8 ms·
A lot of talk in this article about Google capturing the whole web, all valid points, but I find the Facebook walled garden even more terrifying. I see people n
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
A lot of talk in this article about Google capturing the whole web, all valid points, but I find the Facebook walled garden even more terrifying. I see people now, often in online school parent groups I'm a part of, etc. who cannot even use email anymore, who don't use web pages at all, they get all their information through Facebook groups and Facebook, and only talk through Facebook messenger or sometimes SMS. E-mail is seen as arcane and tricky, lots of these people do no searching, and rarely leave Facebook. If they can't find it through Facebook (or a Twitter feed sometimes) they act bewildered. This may sound like exaggeration, but there really are people like this. I think this is even more problematic.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- huffmsa 6y agoI was very unaware that people use Facebook as their source for forums and groups until my wife started talking about the groups she's in and the wild stuff that goes on. My facebook experience is similar to how it was in '08. Updates from friends, though those are getting less common.
- kristopolous 6y agoCouldn't you have said the same thing 20 years ago and used "AOL" instead? There seems to be a large group of users who consistently fit this trend and the company names just get swapped occasionally
- searchableguy 6y agoWhat's the difference between hn and a facebook group?
- chrisco255 6y agoHN does not have 2 billion users and teams of thousands of developers working to exploit psychology and an ad monopoly to keep you on HN.
- nogabebop23 6y agoHN is one website with a very small audience of people who understand how it fits into the broader internet. A FB group is what a much, much larger set of less experienced users have been taught is "how you communicate with your tribe". That's not only very different but chillingly scary, IMO
- arnvald 6y agoHN allows you to see all the content without registration. Facebook pushes login pop-ups even on pages of restaurants etc (which often replace independent websites these days)
- jasode 6y ago>What's the difference between hn and a facebook group? - creating a discussion forum like HN -- whether via PG's custom Lisp programming or installing/hosting software like PhpBB/Vbulletin is way more difficult for non-techie users. Compare that to the easy steps of creating a new Facebook group.[1] - HN is a mixture of real names, pseudonymous, and anonymous identities. Facebook is mostly real names. - HN has no integrated calendar of related events, no rich media like photos and videos, no realtime chat with group members. Facebook groups can include that. Yes, HN demographic hates all that distracting "noise" but Facebook demographic does not. [1] https://www.facebook.com/help/167970719931213 https://www.facebook.com/help/167970719931213
- pjmlp 6y agoYep that is to be expected when for a large part of the population the built-in browser is the Internet, and for many of those persons, AOL, FB are what Internet means on their universum.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoAOL at least was pretty strictly a US phenomenon. Here in Canada it wasn't a thing, and it wasn't a thing in Europe or Asia. FB's tendril's are international. What's worse is it's very walled off, it's not really searchable or properly indexed. FB's search facilities are a joke, such as they are, but they are only available to FB users. Information that goes in there is basically available to FB and to nobody else.
- GordonS 6y agoBack in the day, Compuserve was quite popular in the UK, and I had understood the rest of the Europe too. I never used AOL, but I believe it was similar to Compuserve - a walled garden with forums, file downloads, instant messaging and such. Like AOL, Compuserve reached popularity during the infancy of the web - the web, viewed through Netscape Navigator at the time, was really rather basic, and comparatively empty, or at least so it seemed to me at the time. I actually remember thinking Compuserve was far superior to the web, and scoffed that the web would never take off. How wrong I was!
- wott 6y agoI am not sure but I think I used Compuserve too, in France. AOL came, but later and more as one Internet provider in many, and much like the others. It was a bit difficult for us to understand the image and all the memes about AOL, so you had to learn that it meant "Internet for noobs / Joe Six-Pack" in American texts.
- a_bonobo 6y agoI did have AOL in the early days of 56k in Germany. It was the same walled garden as it was in the US, and I was 'locked in' that garden without knowing. I must've been 12 or 14 years old and this was our very first internet.
- jt2190 6y ago> Here in Canada it wasn’t a thing... I sure remember it was a “thing” in Canada, especially before most people were on the internet. https://youtu.be/iaJsc6DHYkE https://youtu.be/iaJsc6DHYkE
- pyrale 6y agoNo, because most uses back then were not integrated in internet. Parents at school did not rely solely on AOL to get news, communicate with each other, etc.
- alangibson 6y agoAOL died off because the world shifted to the open web. The only way Facebook or Google die off is if a similar paradigm shift occurs.
- jhoechtl 6y agoIt's about time for true change and the open interweb as Tim Berners Lee et al. conceived it. I currently only see ipfs as a viable alternative, but with another markdown format so we need no chrome browser.
- DarthGhandi 6y agoTim Berners Lee himself has a project aimed at this. I like IPFS but it's still quite clunky to use. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solid_(web_decentralization_project) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solid_(web_decentralization_pr...
- Ericson2314 6y agoAOL died off, but also Microsoft was faced with antitrust. The combination is best, and our efforts on each are in fact complementary: we need the politicians to understand how the status quo is not workable outcome, and there is a budding alternative ready to flourish if given some breathing room. That will embolden them.
- jasode 6y ago>Couldn't you have said the same thing 20 years ago and used "AOL" instead? There seems to be a large group of users who consistently fit this trend and the company names just get swapped occasionally AOL was dominant (~30 million dialup subscribers at its 2002 peak) but didn't build any "sticky" products such as Facebook's social graph (a very valuable online Rolodex contacts database of real names). Each dialup user of AOL didn't interact with each other that much back then because the internet wasn't as central to life like today. Thus, switching from AOL access via telephone modems to cable broadband was easier than today's idea of switching away from Facebook's connected contacts. (E.g. Even Google with all its billions and web dominance couldn't get Facebook users to switch to Google+ in 2011.) That said, I still believe Facebook dominance can be supplanted but it will happen by accident : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15263715 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15263715
- giancarlostoro 6y ago> dialup user of AOL didn't interact with each other that much back then because the internet wasn't as central to life like today. Speak for yourself as a kid I would go on AOL chatrooms all day every single day. The kids rooms were packed with at least like 30 instances of them and like 10 to 20 kids in between. Learned what a/s/l meant back then something you dont hear as often these days hah. MSN Messenger had MSN chat which was IRC esque and MSN Groups had their own instances or chat it was glorious. Anywhere you went with chatrooms the internet attracted people like crazy! AOL was definitely full of those types. AOL also had annoying (to me) parental control settings. Thankfully I could justify internet access outside the AOL program by stating that games didnt work online otherwise I would be restricted to AOLs trashy browser.
- jasode 6y ago>Speak for yourself as a kid I would go on AOL chatrooms My phrase of "interact that much" was relative to today's Facebook type of social penetration. Yes, I also interacted with others on old USENET, BBSs, Compuserve (CIS userid), AOL, etc. Many of us did. But Facebook's social graph is the phenomenon that bridged the gap of grandparents seeing updates on the grandkids, high school alumni and past coworkers "finding" each other again and extending weak ties ("friend each other"). This type of social interaction is very sticky and difficult to switch away from. USENET/CIS/AOL level of interaction was much weaker.
- nogabebop23 6y agoAt its peak AOL had millions of users and the internet accounted for a tiny fraction of a person's life. The number of people who viewed AOL a "the internet" and the impact it had on them was a rounding error compared to FB's breadth and depth of integration into the very identity of it's userbase.
- x87678r 6y agoAgreed, worse is groups/websites/mailing lists which you must have FB account to join.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agowhat employment do these people have, given the theory of an increasingly technical workforce?
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoA vast chunk of the population works in the service sector. Often not really engaging with technology beyond the fixed payment terminals or whatever they need for their jobs. But mostly now people just use their phones for interacting with the Internet. And 10 years on it is still the case that the open web from a phone kinda sucks. Facebook works great on a phone, as a mostly consumption-only, attention-sucking, twitch-scroll heavy medium.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agogood point, I find that as I age I fall prey to the same faults as most of humanity, not fully considering how things must be for those I am unfamiliar with, or no longer familiar with. So I had the problem of conceiving of a person in western culture that was not very old and still of such limited technical proficiency.
- cblconfederate 6y agoIt's the equivalent of people who always used the phone, and didnt give a toss about the internet. I 'm not sure why it's alarming
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoThe phone was a public utility, somewhat regulated in the public interest.
- hrktb 6y agoI see parent’s general point being that some people work in p2p mode, whatever the medium is. Here facebook is the tool, but what matters to them is not to get random info through the feed. It’s to ask people and hear what people have to say, often very close people (family, friend, real world connections). In this respect messaging could be the main use actually. This is the equivalent of some of our parents who wouldn’t open the phone book to find some garagist when they have car issues. They’d phone a friend and ask them for recommendations.
- JadeNB 6y ago> It's the equivalent of people who always used the phone, and didnt give a toss about the internet. I 'm not sure why it's alarming People who used the phone weren't deluged by calls designed to make it impossible to distinguish bot-strewn propaganda from organic activity of real-life friends. (We did get plenty of junk calls, but they were easy to distinguish from the real thing, and people were motivated to avoid them, not to get deeper into their filter bubbles by seeking out more of them.)
- onion2k 6y agoSomething we (people who work in tech) should be acutely aware of is causing unnecessary distractions from important issues. When there's a discussion about the Google very often the first few comments are about how some other tech company also does something unsavory. This is a thread about how Google's engineers are actively working to take over the web as we know it and become the gatekeepers to all the benefit (not to mention profit) the web has to offer, and now the top comment isn't about what Google are doing. While your point is valid and reasonable in it's own right, posting it in a discussion about Google isn't really the right place.
- lawrenceyan 6y agoI respectfully disagree. The entire point of having a comments section on HN is so that the breadth of conversation can be expanded to encompass more than what just the article linked alone can provide.
- lifthrasiir 6y agoAs a result the same reportoire of stamped complaints is repeated over and over. This is a well-noted problem of HN comments section and treating this as a feature doesn't bode well.
- dvduval 6y agoI actually posted a very similar comment before I saw yours. I totally agree that there's always this sort of redirection going on whenever there's something critical of Google here. And there's so much about Google I like. I just wish we could have more discussion about the original topic.
- jrochkind1 6y agoEh, the article is about threats to the web as an information resource not controlled by one company. I don't think it's a distraction to put it in context. Although I guess it becomes one when that becomes like the bulk of what HN viewers see in the first few screens of comments. I guess it could be argued we should have more discipline in HN comments because of the affordances. But that applies to replies to the comment turning it into a big thread of different opinions too, if you just left it alone/non-controversial, it wouldn't do that.
- coding123 6y agoVery weird for me to hear this considering I've never been logged into Facebook in my entire life.
- sanitycheck 6y agoI suspect if you did, they would already know who you are.
- biztos 6y agoI decided to take a break from FB for a few weeks as it was feeling addictive. (Still on Messenger and IG so I'm not a purist.) I quickly found that many of my local business have an online presence only on Facebook. No web site, no freebie aggregator type thing, nothing, just FB. This in a major European city. It makes me wonder if it might be useful, as a public service, to have some kind of free business listing that (with your permission) automatically duplicates what you put on Facebook, just to encourage people to at least be discoverable outside that walled garden.
- JadeNB 6y ago> It makes me wonder if it might be useful, as a public service, to have some kind of free business listing that (with your permission) automatically duplicates what you put on Facebook, just to encourage people to at least be discoverable outside that walled garden. You know that Facebook would immediately start either offering incentives to keep all your data in the walled garden, or spreading FUD about the duplicator ("how can you trust what happens once your information leaves our loving embrace?").
- Const-me 6y agoThey can also remove that integration any moment they like, by revoking an app ID. Very likely they'll be able to find a paragraph in their developer program T&C they can claim was violated by GP.
- biztos 6y agoI agree and for these reasons won't be the one to try it. It's funny (in a sad way) but even for my friends who own restaurants, where I'd be more than happy to give them free hosting or help them upload stuff or whatever, they don't see anything other than FB as worth the effort even to just keep track of. Obviously that's not universally true, plenty of places (especially higher-end ones, and ones with significant delivery business) have dedicated web sites that are kept up to date.
- plutonic 6y ago
- jacquesm 6y agoTextbook case of 'whataboutism'. Besides, avoiding Facebook is easy. Avoiding Google is impossible. I am much more worried about Google because of that.
- Xorlev 6y agoDisclaimer: I work for Google, but not on Chrome or Search. There's plenty of worry to go around. I would like to put aside the (very understandable) fear about Google for a second because I think the GP makes a good point. My parents used to use the open web, but have also more or less exclusively started to use Facebook to "surf the web" and get all of their information. The 2016 election was a joke, my mother would constantly tell me about all these things she'd found out about "on Facebook". She'd click these links and keep getting more and more radical misinformation. I was honestly shocked at what her Newsfeed looks like. The worst thing is she isn't an abnormality, she's fairly typical of her generation. I'm concerned by _any_ closed platform, especially when there isn't enough competition. I realize that's descriptive of many things my employer builds as well. But please don't discount the dangers of other closed ecosystems, it's a certainly related topic. The web by _anyone_ makes it a poorer place to be and there's attackers on all sides.
- jacquesm 6y agoNice of you to speak out. If I were working at Google I'd be more worried about Facebook too. Because your paycheck more or less depends on you being able to tell yourself that you are working for 'the good guys'. But in my book both are equally rotten, it's just that this thread is about Google, not about Facebook and that makes these clear attempts at deflection. Google does plenty to spread misinformation as well, Youtube is a sewer giving outright conspiracy nutcases a platform, they continuously promote Breitbart, infowars and other despicable websites through Google News (the suggestion alone that I would like to see any of that content is revolting), they try to pretend that they care about end user privacy, including plastering all of Brussels' airport Zaventem full of posters and displays proclaiming that, never saw such a poster outside of that airport, just maybe they figured that's a good investment to reach regulators on the hoof. Google is a dishonest and manipulative company that tries hard to pretend it is a sheep. But the teeth are clearly visible and those bloody pawprints tell a different story. I for one am not buying the 'Facebook is more evil than Google' line for a second, if only because FB at least stays in its lane, Google is everywhere.
- burtonator 6y agoRemember in 2005-2010 when every geek worth their salt was talking about an open and distributed web? "The web is open!" they would say. It's a key part of the web. It's part of our core values! We're going to change the world! Yet 95% of these people are now at Facebook or Google actively trying to rip apart what made the web good, stable, and open. It's repugnant. Every person you know working at Facebook should be ashamed of themselves and they should be socially ostracized.
- api 6y agoI see the same thing. I've heard lots of non technical people call facebook posts "e-mails" and they never leave the platform. They use a phone or a tablet to launch Facebook.
- charrondev 6y agoI replaced the battery on my grandmothers phone recently (a galaxy s4 or s5 if I recall), and the only 3 apps she used were: - phone - text messages - Facebook She has no concept of the internet outside of the Facebook app.
- ShadyOperation 6y agoI've said this a few times over the years to my friends: Facebook is the "new" AOL. A lot of what you just described is what people used to do in AOL. Obviously there's some big differences, but as a tool they share a lot in common.
- Lammy 6y agoMy favorite part of this comment is the lack of disclaimer for a decade-long career at Google :)
- Abishek_Muthian 6y ago>but I find the Facebook walled garden even more terrifying. I see people now, often in online school parent groups I'm a part of, etc. who cannot even use email anymore, who don't use web pages at all, they get all their information through Facebook groups and Facebook, and only talk through Facebook messenger or sometimes SMS Replace'Facebook' with 'WhatsApp', outside U.S. especially for developing economies, your comment would be completely valid but even more dangerous as unlike Facebook's content WhatsApp's content cannot be put under public scrutiny and much of its users haven't even used a browser before let alone email.
- pjmlp 6y agoAt least in Africa it is quite overwhelming, the whole economy is kind of driven by WhatsApp, at least on the countries I used to visit before we got into the current situation.
- Jerry2 6y agoHi cmrdporcupine, you should also disclose that you actually work for Google.
- macspoofing 6y ago>but I find the Facebook walled garden even more terrifying. That's interesting that you do. I can't see it because I just don't go on Facebook. And it isn't a moral stance - I have an account, and occasionally I will respond to a relative or a friend. It's just such a small part of my life that I just don't see the danger you do.