5 ms·
Everyone has hopes and aspirations. What's troubling is realizing that you have an aspiration that you will never be able to fulfil. I want to fly a fully-loa
by jrockway 16y ago
Everyone has hopes and aspirations. What's troubling is realizing that you have an aspiration that you will never be able to fulfil.
I want to fly a fully-loaded 777. I want to sleep with every member of my favorite all-female band. These things are never going to happen. Does that mean my life is a failure?
- djcapelis 16y agoDo you honestly think you could never fly a fully loaded 777 if it was the most important thing to you? This project isn't about whims, it's about dreams.
- Peaker 16y agoYour argument doesn't work quite as well on his other "aspiration" :-)
- khafra 16y agoI didn't see any requirement there for consent or remaining uninjured and un-jailed. Of course, the thing about actual human values is that we satisfice instead of optimizing. That's a good thing.
- Dylan16807 16y agoI would argue that the term 'sleep with' implies consent. Even without that it's a wording issue of the goal, not a case of satisficing. Flying the 777 probably is.
- djcapelis 16y agoNo, but the final assertion that not achieving a goal = life failure is still ridiculous. Also the second isn't impossible either. Just somewhat silly and if that was someone's serious life goal, coming from a somewhat strange place I didn't want to get into. It very much seemed like a whim instead of a serious goal. That a whim is not always achievable is not really relevant.
- telemachos 16y agoI think you're unhelpfully treating 'hope' (or 'aspiration') as identical to 'desire' (what djcapelis calls a 'whim' in his reply). To my mind, a 'desire' can be any random thing I want - even if only briefly, weakly or despite my better judgement. A 'hope' or 'aspiration' is a desire that I actively endorse. (By 'actively endorse' I mean essentially 'take a hard look at, approve of and choose to expend effort on'. Right at the moment, I would love some sesame noodles. That's a desire. But the desire isn't particularly strong, and I'm not planning to do anything about it. I haven't in effect moved the item over from the 'random craving' box to the 'will expend effort on this' box. Just based on the little you say, your airplane thing and getting to know that band better, sound more like random desires to me. (Which isn't to say that the desire isn't sometimes very strong.) (There's a second question you bring up about whether a person's life is a failure if he or she doesn't fulfill aspirations. I don't think judging whole lives makes a lot of sense, myself, but it seems to be a popular sport.)