3 ms·
The CIA will instagib Snowden the instant it is physically possible for them to do so. A pardon will never change that. The commander of the CIA states it plai
by sneak 6y ago
The CIA will instagib Snowden the instant it is physically possible for them to do so. A pardon will never change that.
The commander of the CIA states it plainly: https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/395683702757662721 https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/39568370275766272...
(Remember, we're talking about the same CIA that hacked US congressional computers, because the congress was investigating the CIA’s torture record and they wanted to cover it up. Then the CIA lied about hacking them. Then they later lied about lying about it.)
The IC knows they would suffer zero consequences for his “heart attack”.
Ed is far too smart to ever put himself in that situation.
Thus, for practical purposes, such a pardon is irrelevant.
- cryptonector 6y agoWith a pardon he could travel. He wouldn't have to leave Russia either. In time those who want him dead might fade away. Even if he never left Russia, a pardon might sway some voters one way or the other. Of course a pardon is relevant! (Not saying he should be pardoned, or that he shouldn't be.)
- dylan604 6y agoExcept a pardon would mean he could move back to the US and leave Russia
- sneak 6y agoPerhaps I wasn’t clear. If he ever sets foot in the US again, he will be quietly and instantly murdered by his former coworkers, even after he is pardoned.
- learc83 6y agoWhat leaker or whistleblower has the CIA murdered? Why didn’t they murder Manning?
- sneak 6y agoManning was declared guilty in advance by the US president prior to her trial, and subsequently was tortured so badly prior to trial she tried to kill herself twice whilst imprisoned. https://www.politico.com/story/2011/04/obama-says-manning-broke-the-law-053601 https://www.politico.com/story/2011/04/obama-says-manning-br... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/mar/12/bradley-manning-cruel-inhuman-treatment-un https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/mar/12/bradley-mannin... She was reimprisoned after her pardon, where she was subjected again to inhumane treatment, and attempted suicide a third time as a result.
- learc83 6y agoWhy didn’t they kill her? If you know enough about the CIA to be absolutely certain they will murder Snowden, then surely you know what line he crossed that Chelsea Manning didn’t? You might also want to point out that the torture was solitary confinement for all but 1 hour per day, which I’m no fan of, but just to be clear it wasn’t torture in the water boarding or toenail removal sense.
- sneak 6y agoThat’s the thing: it doesn’t need to be “absolutely certain” to be sufficient risk to effectively bar him from ever re-entering (or even venturing too far out of the current protection detail that keeps him alive). Even “pretty likely to be assassinated upon entry” would be enough to keep most reasonable or prudent people away forever. Solitary confinement for extended periods of time causes permanent, physical damage to the human brain and psyche. If you have no experience with it or those who have so suffered, I don’t think you have even a remote shred of justification or qualification to speak of it the way that you have. As I have personally witnessed the intense, permanent damage caused by such things, I entirely refuse to engage with your casual dismissal, which is extraordinarily offensive to me.
- learc83 6y agoYou seemed pretty sure. But ok if he’s “pretty likely to murdered ”, then you must have some numbers to back that up? How many leakers have been murdered, and how many haven’t? What was the probability that Chelsea Manning was going to be murdered? And how was it calculated? edit in response to your edit which included this: >As I have personally witnessed the intense, permanent damage caused by such things, I entirely refuse to engage with your casual dismissal, which is extraordinarily offensive to me. So you're just going to toss out unsubstantiated claims and then retreat under the pretense of being extraordinary offended? Torture has a generally accepted meaning and most people (and our legal system) don’t think that a single occupancy prison cell with an hour of human contact per day fits that meaning. The studies supporting psychological damage are generally talking about months of near total isolation, which is not what Chelsea Manning experienced.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bilbo0s 6y agoI don't know that I would advise Snowden to ever come to the US. Pardon or no pardon. And I mean that in a very caring way. The people after him are dangerous, and they don't care about laws, or rights. Think Erik Prince, but actually smart, methodical, and quiet. Oh, and there are thousands of them. For Mr Snowden, this is not a game.
- runawaybottle 6y agoCan you elaborate? Are there murderous independent elements within the NSA and CIA that would do this to an American citizen? I’m a huge cynic, but perhaps too naive about this. That all sounds very scary, especially when the leak was about a very large institutional apparatus that feels too big for anyone to take it personally.
- sneak 6y agoSnowden asserted clearly, on at least two different occasions, on the record, that the IC would not hesitate to assassinate Bart Gellman, a US journalist, if doing so would have prevented the publication or further distribution of the documents Snowden provided him. Gellman writes about both of these occasions in his book Dark Mirror, which I recommend you read if you’re interested in becoming less naive about the American spy apparatus. Additionally, the commander in chief of the entirety of the US military, including all of the IC (CIA et al), has plainly stated that Snowden should be executed. Note that Snowden has not at this time yet been put on trial, and the US constitution establishes the presumption of innocence, so such an event if it were to occur would be accurately described, legally, as an extrajudicial assassination of a US citizen. https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/395683702757662721 https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/39568370275766272...
- throwaway1777 6y agoIt’s relevant in the sense that he could maybe get a legit visa and leave Russia at some point.
- adventured 6y agoCan you explain why the intel community or US Military hasn't killed Daniel Ellsberg in the last half century then? He's 89 years old, everyone knows what he did and he lives in California. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Ellsberg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Ellsberg Why haven't the people involved in the The Citizens' Commission to Investigate the FBI been murdered? The members still alive have been public for the past six years. They revealed COINTELPRO and caused the Church Committee. Not worthy of an instagibbing? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_Commission_to_Investigate_the_FBI https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_Commission_to_Inve...
- duxup 6y agoIf they wanted him dead he would be. Even when Russia was FAR more closed the US intelligence was able to operate there.
- nootropicat 6y agoIf Russia allowed Snowden to be murdered they would lose the trust of other potential defectors - especially those that are directly valuable (military and industrial secrets). For this reason I'm certain he's under constant watch.
- duxup 6y agoHistory would indicate otherwise. Defectors, spies, people who just leak things for money. They sometimes there are repercussions, other times not ... and still more do their thing. I don't think it is all or nothing and I seriously doubt Snowden is untouchable.
- smsm42 6y agoIt is a common political trick to find a quote from somebody years ago and pretend that quote says it all about that person. It may even be effective at times. But if you actually believe that if Trump said something in 2013 that quote alone is his true lifetime conviction and he will never change it till he is alive (Trump, of all people!) then you're getting high on your own supply.
- sneak 6y agoWhether or not he wants any specific individual person dead is less relevant to the matter than the fact that he called for the execution of a US citizen that had not yet been put on trial. That indicates his lack of belief in the basic concepts of our legal system and constitution: the presumption of innocence, due process of law, the right to a trial, et c. This is further corroborated by the fact that the things Snowden revealed were unconstitutional actions by the US federal government, the exposure of which is in his view worthy of the most ultimate of punishment. I have not seen any indication in the intervening time that he has become more concerned with due process or constitutional rights; in fact quite the opposite: he has recently deployed federal forces to violently attack peaceful protesters. A consistent, long-term pattern of unconstitutional behavior emerges, entirely independent of his specific opinion at this time about one Ed Snowden. I hope that I did not indicate that he can’t change his mind, simply that, in this instance, he has not. Should he decide to pardon Snowden, no one should be surprised if he subsequently commands some or all of the people under his command to deprive him of rights or life. Doing so would be entirely consistent with his old statements, as well as his recent ones.