog/2020/02/17/the-paywalled-garden-ios-is-adware/ https://mjtsai.com/blog/2020/02/17/the-paywalled-garden-ios-... But it's referencing this tweet: https://twitter.com/marcoarment/status/1228431785442381824 https://twitter.com/marcoarment/status/1228431785442381824 > This is something other apps can't display...? You're right, I should have been more specific: it shows the badge even when I don't have System Preferences open, while other apps (such as my chat client, or mail client) only show badges when they're open. It shouldn't show the badge at all, though.
- FreakyT 6y agoOh yeah, this is a great point. I can definitely see it not really being about money, and more about leveraging their monopoly to push their own competing services.
- pier25 6y ago> Even if there are 1M developers in the world There are +20M registered Apple developers. https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/04/app-store-hits-20m-registered-developers-at-100b-in-revenues-500m-visitors-per-week/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/04/app-store-hits-20m-registe...
- danieldk 6y agoThough don't underestimate the number that gets a developer account to get macOS/iOS beta versions. There are public betas now, but the developer portal gets them faster (and more frequently).
- IshKebab 6y agoDoesn't matter why they do it as long as they pay the $100/year surely?
- hutattedonmyarm 6y agoNot all developer accounts are paid though, there's a free tier
- danieldk 6y agoThe money is barely a drop in the bucket for Apple. I was more hinting at that this inflates the number of developers, since a chunk of them are actually people who pay to get early beta access.