5 ms·
What it’s like to go into lockdown for the second time
- hprotagonist 6y agoI’ve not really come out of lockdown since late February. Once there was any community transmission on the continent i knew the jig was up, so we were pretty cloistered off about two weeks early. State numbers look good but I’ve yet to substantially change my behavior since I started working from home. Big restocking food trips several weeks apart, no-contact outside activities only, etc. We’ve only started doing any kind of outside-only-masks-except-when-eating limited contact with family in the last 3 weeks or so, and even that is fragile feeling.
- cactus2093 6y agoSame. This article is quite negatively written like the author wants sympathy or something. 2020's a shit year for just about everyone, not that sure what else they're looking for. They should feel lucky that Australia got to squeeze in a few months of relatively normal life in between lockdowns.
- schemy 6y ago>They should feel lucky that Australia got to squeeze in a few months of relatively normal life in between lockdowns. Victoria didn't. It went lock down, more lock down, slightly less lockdown, army on the streets. A slight over reaction for a virus whose victims mean age is 70.
- jSully24 6y agoarticle is quite negatively written like the author wants sympathy or something It is negatively written, but I don’t think they are looking for sympathy but reflecting how much harder this is when you’re repeating it. Especially when we could have had better outcomes had we all been in this together.
- Godel_unicode 6y agoI have seen an extremely concerning drop (plummet?) in empathy being shown for people over the course of the quarantine. Can we no longer hear that someone is having a bad time without telling them to shut up because it could be worse? It's literally always true that things could be worse, but telling that to people isn't exactly constructive. > not that sure what else they're looking for. "Damn, that sucks." Is probably about right.
- LadyCailin 6y agoAs someone who is relatively introverted, and is very frequently asked to do things outside my comfort zone in order to be successful in life, I can’t help but roll my eyes a little when people are asked to stop being so extroverted for once in their life. I have pity for those losing jobs or being unable to put food on the table because of this, and their complaints are perfectly valid, but for those complaining that they miss being able to go to parties and hang out with friends... I can’t help but roll my eyes.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoAlternate explanation: you work from home (thus aren't forced out of the house) and you are entertained enough by HN and Reddit and Netflix and whatever you do to have no real desire to leave, and since you have any concern about the virus, you confuse your indoor shut-in lifestyle (which most of us have) as some positive premeditated rational character trait that everyone else lacks. I'd wager that explains almost all of the self-congratulating I see online.
- monocasa 6y agoOr I'd really like to leave the house, go to concerts again, go to restaurants, work at my desk at the office where I can better keep life and work separate and have a great view of the mountains. But I also know several fairly young people that have died with no comorbidities (as young as 38), and several others that have survived but are in a mental fog months later, and know the importance of staying in.
- chromedev 6y agoYou can't even go outside?
- techsupporter 6y agoI'm not the person to whom you replied but my answer is: Sure, and I do, quite a lot, but it's not the same. I've deleted 12 different things from my calendar that my family was going to do between early March and now. A trip to see friends in another country, three baseball games (just the ones we'd bought in advance), two different conventions, and more. All ruined because of this stupid virus. None are replaced by a brisk walk outdoors.
- cma 6y agoHe says he has done " no-contact outside activities" all along.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- marcus_holmes 6y agoLife's back to normal here in Berlin. Won't be for long - they're already making noises about rising case numbers and a second lockdown. Second one will be harder, I think.
- pkaye 6y agoWhat things are not open or restricted for lockdowns in your area?
- marcus_holmes 6y agolarge gatherings of people (concerts, theatre, cinema) are still banned. Most people don't go into restaurants and only eat at the outside tables, but that's voluntary. Shops need masks and some attempt at social distancing, but the spatis (kind like corner shops but mostly selling cheap beer, very popular here) don't care about masks.
- searchableguy 6y agoWe gave up on lockdown here. Almost 70k cases daily making up a significant chunk of the total tested people. Specifically, where I live (India, some small part) - most have forgotten about hand sanitizer or face masks. I don't think a lockdown would be a good option for us but people can at least maintain caution for themselves and others which they aren't.
- gregoriol 6y agoWe are pretty close to a second lockdown in France too, but I think this time might be different: more local instead of whole country (by city/region?), more tests, available masks and gel, better knowledge of the things to do, remote work already well in place, ... It might end up being smoother.
- alfiedotwtf 6y agoMelbourne tried that but it didn’t work :( We had people leaving suburbs that had outbreaks, and when the army door knocked positive cases, a large percentage weren’t home :angry: People are selfish and will not self-isolate via the honour system. Melbourne only saw cases drop after the threat of fines for leaving home happened. Incentives matter.
- christkv 6y agoAt least they can go out for an hour of exercise. In Spain during the lockdown only a single person could go to the store a day. There won't be another mass lockdown people won't accept it and cases are climbing again. However the good news is that there does not seem to be equal explosion in hospitalisations or death.
- kibibu 6y agoJust a heads up that the sex scandal mentioned was a completely unsubstantiated rumour spread by Australia's Murdoch press, whose agenda is to politicise this outbreak.
- Lammy 6y agoI would confidently label myself a "Murdoch disliker", but I don't think "media conglomerate pushes news stories that generate the most anger/fear/hatred/etc (a.k.a. dollars)" is a partisan take in any way.
- pugio 6y agoI'm an American living in Melbourne right now (and, I guess, for the foreseeable future) and I've been very impressed with the way the government here has been handling restrictions. They're really doing everything they can to impress the seriousness of this on the population, and of the paramount importance of saving lives. When I chat with my friends and family in the US, I find myself quietly surprised when they mention things like travel or hanging out with friends. "Oh right, not everyone is locked down like we are." It's tough in some ways - my partner and I really miss hiking - but we're more than willing to keep this up until it's clear that we've contained the spread.
- analyte123 6y agoSomething like hiking with your partner is such an astronomically low risk activity for contagion that its prohibition would frustrate me a lot. But I guess the way to justify it is that makes enforcement of actually contagious activity easier, since there are so few people in the street they can all be pulled over.
- cactus2093 6y agoEverything is safe if no one else is doing it, I imagine the concern is that even hiking trails can get crowded. Not if you’re off in a super remote place, but if you’re near a big city and a large percentage of residents all want to go for a hike within 30 minutes of where they live on a Saturday morning, the trails will get crowded. There are bottlenecks like a narrow part of a trail or the public bathrooms where people will have to come into close proximity. And of course you will have people that will inevitably meet up with groups of friends they don’t live with on the hike and spread it that way. If everyone were to hike as responsibly as possible it would be fine, but in terms of broad stroke rules for public health, it seems you have to err on the side of being more strict than you would be just for yourself because people are always bending the rules and acting unpredictably (whether intentionally or not).
- JeanMarcS 6y agoImagine that everything is prohibited but hiking. Soon the trails will be full of hiking newbies. It was impressive the number of people « discovering » they like jogging in Paris when it was one of the only outdoor activity authorized...
- dddddddddd_sd 6y agohttps://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/sweden/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/sweden/ Sweden has proved that lockdown is total propaganda ran by special interest. P.S. I am going to get downvoted. But that’s okey. People don’t want hear truth!
- alfiedotwtf 6y agoI’m not sure how herd immunity is going to work when there’s evidence suggesting that there is no long-term COVID-19 immunity as people are getting reinfected
- dddddddddd_sd 6y agoDid you even try to look at scientific literature before making such claim? Or you are just saying what has been told to you by cnn? Just 3 days ago was another study from Nature which shows that they antibody level is persistent. There was another one a month ago. Read more!
- ptx 6y agoOnly seven countries have done worse than Sweden[1] in terms of deaths/population. It's worse than the US, 4 times worse than Germany, 95 times worse than South Korea and 1895 times worse than Taiwan. Despite having plenty of advance warning and (wasted) opportunity to learn from what other countries had done. [1] https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/data/mortality https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/data/mortality
- dddddddddd_sd 6y agoGive it a few months. We will discuss about it. Let the those countries have their second wave they will be same as Sweden but with broken economy!
- finger 6y agoThe Swedish economy is already suffering. The swedish economy fell by (8.6%) 2nd quarter [1] compared to Denmark (7.4%) [2]. [1]: https://www.scb.se/hitta-statistik/statistik-efter-amne/nationalrakenskaper/nationalrakenskaper/nationalrakenskaper-kvartals-och-arsberakningar/pong/statistiknyhet/nationalrakenskaper-2a-kvartalet-2020/ https://www.scb.se/hitta-statistik/statistik-efter-amne/nati... [2]: https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/penge/historisk-stort-fald-i-bnp-coronakrisen-faar-dansk-oekonomi-til-skrumpe https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/penge/historisk-stort-fald-i-bnp-c...
- aaron695 6y agoHow does economic theory apply to Learned Helplessness? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learned_helplessness https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learned_helplessness This will continue to happen regularly in countries like Australia over the next few years under their current plan.
- beaunative 6y agoI once thought coronavirus is far away even with the level of mandatory lockdown we've endured, none of my family member were affected. Until a few days ago, a remote cousin of mine who was studying in NY died because of it, and it felt real. I'd be so willingly under lockdown for so many more days if that will bring her back. Even if we hardly met, it felt real, and so close.
- umvi 6y agoTotal lockdown is overkill. Masks + social distancing are more than enough to keep cases in my area below ICU capacity. In places where people refuse to wear masks and social distance... Let them die at slightly elevated rates, it's clearly what they want. I'm tired of the government trying to save lives at any cost against people's will.
- tunesmith 6y agoWhy stop at ICU capacity? What's been mystifying me is all the R0 graphs. They go up above 1, regions get more strict, they flatten, then slope down to around R0=1.... and then they flatten out again. Right at around R0=1. It's maddening. We should keep it sloping down beyond that point.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIn most countries, maintaining the minimum restrictions needed to get R~=1 is a deliberate policy choice, not something that's happening by accident.
- tunesmith 6y agoAre they all daft? How does that make sense? R~=1 can have a low amplitude or a high amplitude. The goal should be to make the slope go down at least until contact tracing can be achieved. We have states in the US where R~=1 still means test shortages.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoMost countries' health authorities don't believe that any achievable level of infection can be controlled through contact tracing alone, so they're aiming to find an acceptable equilibrium for the next year or two until a vaccine can be widely deployed.
- DennisP 6y agoThe problem is that when people refuse to wear masks, it's often other people who end up dying because of it, even when the other people took more care. The reason, of course, is that masks are only partial protection for the people wearing them.
- kaladinstorm 6y agoThis is insanity. Why are these people letting their government put them under house arrest.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- batt4good 6y agoAs a resident of New York City I absolutely cannot fathom another lock-down, and unfortunately I don't think a vast majority of residents my age would take it "seriously". A big reason the lock-down ever worked was the sheer exodus of people from Manhattan. Brooklyn and outer boroughs never really had full-quarantine. People hate to admit it, but my friends who live in neighborhoods with high minority populations complained of constant block parties and drinking in the streets - largely pointing to why queens and Williamsburg were hit hard. I lived a mere three blocks from one of the hospitals that was overrun with patients and for months had multiple chilled semi-trailers filled with dead bodies. New York has been absolutely decimated, I honestly don't see small business and restaurants coming back in even two years, even if a vaccine is found. I'm starting to shift to the side of finding a compromise to help working class people get back on their feet. Government hand-outs will NOT fix this. I whole-heartedly supported the first lock-down, but I no longer believe a second lock-down would really help anyone. Obviously, masks should become a social norm but I believe once daily testing before entering certain businesses or buildings will become commonplace. It's already common practice at hospitals and certain federal buildings.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoAs someone in the area, agreed!
- Lammy 6y agoI hope this comes off as politely as it is intended, but do you think your friends' observations also hold across class boundaries and not just across ethnic ones?
- batt4good 6y agoNo worries, I think in NYC they happen to be more ethnic. Only since poor white communities generally reside in NJ or surrounding states. I've only lived here for six months though, so I don't really consider myself in a position to comment on either of their observations.
- zaroth 6y ago
- dm319 6y agoHere in the UK the cases are going back up again. We're currently lower than France, Spain (which seems to be really taking off), Belgium, Luxembourg and Sweden, but have higher rates than Germany and the other Nordic countries. We've had local lockdowns, but we'll have to see if that works. It's the holiday month, and seaside towns are fully booked with tourists. People were desperate for a holiday, my family included, but it seems premature, and these busy seaside places are not suited to social distancing. Hospitals are trying to get the elective work going again, but everyone's keeping an eye on the numbers, which threaten to choke elective pathways. Generally, everyone seems to be struggling a bit psychologically. People are slightly grumpier, slightly more aggressive. Petty crime seems to be going up. My shoe trees were stolen at work. Why? My wife has had to park her usual intellectuality stimulating work and homeschool our children for several months now. She's done with that. I totally empathize with the writer. This has become a war of attrition.
- carlcarlcarl 6y agoAre you talking about the number of identified cases per 1 million or the number of deaths per 1 million? Looking at the death tolls, you are only lower than San Marino, Belgium, Peru, Andorra and Spain.
- dm319 6y agoCases. Yes, deaths still seem high. I find that a little strange, as it doesn't fit the rate at all. It might be that the incidence has only just dropped after a delay compared to the continent. Or maybe that these are assummed COVID-19 cases that haven't been tested. But I also notice on the latest data a -78.9 deaths/million two days ago. Not sure if that is a mistake or a correction.
- fblp 6y agoThis was written a day ago and it's annoying to see the author state "cases are only going up" when it has been widely reported that the number of cases in Victoria peaked around a week ago - thanks to the strict lockdown. Victoria is also unique in that it is the only state in Australia with a large outbreak. The government has huge economic and social incentives to contain it. Victoria charts: https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/ten-graphs-that-show-victoria-s-coronavirus-trends-20200709-p55ajk.html https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/ten-graphs-that-... I'm sorry that the writer is suffering, but as an Australian living in the US id prefer to undergo several weeks of draconian lockdown enforced by the police that could practically eliminate coroanavirus rather than what is probably going to be at least 12 months of restrictions in the US, and hundreds of thousands of deaths.
- zaroth 6y agoThere’s no evidence that a strict lockdown for several weeks can practically eliminate coronavirus indefinitely without perfect control over a non-permiable border. As soon as people (or even goods) can move freely across the border of your strictly locked down area you’re back to positive cases spreading through a susceptible population.
- gregoriol 6y agoThat's called summer and holidays here in europe. The result is not good.
- gnat 6y agoThe three essentials: strong borders, lots of testing & tracing, and social distancing (including masks). I've read epidemiologists saying that there's kinda a CAP theorem for epidemiology. Namely, you can trade off one if you're strong on the others: if you're going to have a greater risk of letting it in from weak border controls, then you have to make it hard to catch (distancing) and detect & eliminate it fast when it shows up (testing & tracing). Similarly, if you don't want distance then you've got to be very strong keeping it out and finding it if it shows up. And if you're slack on testing & tracing, then be extremely vigilant on not getting it in the first place.
- wslh 6y agoIn Buenos Aires, Argentina we are in lockdown since middle March. Never stopped.
- ojhughes 6y agoWhy so many of us accept authoritarian lockdown rulings is beyond me. It’s even more alarming how willing many are to report their neighbours for perceived infringements. Freedom of movement is sacred and people should be able to make their own choices based on the information available.
- gregoriol 6y ago"your rights end where mine begin" => you can't use your freedom to endanger others
- ojhughes 6y agoIf we both wear a mask then we pose very little danger to each other. We pose a far greater danger to others driving a car and having a collision
- gregoriol 6y agoIn France for example, there has been ~35'000 deaths because of COVID-19 in ~6 months of 2020, while there has been ~3'500 deaths on the roads in ~12 months of 2019. Your "if we both" is a very big if => without making it mandatory, people don't wear them and ill people can propagate the virus to many, making COVID propagation possibly more dangerous than a car accident they could create.
- ojhughes 6y agoMaking mask usage mandatory and actually policing it would be a much lighter touch and the evidence from Japan suggests the virus can be kept under control without lockdowns. If you take the numbers in Japan in your example, driving is more dangerous
- thinkingemote 6y agoI'd things are beyond you, you should look harder. To understand why might make you more afraid though.
- tsherr 6y agoDuring WW1 and WW2 people went off to war to die or at best come back scarred from the experience, or people sent loved ones off to war. They grew victory gardens. They lived with shortages. They survived. For years. A few months of lockdown/masks/distancing and we're crying like babies. Come on. Life's tough. Wear a helmet (or in this case, a mask).
- ojhughes 6y agoUsing the language of war has been a common theme during the pandemic as a way to justify draconian measures. This isn't a war, nurses are not like soldiers. Lockdown is great if you work from home and can sip wine in the garden. Not so attractive for small businesses owners watching their livelihoods go down the drain or if you are stuck in a tiny high rise flat with 3 kids.