5 ms·
How long since Google said a Google Drive Linux client is coming?
- nautilus12 6y agoWanna make one for pixel watch too
- 01100011 6y agohttps://rclone.org/ https://rclone.org/ works great. Do we need Google to write a client?
- nichos 6y agoPidgin used to work great with gtalk, then Google broke the standard. I guess there's always a fear of that when using a third party client.
- abiogenesis 6y agoGoogle can always change the protocol and stop supporting a native client too.
- pheug 6y agorclone uses google drive's APIs to talk to them
- pmontra 6y agoAnything can happen. We're always at the mercy of the busines decisions of our technology providers. In this case Google can keep the protocol stable and stop supporting the client to the point it stops working after an update of your distro. If you want to be nearly 100% safe you self host whatever the price and the time you have to pour in. Personally I use Syncthing over my home network.
- acolumb 6y agoNo, but having a desktop client fully integrated with the popular desktop environments is a big creature comfort.
- sukilot 6y agoNothing on that page says it continuously syncs files or handles interruption/resume of syncing.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>continuously syncs files Mount? >handles interruption/resume of syncing. "Transfers over limited bandwidth; intermittent connections, or subject to quota can be restarted, from the last good file transferred."
- mcs5280 6y agorclone seems to work well enough with Drive for my purposes
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agorclone does work, and quite well, but it's not a sync client; it lets you do a one-off upload/download, or FUSE-mount, neither of which are quite the same thing
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway2048 6y agoIn the meantime you can use rclone, which is a fantastic tool for accessing cloud storage/ftp/sftp/anything with a single tool, including the ability to encrypt and cache data as well as mount volumes via FUSE. https://rclone.org/ https://rclone.org/ one of my absolute top GOTO tools.
- api 6y agoIt was found written inside the kings chamber of the great pyramid?
- blickentwapft 6y agoSaves them the trouble of canceling it.
- beached_whale 6y agoThis seems to be the lesson of Google. If you depend on the service, find someone else and pay them. Too many services are decommissioned, and if they are replaced it often is very different. Outside of search/email, it is a risk
- harikb 6y agoFor the record, Google drive is not being decommissioned.
- bdcravens 6y agoYet. I'm feel pretty secure that it won't be, but I've heard enough horror stories that I would have a backup strategy.
- beached_whale 6y agoThe uncertainty is the problem. Until recently I had fairly slow broadband, weeks to sync initially. Changing providers is often do it again, loose history either way, or pay another provider per GB to do it. The lack of official Linux client was the killer for me years ago, but prior to fibre internet the uncertainty was a big issue too. People want to plan around services like this remaining. Nothing is certain, but the news quite often talks about Google dropping another service.
- JZL003 6y agoI also read somewhere (can't find the link now) that there is an internal gDrive client used by google employees (maybe an (ex-)employee can comment) but which was never released
- iamcreasy 6y agoIs this[1] what you are referring to? [1] https://github.com/odeke-em/drive https://github.com/odeke-em/drive
- JZL003 6y agoYeah I think so
- ffpip 6y agohttps://old.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/3z0yft/why_does_google_refuse_to_provide_google_drive/cyikffo/ https://old.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/3z0yft/why_does_goog...
- deeg 6y agoI gave up on waiting for Google and ended up using Syncthing on HN's recommendation.
- JamesLeonis 6y agoSyncthing is so nice. I have it running on an old Rasperry Pi as an always-on connector.
- hiq 6y agoSyncthing is awesome. The next feature I hope they'll manage to get in is "encrypted devices", to allow the use of VPS and other less-trusted devices without losing much in terms of security. I would be really uneasy to let a third-party have access to my files, when there are such good alternatives.
- timmytokyo 6y agoForget Google Drive. Just run Nextcloud on your own VPS. I put mine on a digitalocean VPS and it costs me $5 a month for ~20GB of storage. Nextcloud has great sync clients for linux, iPhone and Windows. (It has clients for Mac and Android too, although I've never used them.) And google doesn't get access to my data or metadata. [1] https://nextcloud.com https://nextcloud.com
- DoctorNick 6y agoHope you've properly secured it, because if not, everyone will have access to your data and metadata.
- timmytokyo 6y agoI have. I set up an iptables firewall rule that allows access only from my home IP.
- mmahemoff 6y agoDon't you want to access it from your phone when mobile?
- timmytokyo 6y agoIf I need access while I'm away from home, I go through my home VPN. This is what I do on my cell phone.
- CameronNemo 6y agoWhy not just buy a NAS and keep it at home? You would get way more than 20 GB.
- timmytokyo 6y agoThis would be a good idea if I had decent upload bandwidth from home. When I'm on my cell phone, I'm generally syncing smaller things.
- askvictor 6y agoInterestingly, it does exist as a fuse driver, as can be seen in ChromeOS if you try to open a file (say a PDF) from Drive in the browser, it shows a file path of /media/fuse/.../ . Google have just chosen not to release it publically.
- ajphdiv 6y agohttps://github.com/dsoprea/GDriveFS https://github.com/dsoprea/GDriveFS Fuse driver wrapper
- ISL 6y agoIs a client even required? If Drive were to implement a sufficiently-secure NFS connection, isn't that enough? If I could NFS-mount Drive from within fstab, Google would earn even more of my money.
- 1propionyl 6y ago> If I could <use standard protocol or API reliably>, Google would earn more of my money. This is wishful thinking. Across their product line Google extends and abuses common standards, or more frequently rolls their own parallel which dominates by virtue of convenience and userbase. Try using an organizational (GSuite) Google Calendar account from any app that isn't Google Calendar, and it'll quickly become clear that this use-case simply isn't optimized for. Simple things like sharing calendars with write access don't work without finding a particular settings page that hasn't been updated since 2009. There is also no API for room reservation systems if an organization is using Google Calendar for those that I can find. And of course, need I mention the casualties of RSS compatible Reader and XMPP/Jabber compatible GTalk? The parallel to Microsoft's 90s EEE modus operandi is plainly evident. But with Google, it even stretches into web standards. Google has shown little interest in being a good citizen of an open protocol-based ecosystem, except at first to get new users into the walls before they close the gates.
- ISL 6y agoWithout wishful thought, how can one make wishes? Standards compliance is good for customers. What is good for customers is ultimately good for the company.
- mmahemoff 6y agoGoogle also promised a tool to migrate regular accounts to GSuite accounts on Google Plus, since GSuite accounts weren't supported when Google Plus launched. (What kind of lunatic company would support its paying customers? I still can't leave Google Play reviews for the same reason). I naievely kept using my regular account, even when GSuite accounts became possible, because of course Google would deliver on this promise. Never happened. Seven years later, Google Plus shut down.
- taldo 6y agoSupporting all the weird combinations of kernels and desktop environments and such must be a pain. There was an (internal only) FUSE client, but, as a good google3 binary, had a ton of internal stuff linked, and those can't get out of corp desktop/laptops (might not even work, who knows).
- xyzzy_plugh 6y agoThis is actually not a hard problem at all. Slack, Steam, heck even Google Chrome have no problems across various distros, and all have pretty good toolbar icon support, notifications, etc.
- harikb 6y agoNone of them deal with trying to provide a file system interface right? If you want to compare, compare to Dropbox.
- xyzzy_plugh 6y agoWhat does that have to do with desktop environments?
- GoOnThenDoTell 6y agoIt’s not hard to support FUSE across distros\kernels
- every 6y agoNot sure if this qualifies but I have Debian on Chrome OS. For me Google Drive is nothing but a symbolic link that I pass stuff back and forth on...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zmarty 6y agoDon't worry, the Windows one is pure garbage.
- teleforce 6y agoOn a related note and hopefully not off-topic, there's a OneDrive Linux client written in D language [1],[2]: [1] https://github.com/abraunegg/onedrive/ https://github.com/abraunegg/onedrive/ [2] https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/office-365/onedrive-on-linux/m-p/1318644 https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/office-365/onedrive-o...
- drocer88 6y agoAny reason to use this over rclone? Do you have to use a web browser to get the key?
- teleforce 6y agoI've never used rclone but according to the OneDrive Client for Linux (OCL) maintainer it does support OneDrive Personal, Business, Office365 and Sharepoint including shared folders for Personal and Business. It also fully supports Azure National Cloud Deployments. To get the key you need to use the web browser to complete the set up.
- harikb 6y agoWhat Google product managers meant to write was “We will release as soon as we hit the year of the ‘Linux on the Desktop’”. I say, they are still waiting..
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe google drive OSX client is surprisingly lack luster, as it’s merely mounted like a pseudo drive rather than even meeting the standard Dropbox met years ago. Given that they won’t write a decent OSX client, I’m unsurprised they haven’t followed through on their promises to an even less popular OS.
- crawsome 6y agoYou... don't want their clients, to be honest. I've seen some serious team-breaking bugs all because someone's mouse slipped and a team folder was dragged to a recycle bin.
- jasonmar 6y agoWhat does the client need to do? Which would be more useful, desktop GUI or command line? Would it be ok if the client runs on the jvm? Should it be deployed as a systemd service?
- Lammy 6y agoThis should be on infinite loop in an <audio> tag: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EXksOtVbxo8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EXksOtVbxo8
- diwu1989 6y agoGoogle has a private linux drive client. It's in use in Google Colab: https://colab.research.google.com/notebooks/io.ipynb https://colab.research.google.com/notebooks/io.ipynb
- buss 6y agoIt won't ever come. I use InSync on ubuntu and it works exceptionally well. I actually upgraded to the paid 200GB Google drive plan because I started using Drive dramatically more once I installed InSync.
- comperem 6y agoInsync is outstanding (https://www.insynchq.com/ https://www.insynchq.com/). It's better than the native Google Backup and Sync and works in Linux with multiple desktop variants. It also syncs MS OneDrive. One time purchase. It works great.
- Normille 6y agoUbuntu file manager has mounting of Google Drive built in. So I've not really noticed the lack of a native client.
- aembleton 6y agoHow do you do that? When I go to File > Connect to Sever then Google Drive isn't an option. Is it somewhere else?
- Normille 6y agoIf you add your Google account in 'Settings > Online Accounts' then, in the file manager sidebar right at the bottom, click 'Other Locations' and your Google Drive should be listed there under the 'Networks' heading as '<yourname>@gmail.com'. [DISCLAIMER: I'm 99% sure that was all that was involved. But I set up that Linux box quite a while back. So apologies if I've forgotten a step and am misleading people!]
- xtracto 6y agoThe problem for me with this approach is that it is not syncing but live transfers. So the performance is horrible even in my 100mbps connection. In addition you dont really have your files in your computer (this may or may not be a problem for some)
- AdmiralAsshat 6y agoIt's now built-in to Nautilus, Nemo, and Dolphin (I think), so yeah, I'd say the majority of Linux Desktop users have some means of mounting their Google Drive. I guess everyone is peeved that they don't get the "syncing" aspect of Drive w/ desktop mounts, but it works for me, as I personally use Drive as more of a cloud storage thing.
- nabeards 6y agoI use odrive, works better than any native cloud client IMO. Connects to Google Drive and many others.