4 ms·
It's important to note that you can still run unsigned Mac apps. Apple isn't preventing users from running a tool they want to run, it's just showing them a big
by brundolf 6y ago
It's important to note that you can still run unsigned Mac apps. Apple isn't preventing users from running a tool they want to run, it's just showing them a big scary warning and making them jump through some extra hoops.
It's incredibly scummy and inappropriate, but I would put it more along the lines of an attack-ad than an outright ban.
Edit: Now, one thing that isn't totally clear is whether or not devs who have their own developer accounts, and use Unreal Engine to target iOS, can still make iOS builds. If not that's a much bigger deal, though the fundamental issue would still lie with iOS, not macOS.
- babaganoosh89 6y agoNotarizing has been mandatory since Catalina: https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=09032019a https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=09032019a
- brundolf 6y agoYou can bypass it: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202491 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202491
- grishka 6y agoYou can also disable AMFI, the component that enforces signatures and entitlements, altogether, but you have first to disable SIP completely by either booting into Linux of by patching the kernel and then setting the requisite NVRAM variable directly. (`spctl` does not, in fact, disable it completely.)
- VectorLock 6y ago>by either booting into Linux I don't think thats an option on newer MacBook Pros any more.
- my123 6y agoYou don't need to do it that way. Boot to macOS Recovery and use csrutil(1) to disable SIP.
- grishka 6y agoSorry, I mixed up spctl and csrutil. SIP state is stored in an NVRAM variable that is a bitfield of what is allowed. You can't change all bits with csrutil, and you can't set the variable from within macOS, both main and recovery. You have to bypass that mechanism by either patching the macOS kernel to allow setting whatever you want, or booting into an OS that doesn't perform these checks in the first place. And you need to set the bit for IIRC kernel debugging for it to honor the `amfi_get_out_of_my_way` argument.
- saagarjha 6y agoI am not sure if you can flip the bits in the NVRAM variable, but you can disable SIP from recovery mode including the flag for kernel debugging.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoThe pop-up box you get when you try to run unsigned applications gives the user absolutely no hint as to how they can jump through those hoops to run the thing. You need to know what to google for to find the right magic incantation to enter into the macOS terminal. On Windows, at least, the “Run anyway” button is merely behind the “More information...” link.
- brundolf 6y agoRight. I'm just saying, user-freedom is technically preserved. This is a huge inconvenience, and bad for Epic's business, but it's not a ban. As an owner of Mac hardware, I still have control over what I can do with my machine.
- jonplackett 6y agoThe point is though that they have the ability to 'ban' it for 99.99% of users who don't know that.
- brundolf 6y agoThis isn't a social app, it's a professional tool that multimillion-dollar businesses are built on (most of which have in-house engine programmers). They'll figure it out if they have to. Heck, Epic could publish instructions for doing so.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoUnreal Engine isn’t a shared iOS component. Apple doesn’t care about signatures on individual lib/so files: only the signature on the published app package. When you make an app or a game using an existing engine then only you become responsible for it. A ragtag band of devs all banned-for-life from Apple’s stores could put together a new app-engine or game-engine that other devs use as the basis for their app and provided that those apps don’t break the rules about undocumented APIs or malware (and no-one in Apple’s higher-ups gets suspicious...) then those apps will appear. I don’t believe Apple has any way to automatically ban or delete all apps that use the same third-party libraries by using their macOS Notary system or iOS Certificate revocation system - they’d have to inspect every published app-package individually (granted, this would be automated, but you know what I mean).
- oscargrouch 6y agoThis sounds like a 'deprecation tatics' to me. You use a pavlovian adequation mechanism on your users for some time, labeling as "dangerous", until you completely ban the thing. By then users wont miss. I´ve never used anything Apple by this same reason. Apple seems to think that once you by one of their products, they own you. Its not just inappropriate, for me its pretty scary and humiliating. Its like that girlfriend or boyfriend who thinks it owns you, and want to say what you should dress or if you can hangout with our friends. It dont get it how people can be ok with this kind of stuff (as this is just one example) and later just say it snarkly as if it was your kid being naughty, where actually it can have severe consequences if they can get away with it, and future generations wont even argue because its already normalized for them.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoIMO, it’s about the moral equivalent of using dark UI patterns to trick users into performing actions they don’t want to do. The scary warning and convoluted workaround for running un–notarized apps is ostensibly to prevent non–technical people from compromising their computers. Now Apple is abusing that security mechanism for Business Reasons that have nothing to do with protecting users. The fact that users can technically bypass it is a weak defense; if it’s an effective way to stop malware, it’s probably an effective way to prevent people from running Unreal Engine games as well.
- ptx 6y agoThis is completely off-topic, but isn't the regular hyphen what you want in "non-technical"? I don't think the en-dash is correct.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- squiggleblaz 6y ago> if it’s an effective way to stop malware, it’s probably an effective way to prevent people from running Unreal Engine games as well. Probably only one or the other. If Epic produces legitimate software that users have a legitimate reason to run, some of them will become accustomed to clicking through in order to run a legitimate program. Then, they will become more likely to click through on other programs: "Oh, they're probably banned for business reasons like Epic, not for security reasons like malware". Apple is clearly hoping that is not the outcome, and that Epic simply loses as close to 100% of their Apple-based customers as they reasonably can.
- laurent92 6y agoApple, with code-signing signalling, will actively be telling users Fortnite is a security danger. It is not the same as code signing, which would be vendor-agnostic and politically neutral. I would be surprised if the European Commission does trigger an inquiry into abuse of dominant position.
- benhurmarcel 6y ago> Apple, with code-signing signalling, will actively be telling users Fortnite is a security danger. Sounds like Apple will rather teach young consumers to ignore security warnings.
- mthoms 6y agoAccording to the court filing, Apple is denying Epic access to any development tools, software betas, APIs and the like. Epic will not be able to keep Unreal Engine up to date. Including on MacOS. The end result will be that Unreal Engine, and all applications developed with it will be dead in the water on MacOS/iOS/iPadOS. From the the legal filing: >... when Epic sued Apple to break its monopoly on app stores and in-app payments, Apple retaliated ferociously. It told Epic that by August 28, Apple will cut off Epic’s access to all development tools necessary to create software for Apple’s platforms—including for the Unreal Engine Epic offers to third-party developers, which Apple has never claimed violated any Apple policy. Not content simply to remove Fortnite from the App Store, Apple is attacking Epic’s entire business in unrelated areas. and... >Apple stated that unless Epic capitulates, Apple will also block “[e]ngineering efforts to improve hardware and software performance of Unreal Engine on Mac and iOS hardware [and] optimize Unreal Engine for the Mac for creative workflows”. PDF link: https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-v-apple-8-17-20-768927327.pdf https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-v-apple-8-17-20-768927327...
- iphone_elegance 6y agoin catalina it's a total pain now, I stopped using a lot of software because of it
- cageface 6y agoWeaning myself off Macs has been on my to-do list for the last year. It just moved up to top position.