7 ms·
We badly need some sort of industrial fish farming at a large scale. Oceanic fishing at this point is basically like hunting gathering at an industrial scale: w
by oblio 6y ago
We badly need some sort of industrial fish farming at a large scale. Oceanic fishing at this point is basically like hunting gathering at an industrial scale: we just catch whatever we can and who cares if it grows back, not our problem, "nature" will take care of it. The same way we seed, till, etc., we should be doing the same thing with oceans and "hunting" aka fishing should only be allowed as a hobby.
In a somewhat "positive" side effect of what they're doing, traditional Chinese medicine will probably go extinct together will all the fish and animal species they will wipe off the face of the Earth...
- microcolonel 6y ago> We badly need some sort of industrial fish farming at a large scale. Even if we invented it, PRC would most likely not use it. > In a somewhat "positive" side effect of what they're doing, traditional Chinese medicine will probably go extinct together will all the fish and animal species they will wipe off the face of the Earth... Unfortunately, this probably only happens when everything more exotic than common farm animals has been eaten to extinction.
- oblio 6y agoWhy wouldn't they? They're not irrational. I understand their desire to keep their newly achieved standards of living and I imagine they don't want to be dependent on foreign seas, especially as these situations can cause conflicts. They also have a pretty big EEZ, about 1 million sqkm. Seems more than enough to have some huge fish farms.
- flyingfences 6y agoThey're not irrational. They're quite rational. They'll go for whatever is cheapest. For a long, long time, commercial fishing as they currently do it will be the cheapest way to do it. It's darn difficult to beat the cost-effectiveness of just harvesting the grown fish without any further involvement in the process. Especially given the labor conditions [1] exploited by these sorts of operations, there's no way that any domestically-operated farm could beat them out. [1] I've been reading Ian Urbina's Outlaw Ocean on a recommendation from another comment somewhere on HN. It's eye-opening, to say the least.
- oblio 6y ago> For a long, long time, commercial fishing as they currently do it will be the cheapest way to do it. See, here is where I argue that's not the case. Commercial fishing has increased incredibly in the past 20 years or so. We don't have a "long, long time", unlike for oil, because we can't find new fish "reserves". We pretty much know where all the existing fish we'd like/want to eat is. I'd be surprised if fishing goes up at the current rate and we have fish to eat for more than 20 years, unless we switch to the sane thing: large scale, regulated and sustainable fish farming. Now we're basically a few years before the Fishing "Dust Bowl". Or, alternatively, we figuratively "boil the oceans" and persuade everyone who currently eats fish to not eat fish. I wish people trying this alternate approach good luck! :-)
- scarmig 6y ago> Even if we invented it, PRC would most likely not use it. Something like 2/3 of the world's industrial fish farming happens in China.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoAs it happens, China has extensive fish farming. It is huge and China may be the country where it is the most developed. It may also be helped by the fact that Chinese eat quite a lot of fresh water fish compared to what we eat in Western countries. Of course an issue is that it creates further pressure on agriculture/traditional fishing to produce fish feed...
- rich_sasha 6y agoFarmed fish are fed wild-caught fish generally, so their environmental impact is comparable. There is an ongoing effort to remove that from the chain, but it remains an unsolved problem.
- oblio 6y agoWell, I have a feeling that the resolution of this problem will accelerate in the following decades. With China and other developing countries rising, we're going to need to feed 2-3 billion people more at developed country standards. We'll literally suck all the fish out of the ocean at the rate we're going, with our current processes.
- usrusr 6y ago(Salt water) fish farming is still hunting on an industrial scale because the farmed fish are mostly carnivorous and are fed with feed derived to a large part from hunted fish. It's mostly a tool to strip the oceans even harder (with fish farms converting undesirable catch into species people like to eat, everything becomes a target)
- giancarlostoro 6y agoThey should farm the prey too then? I still wonder where those mice that pet snakes eat come from. Never had a pet snake so I don't know much about them.
- oblio 6y agoYeah, I agree. Otherwise it's like saying we can't grow corn because you need water, minerals and these days, fertilizers. When we really want to, we can take care of the whole chain.
- usrusr 6y agoIf you continue that line of thought long enough you end up declaring the entirety of the world's oceans one big fish farm and truly sustainable fishing that doesn't deplete populations your method of farming.
- giancarlostoro 6y agoThe alternative is farming fish you can feed other things you can grow instead. Ultimately artificial meats and what have you will be the ultimate goal to sustain the whole system.
- globuous 6y agoI don't understand why we eat carnivorous fish. It'd be like feeding on lions... I read some of piketty's book, capital and idéologie, and he sources work that show that if India and China have historically had a greater population, it's because Europeans love meat. And feeding a population on meat requires much more agricultural space than feeding on veggies and cereals alone. I had always wondered why it was, and I liked this explanation!
- geddy 6y agoWhat we need is to stop consuming animals and animal products, or we’ll keep having economy destroying pandemics. Not to mention the obvious problem that farming is horrendous for the animals. Animals aren’t some inanimate object.
- oblio 6y agoWe need to be realistic. Reeducating several billion people from something very addictive, culturally engrained and with no direct negative effects for consumers is almost impossible.
- momokoko 6y agoGlobal pandemics are not direct negative impacts? We have several documented(h1n1 etc) significant loss of life events due to animal agriculture. No more silent downvoting. People are dying and will continue to die as these continue to happen until grown adults get some self discipline and stop eating meat.
- deelowe 6y agoI think the parent's point is well proven your exact example. There is a significant portion of the globe who think the pandemic isn't real or was caused by humans.
- oblio 6y agoYou basically read my mind. I didn't want to say it outright to avoid this hot topic.
- crucio 6y agoTypical response of HN to downvote comments like the parents, just because it's doesn't suit their own lifestyle.
- oblio 6y ago
- SaintGhurka 6y ago"industrial fish farming at a large scale" They're doing that. Bring up an areal view of china's coast, zoom in on most any protected bay and you can see they have some kind of aquatic farming going on at a pretty impressive scale. https://www.google.com/maps/@23.8785992,117.6354366,322m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@23.8785992,117.6354366,322m/dat... https://www.google.com/maps/@23.6576045,117.4483416,171m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@23.6576045,117.4483416,171m/dat... https://www.bing.com/maps?osid=d1e87c14-b29f-4173-a4f5-cbd56fb24cde&cp=29.350096~121.934377&lvl=16&style=h&v=2&sV=2&form=S00027 https://www.bing.com/maps?osid=d1e87c14-b29f-4173-a4f5-cbd56...
- ardy42 6y ago>> We badly need some sort of industrial fish farming at a large scale. > They're doing that. IIRC, most farmed fish are fed with fish meal, which is basically less-desirable wild-caught fish, so fish farming does not take the pressure off the oceans as much as you'd think. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fish_meal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fish_meal > The production and large-scale use of fishmeal are controversial. The lucrative market for fishmeal as a feed encourages corporate fisheries not to limit their yields of by-catch (from which fish meal is made), and thus leads to depletion of ecosystems, environmental damage, and the collapse of local fisheries. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fish_farming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fish_farming > Farming carnivorous fish, such as salmon, does not always reduce pressure on wild fisheries. Carnivorous farmed fish are usually fed fishmeal and fish oil extracted from wild forage fish.
- bhupy 6y agoIt's a good example of the Tragedy of the Commons. We mostly solved that problem on land, and even ended up with industrial farming by allowing people to own pieces of land to run their own farming operations. Would be nice to be able to replace off-shore oil rigs with off-shore fishing farms that sell the produce directly to retail markets. Might even be able to run aquatic "farm to table" restaurants!
- MiroF 6y ago> Would be nice to be able to replace off-shore oil rigs with off-shore fishing farms that sell the produce directly to retail markets. Might even be able to run aquatic "farm to table" restaurants! There's definitely at least an order magnitude more offshore aquaculture farms than there are oil-rigs currently.
- ardy42 6y ago> It's a good example of the Tragedy of the Commons. We mostly solved that problem on land, and even ended up with industrial farming by allowing people to own pieces of land to run their own farming operations. That's a myth. This "problem" wasn't much of a problem, historically, since real-world communities would spontaneously develop regulatory practices to prevent over-exploitation of the commons: > Political scientist Elinor Ostrom, who was awarded 2009's Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences for her work on the issue, and others revisited Hardin's work in 1999.[45] They found the tragedy of the commons not as prevalent or as difficult to solve as Hardin maintained, since locals have often come up with solutions to the commons problem themselves.[46] For example, it was found that a commons in the Swiss Alps has been run by a collective of farmers there to their mutual and individual benefit since 1517, in spite of the farmers also having access to their own farmland. In general, it is in the interest of the users of a commons to keep them functioning and so complex social schemes are often invented by the users for maintaining them at optimum efficiency.[47][48] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons#Non-governmental_solution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons#Non-gov...) Privatization is one solution, but it seems to often be falsely portrayed as the only solution. The wiki article has a decent list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons#Solutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons#Solutio...
- scythe 6y agoAquaculture is huge in Asia. China produces 61% of all of the farmed fish in the world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aquaculture#/media/File:Global_aquaculture_production_by_country_2010.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aquaculture#/media/File:Global... What we need is to reduce the popularity of consuming "predator" fish species -- there is an abundant supply of forage fish, but these are often caught and fed to farmed fish! Sardines and herring aren't popular today, but they'd be a lot more appetizing and sustainable if we just froze them on the boat instead of grinding them into fishmeal to be fed to tilapia or salmon. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forage_fish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forage_fish
- rdtwo 6y agoBut they are also overfished and under pressure
- scythe 6y agoThey are overfished largely in order to be fed to other animals. Similarly we clear too much land to farm corn but we do it because it gets fed to animals. But nobody would refer to this to argue against eating corn. I don't know how to quantify the potential sustainable yield of forage fish vs. the human diet, but I know that eating small fish is more sustainable than feeding them to larger fish and eating those.
- wk0 6y agoMaybe something like this[0] will become more common. Seems to have had some success in increasing the Salmon population (via plankton boom) but was obviously quite controversial. [0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fertilizing-ocean-with-iron-to-save-salmon-and-earn-money/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fertilizing-ocean...