27 ms·
Anonymous goes after Sony, makes it personal... very personal
- ascendant 16y agoI think personal attacks like that degrade whatever credibility they gain by fighting for the little guy. Granted people have been prank-ordering pizza's to other people's houses since waaaaay before the Intarwebz, but I'm sure our generation of news-addicted alarmists will send up the flag saying this is why we should give away all of our privacy and freedoms so the government can protect us from bored teenagers.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoFor me this isn't an issue of privacy as much as its an issue of decency. If they released the bank records of these executives and said "these guys are loaded so why are they suing some kid" I wouldn't have a problem with that. But once you graduate to involving their families you cross a line. The only thing that can be accomplished by releasing the names and addresses of someone's spouse and children is to put them in harms way. That harm might just be getting yelled at but it could be much worse. Which puts this act into the category of "threatening someone's family" As someone who agrees with Anonymous on the facts I would only support a small fine for violating someone's privacy. But for involving their family I would support and encourage local governments to send the members of this subsect to jail
- wmf 16y agoI don't agree with Anonymous's tactics, but look at it from their perspective: Corporate executives don't scare easily. What level of threat would convince Sony to change its policy?
- Aaronontheweb 16y agoYou're missing the point - trying to change a companies policies at the price of being decent human beings is worse than whatever offense Sony committed.
- wmf 16y agoGood point; I didn't think of it that way. I never saw Anonymous as particularly honorable.
- jongraehl 16y ago> worse than whatever offense Sony committed This gives the impression that you're making a claim about something you don't have much specific knowledge of. Or that you're absolutely sure that Sony is incapable of offenses larger than a certain magnitude.
- Devilboy 16y agoWhy is this comment being downvoted? He's not being rude or off topic or spammy. Are we dumping on people simply because we disagree with them now?
- haploid 16y agoWell, yes, actually. For quite some time, in fact. I learned the other day that questioning the orthodoxy of the virtue of parenthood is disallowed on HN. Suggesting that having kids is anything other than an amazing accomplishment by capable, intelligent couples is heresy. I have not been on HN that long, but the claims that it is somehow a bastion of pure rational discussion that no other internet forum can reach, appear to be wrong.
- saturn 16y ago> Corporate executives don't scare easily Hm, I deal/have dealt regularly with a number of HNWI in executive roles and I reckon they'd scare easily enough. Acting all tough in the conference room is one thing, getting phone calls at home is quite another. One is "the game", one is real life, completely different. They're not the spetsnaz. Speaking hypothetically and nonjudgementally - phone calls to the wife is an excellent tactic which would get you to the top of the mental agenda instantly in 99% of cases.
- throwawayabcde 16y ago> phone calls to the wife is an excellent tactic which would get you to the top of the mental agenda instantly in 99% of cases. This is a truly disgusting suggestion. I don't have a word for the level of disgust it arouses in me. Also, if I was on the receiving end, it would serve only to harden me, and to become far, far more strident against you and the other kids who are pulling this crap. Would you really want to be facing an angry executive who has the budget to buy not just security and investigators, but also law enforcement, legislators, the media, and anything else that's required to discredit you, and ruin your entire life?
- saturn 16y ago> This is a truly disgusting suggestion. Yeah I know. That's why I tried to qualify it. But speaking honestly, would it work? Yeah. > become far, far more strident against you it's not me OK? I was just trying to dispassionately speculate on what I thought would be effective.
- throwawayabcde 16y ago> would it work? Yeah. Do you really believe that somebody with access to incredible resources is going to get harassed at home and think "well, I should go easier on this fellow, since his internet friends are stalking me and harassing my wife"? Really? If so, I've got a bridge to sell you. This is a horrible idea that can only go badly. Escalation against a well-armed enemy is an incredibly bad strategy. In fact, it's hard to think of a worse strategy.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- DanWeinreb 16y agoI totally agree about the families. That's way, way over the line. IANAL so I don't know whether there are actually laws being broken here, but there might be; freedom of speech in US law has exceptions for threats and putting people into harm and so on. The problem is that it may be hard to find out whom to prosecute; the name "Anonymous" is there for a reason. A lot of very bad things can be done behind a mask of anonymity, just as good things can be (c.f. Tor servers to help dissidents).
- ahi 16y agoFrom my reading of the Ars article, the only thing illegal they did is the ordering of pizzas. Even the digging through his trash is perfectly legal in most jurisdictions. Is what they're doing right? I don't know, but actions have consequences.
- darksaga 16y agoYou might want to read up on the laws regarding digging through trash. If the trash is on your property - it's illegal. Even if its in your driveway waiting for pickup, it's still illegal to go through. Also, In most states dumpster diving at any business is considered a felony.
- ahi 16y agoCitation needed. I tried to figure out which one of us is correct, or at least more correct and this is the best I could do: http://www.opsecprofessionals.org/articles/dumpsterdiving.html http://www.opsecprofessionals.org/articles/dumpsterdiving.ht... As always, depends on state and local ordnances. If you are on private property you can always get hit with trespass, but the actual trash picking is typically legal. Many licensed PIs make their living going through other people's trash. In short, buy a shredder.
- darksaga 16y agoYou are correct in terms of state and local ordinances, and I did do some more research and came up with the landmark case of CALIFORNIA v. GREENWOOD, 486 U.S. 35 (1988) where this very issue was argued before the Supreme Court: http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?court=US&vol=486&invol=35 http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?court=US... It basically says if your trash is visible, you can't assume privacy of the contents. If it's inside your garage, then it's off limits. Interesting case nonetheless.
- tomelders 16y agoSony wouldn't care if their legal proceedings ruined your families lives, directly or indirectly.
- ascendant 16y agoThis is a great point. They're currently devoting millions of dollars to ruining the life of GeoHot, but since they're doing it in a way that's sanctioned by politicians and lawyers, that's "alright".
- hartror 16y agoGeoHot knowingly put himself in harms way, whether the law is just or not in this case his family is not being exposed to vilification and possible harm to their persons. Sony's executives are in a similar situation, through their actions, or actions they support (explicitly or implicitly) they have put themselves in the firing line of Anon. However going after innocent bystanders cannot be justified, on either side. Though I think it is a stretch to say Sony is going after GeoHot's family.
- sudonim 16y agoI have a PS3. If I make modifications to it and talk about those modifications online, is that knowingly putting myself in harms way? Who owns my PS3? And what right does anyone else have to dictate what knowledge I share online about my PS3?
- hartror 16y agoYes. It is knowingly putting yourself in harms way because you know what the law is, whether you agree with it or not. When you take an action as an adult you are accepting the possible consequences of that action. If you punch a mobster in the face and get shot for your trouble every one is going to say "Wow what a brave fellow, he knew what the risks were but he did it anyway". Just like in GeoHot's place he knew what he was doing had risks of getting himself sued or worse, but he chose to do it anyway because he disagreed with the law. You have missed my point however, I agree with the sentiment of what Anon is doing, just not the methods they are using.
- mcantelon 16y ago>I think personal attacks like that degrade whatever credibility they gain by fighting for the little guy. Sony is attempting to create discomfort for Geohot: Anon is returning in kind. It's not about PR.
- Qz 16y agoPeople say this every time Anonymous comes up, and guess what? They don't care. For the most part, the news media doesn't care either. Credibility is becoming an outmoded concept.
- mbesto 16y agoI'm on the fence here. One side of me says, I don't wish this type of personal abuse on anyone. The other side of me says that I don't wish anyone at the age of 21 to be dragged through a ridiculous legal battle that could potentially affect the rest of his life. (debt for life, out of school, jail?) Which is worse? Corporate greed or personal hacking attacks? Anon endorses the same techie progress that allows corporations like Sony, BoA, etc to reach it's mass market on the internet. Corporations like Sony embrace it's ability to use its mass market appeal (and therefore sales) to hire tons of lawyers to protect it's market. Gavels vs. Mice. Who ya got?
- zipdog 16y agoBefore the internet, people were comfortable releasing small amounts of personal data - and so they still release small amounts of personal data (to a florist, into the garbage). One of the issues here is that a few of these pieces of data are like Primary Keys: home address, ssn etc: once you grab these you open up so much else, and there's not too many alternatives to these keys (for those times you actually need them).
- r00fus 16y agoSSN (and possibly home address) are not just primary keys, but super-keys in that they are primary keys across systems and datasets (in general). They may not be immutable as a primary key suggests, but are very hard/costly to change, so the difference is moot. Another reason to not give out your superkeys to anyone who doesn't need it. Finally, though in general I'm in favor of privacy, with the complete lack of corporate accountability, I support the intention behind Anonymous's actions.
- djtumolo 16y agoI dont think this is representative. There have been comparisons made between Anonymous's DDoS and sit-ins. But there was also a more antisocial and violent part of the civil rights movement as well.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoIt's very interesting to see folks rediscover what we always knew: there's a big difference between a group with a purpose and standards and a mob. It used to be that geography contained a lot of mob-like behavior. You might be mad at the guy who lived in the nearby castle, but there were only so many villagers you could round up. And some of those liked the guy, some didn't want trouble, some didn't like your plan, etc. Now the internet lets us find the most emotional people possible about a particular topic and put them all together in one "place". Then people can feed off each's other anger, saying and doing more and more preposterous things in order to impress the group. Information that might challenge the groupspeak is discarded. "Acts of valor" the group commit are spread far and wide, drawing in more members, thereby creating a feedback cycle which encourages more and more dramatic acts. The thing is: the issue doesn't matter. The larger story isn't about Sony, or Anonymous, or any one particular issue. It's about how governments are going to be able to consistently function when the world is breaking up into thousands of little angry groups like this. I have no idea how this is going to play out, or how many kids and families of corporation execs are going to suffer because of things they cannot control. But there will be a backlash. It's building, and I'm concerned that when it happens we are going to see governments step in and take control in ways that are as equally terrible. </doomsaying>
- djtumolo 16y agoYou may be exaggerating. I visited the #opsony room, and at one point they were broadcasting how many LOICs were in operation. Millions? Thousands? No. <100. Less than 100 people in this mob of internet justice. And fewer still doing more nefarious stuff like stalking down execs.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoYes, I am purposely overstating and glossing over certain details, mainly because I'm attempting to extrapolate. Thanks for pointing that out, though. Perhaps if we're lucky (?) tools to monitor and control mobs will evolve faster than tools to communicate and collaborate securely. Anonymous is working at the basest level of security -- just drop by and jump in. I imagine what we'll see soon, what we see already in organized crime, is a combination of better ways of vetting while still integrating to the wider net in order to attract new recruits. As they say in the movies, the night is still young. If we get something with the moral foundation of wikileaks, the activitst appeal of Anonymous, the secure communication system of Tor, and the virality of Facebook? We're going to have problems (once again, I'm overstating for effect) Having said all of that, even if it's only 100 people, and even if it's always 100 people are less, that's a problem. Smaller groups that fly under the radar are more problematic than large noisy ones. How many people did it take to dump all the secure embassy traffic of the United States government?
- analyst74 16y agoOn one side, I think it's great that "important" people who make major decisions take personal responsibilities, instead of hiding behind corporate/government entities; On the other side, this sort of hack-attack could easily go out of hand: what do we do if someone uses this sort of technique for malicious intents?
- r00fus 16y agoWhat if? I'm sure this is already being done, and probably sponsored by governments/corporations. Just because we get visibility into this sort of attack doesn't make it any easier or legal to do.
- blhack 16y agoIsn't this exactly the type of information that Sony was seeking on George Hotz (geohot), as well as anybody who even visited his website?
- Apocryphon 16y agoLast night I watched "The Next Day", a teaser film for the inevitable Tron 3. In it there's a Banksy-type group of hackers called "Flynn Lives" who commit acts of sabotage and mischief specifically against ENCOM. I thought to myself, "That's silly, how could there be an underground activist organization that focuses its efforts on undermining a tech company that, while big and vaguely sinister, doesn't actually seem to have committed any actual evil?" Oh, 4chan, you've proved me wrong again.
- jbermudes 16y agoI think the "evil" that is alleged is that Sony is the type of company that is ruthless enough to do things like installing a rootkit on your machine to ensure that its copyrights are not infringed.
- xsmasher 16y agoSony has sued to shut down geohot and obtain the IP addresses of all visitors. They obtained a TRO that prevents him from distributing information about the exploit and which hands his hardware over to Sony. That's more than vaguely sinister, and is arguably an actual evil.
- wladimir 16y agoYes. If there is any tech company that is 'evil' at the moment it's Sony. I don't agree with every action that Anonymous does, but honestly I hope Sony gets their due like HBGary did.
- Jach 16y ago"I quarrel not with far-off foes, but with those who, near at home, co-operate with, and do the bidding of, those far away, and without whom the latter would be harmless." ~Thoreau Before condemning I'll wait to see what is done with this information. If someone dies, that'll be the end of it, but don't freak out over pizza deliveries. I've been waiting for Anon to start endorsing violence, so far they haven't.
- ImprovedSilence 16y agoMy only complaint about Anonymous is... Who watches the watchmen?
- mcantelon 16y agoState intel and law enforcement agencies.
- iwwr 16y agoThis doesn't answer the question.
- mcantelon 16y agoSo state intel and law enforcement agencies don't watch groups like Anon?
- radioactive21 16y agoThe FBI mostly has been watching, but not directly involved because so far, for what they've done it's not worth the resources and money to go after. The FBI could go after anonymous but the cost and time would be so high eventually you're gonna tell yourself, we just wasted a lot of tax payer money chasing a bunch of kid pranks. That is unless Anon does something stupid to invoke massive public anger.
- darksaga 16y agoI'm pretty sure the FBI and most likely CIA are already tracking these guys and building cases on them as we speak. They've broken enough laws in enough countries to go after them. You'd be pretty surprised how much money is available to these agencies and task forces to infiltrate, track and bring down these guys. I figure its only a matter of time before they get at them.
- jrspruitt 16y agoThis is the kind of stuff I think will cause more damage, than do any good. Yeah ordering pizza's is funny, but when you start digging into someones family, I think it goes over the line. This is something criminal thugs would do. This isn't going to do their cause's PR any good at all, which perhaps I'm wrong, that their goal is to help support the "little guy" against the "big powers", to accomplish that, its best to get the support of the people, to expose corruption, not threaten people like this. Which, when this goes to national news, its going to look really bad. Not to mention, this is stalker grade stuff, which that freaks me out for some reason, I imagine socially dysfunctional people, looking for some attention sitting around thinking, Anonymous is doing it, people like them, I know... I'm going to go do something completely insane so people will like me. These sort of tactics can easily blow up in their faces, perception of the people is everything these days, stuff like this can make it real easy to look really bad.
- waqf 16y agoAhem, they tried to censor Stringer's personal information but they left the ZIP+9. You can get at least the address of the apartment block from that.
- whakojacko 16y agoNot specifically related to this article but Id like to give Ars major props for following all of the recent Anonymous actions so throughly. Their articles on HBGary were fantastic and they seem to be keeping up well.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- radioactive21 16y agoI am for trying to poke at someone, but to me the line is drawn at family and kids. Anonymous themselves might not do it, but lets say they make information about the kids public and some weird psycho uses that in a bad way. Just takes one incident involving a child and the public out lash could be severe.
- AlfaWolph 16y agoIt reminds me of Fight Club a little.
- jc123 16y agoPublic information + Social Engineering + Willpower = Zero Privacy
- EGreg 16y agoWhere are these chats between anonymous taking place? How are people getting the chat logs? I haven't seen anyone talk about this.
- yummybear 16y agoThis is not cool - harrasing the man's wife, investigating the "schools their children attend". If you need to go after Sony the cooporation or the CEO, do so when they assume that role, but stay away from family and personal business.
- temphn 16y agoOk, now we're talking lulz. Tracking people's children? All's fair, I guess. But taking down the PlayStation Network, well...that's over the line. > "Anonymous is not attacking the PSN at this time," said the document. "Sony's official position is that the PSN is undergoing maintenance. We realize that targeting the PSN is not a good idea. We have therefore temporarily suspended our action, until a method is found that will not severely impact Sony customers. Anonymous is on your side, standing up for your rights. We are not aiming to attack customers of Sony. This attack is aimed solely at Sony, and we will try our best to not affect the gamers, as this would defeat the purpose of our actions. If we did inconvenience users, please know that this was not our goal."
- drstrangevibes 16y agoapparently the "kids" are older than geohot