3 ms·
>I recently came across the article by Paul Graham on modelling a wealth tax. Where with simple mathematics of Geometric progression he makes the case against w
by coldtea 6y ago
>I recently came across the article by Paul Graham on modelling a wealth tax. Where with simple mathematics of Geometric progression he makes the case against wealth tax because in about 60 years nearly half of your wealth will go to the big bad government.
Well, that would be a red flag in PG's argument already. Who said it's bad for your wealth to go to the govenment (assuming you still have wealth to spare and take care of all your needs and even your grandchildren up to 3-4 generations, as this is about big wealth)?
In a normal country, the governmnet is not some enemy, it's the public pool of resources and planning public goods/policy/infrastructure/protection/etc for a country.
If on the other hand live somewhere where the government is an enemy, then you have bigger problems than part of your wealth going to them, and you should fix those first, not the tax.
- dantheman 6y agoGovernments have killed more people than anyone else in the 20th century. What are your thoughts on the wars the US is currently fighting? Why not pool all resources, and let there government handle everything?
- refulgentis 6y agoHaving collective resources doesn't imply killing people, war, or collectivizing everything. Maybe it could fund the 2008 and 2020 corporate socialism
- lliamander 6y ago> Well, that would be a red flag in PG's argument already. Who said it's bad for your wealth to go to the govenment PG didn't say it was bad. That was a motive imputed erroneously by this author. He simply provided a model of how much it would cost, and what people might do in response to that cost.