6 ms·
This reminds me of the DR (Denmarks Radio - which is also a Public TV sort of like the BBC) license, you used to have to pay it for TV. I didn't have a tv so I
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
This reminds me of the DR (Denmarks Radio - which is also a Public TV sort of like the BBC) license, you used to have to pay it for TV. I didn't have a tv so I stopped paying. Then a year or two later they passed a law that if you had a computer you had to pay.
I guess lots of European countries have a similar license.
They are phasing the license out in the next couple years, but it used to really piss me off because I never watched anything on DR but I still had to pay for it (ok I did accidentally see things if I was over at people's houses, it was nothing impressive). The assumption being of course that it was a public good.
Anyway - sub-regional pricing for Netflix etc.
- undreren 6y agoI just wanted it to be financed through taxes as it used to be. It was completely ridiculous; after switching to a licensing model, DR’s costs for raking in money went up by about 15 million DKK just in fees to lawyers, if memory serves correctly.
- stkdump 6y agoWe have the same scheme in Germany. The reason given for the fee vs. taxes I think is the independence of public broadcasting from the government. Imagine a bully as the head of government that can threaten to defund public broadcasting, if it doesn't report favorably for him.
- te_chris 6y agoThis is what's happening in Australia to the ABC right now.
- Mirioron 6y agoDoesn't the parliament set spending? And if you're worried about the parliament not funding it, then why wouldn't you be worried about parliament just changing the law that set up the public broadcaster in the first place?
- ketzu 6y agoOne reason might be that it's much easier to take a law changing the structure of the public broadcasting financing infront of the supreme court than it is to do so with regular budgeting.
- stkdump 6y agoIt isn't so simple. I think the federal government/parliament has to agree with the 16 state governments or so. There is a so called 'Rundfunkstaatsvertrag' (a treaty between states) governing the rules.
- mercora 6y agoive always thought this is a very moot argument. if the government decides to remove their backing from this scheme they still can. it really should be a tax, dependent on income. this whole apparatus for hunting people costs millions for nothing really...
- patates 6y agoYes, the question is (and I won't pretend to know the answer), do the people have the need to be forced to pay to have independent journalism? Is there any country in the world, where free press works just as a product of a free market? I'm living in Germany and I'm not super happy about the TV tax but I suppose we haven't got a better solution.
- lordlimecat 6y agoReuters does a pretty good job.
- stkdump 6y agoI think there are good examples, where the press operating in a free market can give good results. But the more important question is, if it is equal or better at its worst (which is exactly, when this is important). Having a mix between private free press and publicly funded broadcasting probably creates some balance between the two worlds. I would expect the quality of the private press to decline (further), if we wouldn't have public broadcasting anymore.
- undreren 6y agoWell, in Denmark, government officials are part of the board of directors, so it's not independent either way.
- seventh-chord 6y agoNorway switched back to a tax-based model this year, where everybody above a certain income gets deducted between 150€ and 300€ more yearly. The cost to the average person went down, I assume that is mostly because there will be more total payers now. They also closed a 70-people office previously responsible for collecting the license fee.
- hkmurakami 6y agoNHK in Japan has a similar scheme. If you have a TV you have to pay. If you have a phone that can receive TV signal, you have to pay. They'd even send people in person to "check if you have a TV". I believe they recently lost a court case on this.
- predakanga 6y agoIn Britain, the BBC uses vehicles fitted with equipment to detect TVs, though who knows how effective they are. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TV_detector_van https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TV_detector_van
- cheerlessbog 6y agoIt's unclear they even exist..or work..our could even theoretically work now we have digital. Their true enforcement strategy is to harass the small minority who don't pay the license fee.
- UK-Al05 6y agoFor young people it's not a small minority. Young people have gone off transmitted TV and they havent adapted yet.
- toyg 6y agoThey have started to - they extended the relevant law to close loopholes about “real time” vs “prerecorded” BBC broadcasts, now you need a licence if you use the iPlayer for anything. Which is fair, even if it forced me to get a license again. I expect at some point the law will either get more draconian (by requiring a license for any broadband contract at home) or the BBC will become an actual streaming service like Netflix, with regular subscription (which would be a bit of a disaster, since it would basically mean the end of the BBC as we know it).
- UK-Al05 6y ago
- aikah 6y agoYeah, France has the "redevance télé". You have to explicitly refuse any cable service from your ISP in order not to pay it. Otherwise you're screwed. And its cost is significant, I will never pay for such thing.
- Thervicarl 6y ago> You have to explicitly refuse any cable service from your ISP in order not to pay it Legally, you have to pay if you have a television in you home and you are subject to paying the residence tax (which will soon be applicable to less than 20% of homes anyway). > And it's significant No, it's not. It's like less than 0.5% of the tax you are paying (considering income tax, social tax, residence/homeowning tax, VAT...). They just keep it because they can rile up /distract people when they increase the TV tax by 5 euros. And it is a way for the government to pressure public TV/radio into some obedience (since the government can basically cut a large part of their funding of these TV/radio by removing this tax).
- aikah 6y ago> No, it's not. It's like less than 0.5% of the tax you are paying (considering income tax, social tax, residence/homeowning tax, VAT...). They just keep it because they can rile up /distract people when they increase the TV tax by 5 euros. You don't know my income,monthly expenses, how many kids I have to feed, whether I have a mortgage, an alimony to pay or not... You have no idea what my budget is. So less than 0.5% of what disposable income I have exactly? Tell me. I'm not paying a flat tax (the tax doesn't depend on household income as you are insinuating) for something I have no use for at first place.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoFor context, it's 138€/year.
- Legogris 6y agoIn Swedish 90s, there was a public information campaign series with vigilante kids putting a snail on the eye of people who don't pay their TV license. I think everyone who was around then recognize the reference "Do you want a snail on your eye?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK0R-N0w8-Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yK0R-N0w8-Q
- deanclatworthy 6y agoIn Finland there is a media tax that is taken out of everyone's salary. I don't think it's optional. I've never paid close enough attention to care. I think it subsidises our state broadcaster YLE and perhaps some other things. Maybe a Finn can chip in and explain... > The public broadcasting tax, also known as the Yle tax, replaced the license fee in 2013. The tax ranges from 50 euros to 140 euros per person and per year, depending on income. Minors and persons with low income are exempt from the tax. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yle#:~:text=Yle%20tax,-Main%20article%3A%20Yle&text=Until%20the%20end%20of%202012,euros%20per%20year%20in%202012.&text=The%20public%20broadcasting%20tax%2C%20also,the%20license%20fee%20in%202013 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yle#:~:text=Yle%20tax,-Main%20....
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoBecause of the shift in how people use TV and public access channels, in the Netherlands they simplified the whole scheme, got rid of the TV license entirely and just pay the public broadcasters through the regular state budget - e.g. "regular" taxes. It just saves a ton of headaches and complexity. I'm not "smol government" or whatever, but I do think laws and the like can be simplified by a lot. In a similar vein, they simplified tax brackets for last year, instead of four brackets, there's now just two, and most people ended up paying less taxes (see https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/belastingplan/belastingwijzigingen-voor-ons-allemaal/tweeschijvenstelsel-inkomstenbelasting https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/belastingplan/belas... for an infographic; keep in mind that while the lowest incomes do pay a little more taxes, they also get more money back from the government in stipends and subsidies for e.g. rent, health insurance, and a fixed 'discount' on taxes)
- rocqua 6y agoNote, before the tax change we had 3 brackets, not 4. Also note: technically we have, and have always had 4 brackets. They just merged the tax brackets by setting limits and rates weirdly.
- woadwarrior01 6y agoThat is still the case in Ireland. It’s called a TV license. It’s an annual fee, that you have to pay as long as you have a TV, regardless of whether you use it for watching terrestrial TV or not. They even have a crew of inspectors who go around randomly knocking on doors to check if people are paying it.
- bebna 6y agoGermany had TV or Radio, (every car got a radio...). Today it is per household, independent what you own. As a student, unemployed or otherwise paid from the state it isn't a problem, you let them pay it. But if you are single, you have to pay the 210€/yr on your own.
- snorremd 6y agoUp until two or three years ago or so we used to have to pay a public TV license for the public TV and radio broadcaster in Norway if we had a TV or tuner capable of receiving TV signals. Some people just opted to not having TVs or disabling any receiver capabilities. Then they simply moved the collection of the license to your taxes so you don't see it explicitly, and of course now it does not matter if you don't have a TV. Everyone pays the TV tax regardless, but it is somewhat progressive with low income residents paying somewhat less than higher income ones. I don't really mind paying for the public broadcaster as they serve as a guarantee for public, independent news. What does annoy me is that they compete for the rights to broadcast super expensive sports and culture events (olympics, various football leagues, eurovision, etc). This greatly increases their budgets while not providing essential news value to the public not equally well served by private media broadcasters. Some of their own tv-series productions are well made and would not get the green light at private broadcasters and channels, so I would rather they focus on those.
- srg0 6y agoIn Italy the TV tax is now auto-included in the facilities bill. You have to explicitly declare that you don't have a TV and repeat it each year.