7 ms·
I have a flight tracking app for my phone and see aircraft flying in circles over where I live all the time. Dozens and dozens of times each day. They're peop
by reaperducer 6y ago
I have a flight tracking app for my phone and see aircraft flying in circles over where I live all the time. Dozens and dozens of times each day.
They're people in small planes practicing.
Also, I live near several military bases. The interesting and loud stuff that I see flying by out my window NEVER shows up on any app. I expect this web site is similarly, deliberately, incomplete.
- rhacker 6y agoEveryone that plans on moving somewhere should do 1 of 2 things: 1. Not move there because of flight training schools. 2. Lobby to get the flight training school to practice over unpopulated areas.
- punnerud 6y agoOr live close to a prison or other place with restricted area
- NikolaNovak 6y ago#2 Doesn't seem feasible for large portions of the world though. I did some flight lessons in rural Manitoba. You got ~45 minutes of flight training for every hour you paid for. Then I considered restarting them once I moved to Toronto... you get about 20, 25 min of training for every paid hour - the rest is just getting out of restricted space. If you wanted to head to actual "unpopulated area", I think you'd need to book a 3 hour lesson in order to get any actual training. Completely unfeasible. And this is in Canada, a famously sparsely populated nation. It feels even less feasible for majority of more densely populated countries. (basically, by definition, if you only allow flight training in the unpopulated boonies, you'd deny it to a very large super-majority of population. One may view that in positive or negative light, of course)
- ysavir 6y ago> If you wanted to head to actual "unpopulated area", I think you'd need to book a 3 hour lesson in order to get any actual training. Completely unfeasible. Why is this unfeasible?
- dylan604 6y agoUnaffordable might be another word. Rental on the plane per hour, fuel for the flight, fees for the instructor etc are all not known for being cheap.
- NikolaNovak 6y agoIt's not impossible. It's unfeasible. Paying 3 hours of very expensive flight training to obtain 30min of actual flight instruction should be unfeasible at plain sight, but fair enough - the next level of detail is "makes it unaffordable, impractical, and is a strong deterrent for vast majority of interested parties".
- rory096 6y ago>2. Lobby to get the flight training school to practice over unpopulated areas. This is fairly typical — even in urban centers there's typically one or more "training areas" for students to practice maneuvers. e.g. in New York: https://i.imgur.com/Djum5pX.png https://i.imgur.com/Djum5pX.png
- beamatronic 6y agoTry OpenADSB?
- Scoundreller 6y agoI think the issue is that military is permitted to fly without broadcasting anything, but the airspace is restricted to avoid civilian collisions. Or maybe de-facto clear by staying in high enough altitudes? I have seen some military aircraft light up while practicing refueling over the pacific, but go dark when leaving or returning to base.
- zymhan 6y agoOpenADSB and ADSBExchange will definitely give you a better view of any military and private planes broadcasting ADSB.
- revicon 6y agoThe web map is entertaining to watch https://tar1090.adsbexchange.com/ https://tar1090.adsbexchange.com/
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoIt's also good for making abstract art: https://postimg.cc/vgG3PyW4 https://postimg.cc/vgG3PyW4
- jcrawfordor 6y agoAs a current student pilot, I have been doing a whole lot of circling. Hope no one thinks I'm the FBI in a ratty old C172. :) When it comes to military aircraft, the situation there is kind of interesting. There's no general exception for the military, military aircraft are generally "required" to transmit ADS-B unless they have a specific reason not to (and I believe this requires authorization from somewhere up the chain of command). I put "required" in scare quotes though as many military aircraft are simply not equipped... the DoD has drug its feet on installing ADS-B out and the FAA has basically relented by setting very lax objectives. FAA requested DoD to have ADS-B installed on 21% of aircraft by the first of this year and I believe they met that goal... but it's still less than a quarter. Over time more and more military aircraft should be appearing in ADS-B data, but I suspect it's going to be some years before it's almost all of them.
- repiret 6y ago> Hope no one thinks I'm the FBI in a ratty old C172 C172 and C182 both make fine planes for running surveillance. They're inexpensive (to buy and operate), reliable, inconspicuous, and have enough space and useful load to tack on specialized equipment. I used to own a 182 that was originally owned by the Washington State Police. While in WSP service, it was modified to have an automotive-style muffler for "stealth" surveillance.
- jcrawfordor 6y agoYeah, I'm largely joking here, as I've seen a C172 in livery of the state police here before, and I don't think it was a new one either. The cops have payments to make too.
- kitteh 6y ago206s seems to be the most popular out there. Plenty of room in the back for the surveillance gear and there's a few companies that cater to fitting in all the gear in there (FLIR/TV tracking pod, additional radio gear etc.). The step up are the B1900s that CBP has which have additional sensor capabilities.
- nja 6y ago> I expect this web site is similarly, deliberately, incomplete. Perhaps less incomplete than you think (and certainly more complete than the standard tracking websites, which outside of hiding planes also must honor a 5-minute data delay requested by the FAA). The advisory circular bots the author runs link to https://tar1090.adsbexchange.com/ https://tar1090.adsbexchange.com/ , which is run from a home-grown network of SDRs. It makes a point of not hiding anything that reports its position with ADS-B -- which all aircraft (over a certain size) must report by law. I've even seen Air Force One and its escorts on this service, something that is always absent from other flight tracking services.
- jakub_g 6y ago> 5-minute data delay requested by the FAA Can you expand on this for the noobs in the subject?
- dmitrygr 6y agoso you cannot trivially go hit something with a ground-to-air missile. why the downvotes? this was the actual stated reason when this was requested
- toomuchtodo 6y agoWhich is silly, because ground-to-air ordinance could just listen on ADS-B RF itself for the target (you too can listen in with a software defined radio if you're in the vicinity or have gear that can listen in the area). It's security theater, not an actual mitigation against a threat actor with access to an anti aircraft weapon. For anything not broadcasting ADS-B, you can use multilateration (time difference of arrival) to determine positioning of dumb transponders. Flightaware does this [1]. [1] https://flightaware.com/adsb/mlat/ https://flightaware.com/adsb/mlat/
- jaywalk 6y agoUmm, well, there is this issue that you can actually see the plane without a delay, so...
- minitoar 6y agoThis uses ads b exchange so it shows a lot more than eg flightradar or radarbox.
- Shivetya 6y agoWhich app? Are there several? If so what was the key features you were looking for?
- sandworm101 6y ago>> The interesting and loud stuff that I see flying by out my window NEVER shows up on any app. The slightly interesting stuff doesn't show up, the loud jets, but the really interesting stuff does. CIA rendition flights, police spying on protests, Air Force One, rich people flagrantly violating COVID rules ... they all squawk ADS-B.
- NotSammyHagar 6y agoI thought we/the usa stopped kidnapping people and torturing them with Bush2 leaving office. Is that not true? Any recent cases? I am aware we still keep people in Guantanamo and Obama and trump order the murder of people. But secret kidnapping was over I hoped. Maybe the next pres will stop extra-judicial killings?
- rootusrootus 6y agoAnybody halfway intelligent blocks the details that would otherwise be available with ADS-B, so the best you can do is see they exist, not identify the aircraft. This is often the case with corporate jets.
- llacb47 6y agoNo, you can identify it on adsb-exchange. Sounds like you've been using flightaware/rb24/flightradar24 - they block aircrafts. https://tar1090.adsbexchange.com/ https://tar1090.adsbexchange.com/
- sokoloff 6y agoYou can buy a Dotcom call sign subscription and fly your flights (including ADS-B ID) under a randomly assigned Dotcom callsign. So, instead of being trackable N123AB, I could fly as DCM965. You could still potentially trace approximately where the aircraft flew (because there aren’t quite enough DCM flights for real anonymity), but it’s more work. https://flttrack.fltplan.com/FltPlanInfo/DCMCallSigns.htm https://flttrack.fltplan.com/FltPlanInfo/DCMCallSigns.htm
- jmwilson 6y agoTechnical details are described here: https://gitlab.com/jjwiseman/advisory-circular/ https://gitlab.com/jjwiseman/advisory-circular/ Things flying near an airport are excluded ("The centroid of the last 3 minutes worth of positions must be more than 2.5 km away from all known airports."). I've never seen it tweet about planes doing obvious pattern practice.
- jjwiseman 6y agoIt used to do a pretty good job of filter out pattern practice, but lately I feel like those false positives have actually become the #1 issue (maybe because my code was tuned for and worked fine around LA, but not other parts of the world). I'm working on some slightly fancier filtering to remove those.
- bonestamp2 6y agoIf you're on iOS you want the "OpenADSB" app. I think I paid $10 for it but it's awesome. It doesn't filter out the military planes like FlightRadar24 does. But, sometimes FlightRadar24 has data that OpenADSB doesn't have, so both are still useful. A few weeks ago I was watching an F-35 off the coast of Southern California... so cool to see that stuff. It seems to also pick up weather balloons (or some kind of balloons that are above 60,000ft). Anyway, it's fun to see what's out there.
- larrywright 6y agoI saw a U-2 spy plane a few weeks ago, flying over the SW US. I’ve seen a B-52 as well.
- sbisson 6y agoIt used ADSBExchange as a data source.
- WrongThinkerNo5 6y agoI'm not sure you are totally correct, even though I would agree that some of the stuff he lists as part of the linked revelations about the aerial surveillance programs run by various FBI and DHS organizations, is not at really as nefarious as he makes it may seem … at least not yet. The reason that you will likely not see certain military flights report on any flight tracking systems is that you are likely close to special military use airspace. Other times when military air vehicles are traversing space, they are also flying in special aerial corridors reserved for that purpose and under military flight control. It's not the military that any of this would involve. Something that will become more of an issue is that rather advanced UAVs have been authorized for use domestically now too, likely precisely because of the discovery of these types of aerial surveillance operations. They would be operating at altitudes that are also special use and would therefore also be flying blind, i.e., not signaling. That said, these types of operations would be for the surveillance of far more interesting people than you likely are, i.e., hispanic cartel operators and leaders living in the USA, terrorists, both muslim and likely increasingly leftist, etc. These are not surveillance programs that would be following you after running a red light. Unfortunately, the relatively low altitude aerial surveillance programs using eye in the sky type technology are actually very good crime solving tools because they allow for backtracking or even following perpetrators after the fact. Unfortunately too, as with most major technology transitions like the one we are going though, they will likely have to be grossly abused and misused before people wake up and realize the utter destruction they cause requires controlling them, e.g., nuclear weapons, chem/bio weapons, fire/carpet bombing, etc. And we are unfortunately nowhere near a necessary number of people realizing the awful potential of the abuses being and which will still be perpetrated.
- mysterydip 6y agoApps usually rely on ADS-B data, rather than IFF. US military planes to my knowledge don't use ADS-B.
- larrywright 6y agoThey may not use it for anything, but I think they’re all able to broadcast it.
- mysterydip 6y agoThere was an initiative to have all of them able to by Jan 2020 but didn't address the security flaws of allowing anyone access to that information: https://www.c4isrnet.com/air/2018/01/25/gao-fix-security-flaws-or-anyone-will-be-able-to-track-a-f-22/ https://www.c4isrnet.com/air/2018/01/25/gao-fix-security-fla... I know mode 5 is supposed to be a crypto version of ADS-B but not sure how many implement it https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identification_friend_or_foe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identification_friend_or_foe
- sokoloff 6y agoIt’s closer to 25% than 100% for ADS-B out equipage in the DoD fleet. https://www.aviationtoday.com/2019/08/19/military-2936-aircraft-ads-b-jan-1-air-force-says/ https://www.aviationtoday.com/2019/08/19/military-2936-aircr...
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoHave you tried https://tar1090.adsbexchange.com/ https://tar1090.adsbexchange.com/ ? Don't know if there is an "app", but regarding the interesting stuff, it's the most complete, IMO/E.
- AviationAtom 6y agoThat's where the app sources it's data. If the military planes do not turn on their transponders then they can only be picked up on radar. https://gitlab.com/jjwiseman/advisory-circular/ https://gitlab.com/jjwiseman/advisory-circular/
- larrywright 6y agoThere’s a great app on iOS called OpenADSB. It’s not free, but worth the price. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/openadsb/id1178703539 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/openadsb/id1178703539
- throwanem 6y agoI live in Baltimore. The GA aircraft you see circling over my town don't have students flying them. Most of the helicopters belong to either TV stations or city/county/state police. There's also medevac, but they don't circle much.
- mastazi 6y agoTraining circuits don't look like a circle at all. This is what the standard training circuit looks like (it's basically a rectangular-ish shape)[1] This is the type of orbit pattern that is used for search and rescue (SAR) or surveillance (a near-perfect circle, like the ones in the OP) [2] [1] http://www.ppl-flight-training.com/circuits-briefing.html http://www.ppl-flight-training.com/circuits-briefing.html [2] page 127 of this pdf ("Creating an Orbit Pattern") https://static.garmin.com/pumac/190-01007-03_r.pdf https://static.garmin.com/pumac/190-01007-03_r.pdf
- jjwiseman 6y agoWell, this is where we really get to the "low effort/high impact" philosophy: The bots don't look for circles. That's too hard/I'm too lazy. So they do something much easier, and generally better: They look for a net change in heading equal to 4*360 degrees. (defn curviness "Computes the total curvature of a sequence of headings." ^double [headings] (Math/abs ^double (reduce (fn [^double sum [^double a ^double b]] (let [d (heading-diff a b)] (if (spurious-heading-diff d) sum (+ sum d)))) 0.0 (partition 2 1 headings)))) This is what allows the bots to find interesting activities I didn't think of ahead of time.
- jcrawfordor 6y agoWhile the traffic pattern is indeed rectangular, the "flying in circles" may come off as almost a joke to people involved in flight training (at least it did to me as a student) because one of the maneuvers you are required to learn/be able to demonstrate is flying a perfect circle. So there are, almost comically literally, a lot of student pilots out there going around and around in circles. Also rectangles and S-curves and figure-eights, and I wonder if you could do a little filtering to pick up people practicing their stalls, but I'm not sure if the temporal resolution on ADS-B altitude is enough to get that. Usually in urban areas there's a more or less formal designated practice area where people are doing these things, intentionally not near the airport, but you could filter out small aircraft in those areas if it was really an issue.