3 ms·
> You can't just plop down a fully-furnished city on some unpopulated plot of land and expect anyone to move there. China as you say is trying this, but some of
by vkou 6y ago
> You can't just plop down a fully-furnished city on some unpopulated plot of land and expect anyone to move there. China as you say is trying this, but some of these are basically ghost towns on arrival, despite the massive top-down planning and investment. [1]
They are ghost towns on arrival for two reasons.
1. The employer base (say, government ministries) have not yet moved out of their current locations into the newly built cities. They are planned to in the future - and many former ghost cities are now bustling.
2. China has hundreds of millions of people who are trying to stop being subsistence farmers, and urbanize. It's an absolutely unprecedented demographic shift, anywhere in the world. This is a proactive solution for dealing with what would otherwise be the world's biggest housing crunch.
- CarbyAu 6y agoI disagree with China Authoritarianism and it's heavy handed social approach and they surely get a lot of things wrong in engineering and suburban planning too. But the scale China works at is mind boggling and I couldn't hope to say I could "build a city" better.
- tomcam 6y ago> I couldn't hope to say I could "build a city" better. Because you would probably never make the same trade-offs they do. In the USA we are a little cavalier about eminent domain. In China, the practices go beyond brutal and straight to the inhumane. They will happily displace entire villages to get the job done, and they don’t worry too much about the details of where people end up or how they get compensated. They also make choices that would be baffling here in the west. For example, they frequently do absolutely nothing to maintain new developments, and often those developments are of unbelievably low quality. With in a year or two, many of them look like they have been crumbling for decades. Source: Asian family, real estate investments in China.
- CarbyAu 6y agoYeah, the authoritarian method is brutal beyond compare. But it does let them "get shit done." Building the pyramids and the great wall and many other "wonders" took literally slave labor for multiple lifetimes and yet somehow people still admire these "achievements". (They have lasted however!) They need a city, or ten. Not an outhouse. There is no way to build a city and make everyone happy. Do I think they do it best? No, obviously not. But the Western world would be bogged down in NIMBYism while the chinese engineered cities are built and done. As for quality... I saw a few things on my holiday trip to China many years ago so I don't doubt poor quality is a thing. But here in Australia any high rise apartment building built in the past ten years in Sydney or Melbourne is now suspect due to dodgy building practices too. Maybe the building is fine. Maybe it isn't. But they are all tainted with suspicion. So while I think the Western world still has the edge on China in quality, it is a slippery slope when "homes" are in a market to "make money" rather than "house people".
- redis_mlc 6y ago> They are ghost towns The ghost towns featured several years ago in US documentaries were sold and occupied, and more have been built, but the real problem isn't oversupply: 1) the units require the buyer to redo the electricity and plumbing before they're habitable, and they're faced with twine that is painted like bricks. Selling unrepaired units involves negotiating who will pay for the repairs, which causes a lot of friction. Bribes are paid with units, so a local builder might title 100 units in a multi-building complex to the governor. 2) building codes aren't followed and the concept of HoA fees never developed, so the buildings only look good for about 6 months, then the pools are turned off, the elevators start free-falling, the lobby ceiling tiles fall on residents, balcony railings fall over when touched, etc. Two balconies fall off residential building in NE China (no rebar) (2015) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PDJJIlszVxI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PDJJIlszVxI 3) There's a property bubble, probably the largest in history, creating most of the reported recent wealth in China. The inflation in large urban cores can be justified compared to other regional cities, but not in the ghost towns.