9 ms·
Study: Cheap gas, not renewables, caused nuclear woes (2018)
- ghouse 6y agoCheap gas is also the primary contributors to coal's woes.
- sremani 6y agoIf California invested a quarter of it renewable investments into nuclear, there would not be rolling blackouts today.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoWe have a bunch of full-scale 24/7 low-carbon success stories (France, Ontario, Finland, Sweden) that rely heavily on nuclear. It's abundantly clear that nuclear is a climate champion when comparing live carbon emissions data on this map [1]. Compare Germany (who is phasing out nuclear) to nuclear-dominant France. [1] https://www.electricitymap.org/map https://www.electricitymap.org/map And before anyone says nuclear is too expensive, know that nuclear costs today are about on par with all other future low-carbon grid proposals. While wind and solar generators are dirt cheap, adding the extra transmissions lines, vast energy storage, smart grids, etc. adds $40-$60/MWh when done at levels that actually decarbonize, which makes nuclear already competitive. Right now the dirt cheap renewables are riding on the back of a natural gas powered grid that can handle their intermittency, (except sometimes in California).
- pedrocr 6y agoAll you said is true, but I wouldn't still bet against the renewables because we're probably very early in the cost-curve of storage still. In the last 10 years lithium batteries have become 10x cheaper for example. Nuclear was by far our best technical option for the last 20 years. I'm not so sure about the next 20 though. I ran the math this week on powering the house off-grid with solar and batteries. We even have a stream going through the property that could easily power all our needs throughout the year. The solar install is just so much simpler and lower maintenance though. With current available batteries going 100% solar already has a positive return on ~12k€ total investment. But it still makes more sense to only do a 1 to 3k€ investment in solar with no batteries, even giving away the rest of the power to the power company as we have no net-meetering. If we had net-meetering for the next 5 years it would boost the solar installs while the batteries keep going down in price. Within 10 years we can cover all the rooftops with solar. And with the distributed generation and storage we'd probably need less of a grid than we have now, not more.
- hairytrog 6y agoThe battery/solar/storage costs are near material costs already. And the material costs are artificially low. If you wanted to scale up production to match demand, prices will have to increase so that mines can extract worse ores in harder to reach places.
- pedrocr 6y agoFrom what I've seen there's enough known advancements coming to make the cost of the type of lithium battery I'd need to at least half of what it is right now. There's also the growing market for second-lives of EV batteries. So I expect to turn the house effectively off-grid within 5 years, keeping the traditional grid as backup and occasional filler. In rural areas with crappy power that's an improvement over the existing grid. Even today if I valued the insurance against power cuts enough to buy a generator just doing the battery install today would make sense instead. From what I've read lithium itself is plentiful, it's the other stuff that goes into batteries, and is actively being engineered out, that's a problem, like cobalt. So I wouldn't bet for a rise in the price of the needed raw materials, but insight into the cost curves of mining would be cool to see.
- erentz 6y agoI think the point he is making is that battery metals as a commodity have been unusually cheap. As have a lot of commodities for a while now. Commodity prices are expected by many to go up as demand increases. It’s why people are investing in companies that mine battery metals. As that happens the input costs of batteries will increase and given how massive the component of batteries is in the wind/solar green grid scenario that could change the economics considerably. FWIW uranium is also expected by many to undergo a big surge in price in the next few years with refueling contracts coming due in the US and the growth of nuclear overseas. But the fuel costs for a nuclear plant are a much smaller component compared to other sources, and I am guessing also compared to the battery metals component of the alternate solar/wind/battery/new grid system.
- 6y ago
- hairytrog 6y agoIf renewables growth continues and expands (as in the multi Trillion Green Deal lol), different nuclear thrusts will probably not require any government assistance or support. The money making potential will completely outweigh any other concerns like high capital costs and risk. It's getting there. A carbon tax would be the cherry on top.
- thinkcontext 6y ago> different nuclear thrusts will probably not require any government assistance or support The 2 recent projects in the US came about because of loan guarantees passed under Obama, a form of subsidy. Both have been miserable financial failures going 2-3x over budget on money and time. One was cancelled after spending $9b on a hole in the ground, the other should be coming online soon. Given how badly the projects went no utility in their right mind would order a reactor without even more subsidy to remove risk. There are also other forms of subsidy, notably the $450m per reactor cap on liability. That's a $3b/yr subsidy to the industry.
- guerby 6y agoNew offshore wind will soon change the renewable electricity production landscape. I recommend watching the two NREL videos on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58EYcYbRKqk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58EYcYbRKqk NREL Overview of Floating Offshore Wind https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PdKvmwsFGPE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PdKvmwsFGPE NREL Grand Challenges in the Science of Wind Energy As for comparing with nuclear for the past two years (2018 2019) capacity factor of nuclear power in France has been around 70% mainly due to maintenance according to RTE (1) For reference best UK offshore wind farm had 55.3% capacity factor in 2019 and UK offshore wind average capacity factor was 40.6% in 2019 (2) (1) https://media.rte-france.com/bilan-electrique-2019-2/ https://media.rte-france.com/bilan-electrique-2019-2/ 379.5 Twh produced, 63.1 GW installed, 68.7% capacity factor (2) https://energynumbers.info/uk-offshore-wind-capacity-factors https://energynumbers.info/uk-offshore-wind-capacity-factors Not far from so-called "baseload".
- kurthr 6y agoWell, unless they installed the power near point of use there would still be blackouts for power line distribution issues due to fire danger. I'm a nuclear proponent, because I believe it can be as safe (safer than coal and carbon free), but multi-GW plants have their downsides as well.
- khuey 6y agoLast night's issue was not curtailed transmission capacity, there simply isn't enough electricity for everyone in the western US to run their air conditioners at these temperatures.
- jeffbee 6y agoThat's interesting that you tie it to the region, rather than the state. I was wondering why they had to shed load when the demand according to the CAISO dashboard was only about 90% of the all-time record demand (which was set in 2006).
- khuey 6y agoCalifornia imports a lot of electricity (18% of consumption at this moment) so we can be affected by what's going on in nearby states (particularly in the Pacific NW where we draw a lot of hydropower from). Installed generating capacity is probably down from 2006 too. Electricity usage is flat or declining and old coal power stations have been phased out in CA.
- CameronNemo 6y agoCalifornia is in an earthquake zone, and as I understand it that makes nuclear somewhat risky.
- ip26 6y agoDidn't stop them from building Diablo Canyon, of course.
- ghouse 6y agoBut it is why in 2018 they (CPUC) decided that Diablo Canyon will be retired in 2025. edit: missing space between words.
- mikeyouse 6y agoAlso because nuclear operators are completely incompetent and can’t manage their investment without catastrophic construction issues.. a good friend of mine was involved in trying to fix San Onofre after their failed turbine upgrade. It would be good for the future of the industry if they didn’t keep having billion dollar safety critical mistakes. https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/watchdog/sdut-san-onofre-anniversary-2016jan30-htmlstory.html https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/watchdog/sdut-san-...
- ghouse 6y agoI think it was the steam generator, not the turbine. Or maybe both? The failed steam generator is an incredible story. And the litigation on with Mitsubishi Heavy Industries (MHI) is also interesting. But terrible for the industry.
- p1mrx 6y agoRisk is not a fixed number; it's an engineering problem. I'm sure humanity can design a power plant that doesn't blow up when you shake it.
- ghouse 6y agoIt's important to distinguish between energy and capacity. And recognize the operating flexibility of different resources. While if a 1/4 of the CapEx for renewables were invested in fission, California would have more capacity, the energy cost would also increase. Fission has considerable operating expenses, which is why it has been displaced by both gas generation and renewable generation throughout the United States.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoCheap gas is also the primary driver behind flattening carbon emissions in the USA. As we switch from coal (820 gCO₂-eq/kWh) to fracked gas (490 gCO₂-eq/kWh), our carbon emissions could fall by a lot. But gas is a a climate wolf in climate sheep's clothing. The end destination (490) is wholly incompatible with all the IPCC low-carbon scenarios that actually mitigate climate change. So we're kind of lulled into a false sense of success as we shut down vast quantities of coal (yay) but also actually low carbon nuclear (11 gCO₂-eq/kWh) (boo) and replace it directly with gas. (And I do mean directly. When Indian Point shut down in NY earlier this year, NY subtracted 1016.1 MW of low-carbon nuclear capacity and added 1016.1 MW of high-carbon fossil gas [1]!) We need carbon pricing so we actually add market value to things that are actually low carbon. Shutting down nuclear to replace with gas is so backwards. [1] See "capacity of electric power plants" spreadsheet from here: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data.php https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data.php
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throw0101a 6y ago> Shutting down nuclear to replace with gas is so backwards. As a now-deleted comment observed, gas wells often mean methane methane leaks as well. Methane is 84x worse than CO2 for global warming: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential There's a growing move towards new (HFO-1234yf [1]) refrigerants (for AC/HVAC) because a lot of the current ones (R-134a, Freon [2]) aren't good for climate change. We went to the current ones to fix the problem of the old ones (R-12 [3]) with the o-zone layer. * [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2,3,3,3-Tetrafluoropropene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2,3,3,3-Tetrafluoropropene * [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1,1,1,2-Tetrafluoroethane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1,1,1,2-Tetrafluoroethane * [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dichlorodifluoromethane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dichlorodifluoromethane
- mrfusion 6y agoBut methane is also short lived in the atmosphere. I worry battling methane and co2 at the same time is dividing the efforts.
- User23 6y agoThere’s no energy source that doesn’t have serious environmental trade-offs, with the possible exception of geothermal. Hydro destroys river habitats, wind kills birds especially raptors at an absurd rate, solar only works for a couple decades and leaves you with nasty waste, hydrocarbons release CO2 and nastier things besides, and nuclear’s environmental drawbacks are well known. So unless we want to advocate for a mass human die off such that our energy needs have no appreciable footprint, we need to recognize that there will be serious trade-offs and deal with it.
- andrewl 6y agoI don't know how scalable it is, but isn't concentrated solar power fairly environmentally benign? That system uses mirrors and lenses to boil water and generate steam. The steam drives turbines attached to generators. There are certainly some environmental effects, as described at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentrated_solar_power#Environmental_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentrated_solar_power#Envir... But the basic model seems cleaner to me.
- sesuximo 6y agoI think the primary drawback is amount of energy produced per (area | dollar | worker | etc).
- jabl 6y agoThe problem with solar, regardless of how it's harvested, is that it's a very diffuse energy source. So you inevitably end up with a relatively high material footprint.
- loeg 6y agoMultiple problems: - High land use (low energy density). This has both economic and ecological cost/impact. It might be ok in the SW US, but likely unacceptable elsewhere. - Becomes less effective the further you get from the equator. - Energy storage is a problem at night time, and also cloudy days.
- acidburnNSA 6y ago
- mtooth 6y agoWhen I saw the Greenland study on HN[1] last night, all I could think is how much more worse does it have to get before we refocus on building fission plants and doubling-down on fusion research investment? Unfortunately the economics of natural gas make it a steep hill to climb even if the politics and public sentiment changed on nuclear. To me, fission really seems like the only rational solution to the climate crisis that we can implement starting tomorrow. We probably do need either carbon taxes or heavy fission plant construction subsidies (easier to implement than carbon tax and most of the negative economic incentive is the capital-intensive upfront costs - nuclear is significantly cheaper than gas at the 35-40 year plant life mark). 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24165395 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24165395
- User23 6y agoThis isn’t the first time Greenland’s glaciers have receded. The name is a bit of a clue after all about its condition when the Vikings named it. Edit: Covered in a reply, but for those who don't read it please understand I was referring to the Medieval Warm Period[1]. [1[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medieval_Warm_Period https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medieval_Warm_Period
- nanomonkey 6y agoIt's my understanding that the name Greenland was used to attract new settlers, not because it actually was a good description. [From Wikipedia] The Saga of Erik the Red states: "In the summer, Erik left to settle in the country he had found, which he called Greenland, as he said people would be attracted there if it had a favorable name."
- throw0101a 6y agoGreenland's name was partly marketing: > After finding a habitable area and settling there, he named it Grœnland (translated as "Greenland"), supposedly in the hope that the pleasant name would attract settlers.[20][21][22] The Saga of Erik the Red states: "In the summer, Erik left to settle in the country he had found, which he called Greenland, as he said people would be attracted there if it had a favorable name."[23] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenland#Etymology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenland#Etymology
- jokoon 6y agoEach time I listen to climate change scientists and consultants who talk about the numbers, I clearly see how people will die because of it, but it's crazy how powerless I feel about it. It seems the only good to go about it is to educate people so that they can understand why their standard of living will be forcefully taken from them so that their children can live better lives. Climate change is the worst punishment caused by individualism, even worse than inequality. I'm still staying optimistic, but in the end I think that carbon reductions will reduce the average standard of living of all humans on earth, and that's the most worrying fact, in my view.
- dantheman 6y agoHow is climate change caused by individualism?
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoCould someone who is more R-Wing than I am, please explain why you have an unshakable preference for fossil fuels? We are zeroing in on free energy from renewables, so it isn't economics - not any longer. With that past us, why do folks on the right even care where we get our energy from? If the argument is jobs - well, that's a weak argument because the only job fields that either party cares about are those that can be leveraged for politics. If the jobs argument includes thwarting disruptive technologies to prop up legacy industries - well, that doesn't sound very Keynesian to me. Even so, I'll accept the jobs argument. I would love to see Appalachian coal regions become a mecca for renewable manufacturing. I'd love to see N.Dakota oil workers own massive energy generating coops (or whatever someone who actually groks energy comes up with). I'd be happy to see my tax dollars fund the heck out that. So whatever your jobs[1] complaint is, assume I accept it and agree to subsidize worthwhile substitutes. Once jobs and economics is off the table, why are you still attached to fossil fuels? [1] Shareholding isn't a job.
- the_economist 6y agoRenewables don't provide constant power without city-scale energy storage, which doesn't exist (yet) at any reasonable price point. Solar for example won't provide power after sunset or on cloudy days. Because you can't rely on renewables to provide power throughout every day/year, you need to have natural gas/coal/nuclear available. Those have very high fixed costs (other than natural gas), but very low marginal costs, so once you have built them it is cheaper to just use them than to build additional renewable power infrastructure.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoI can accept that if we include the trend that combinations of renewable tech are clearly closing those gaps. It seems reasonable that policy discussions about future energy should be increasingly dominated by renewables. That the worth of fossil fuels will steadily diminish toward a niche value ought to be a universally accepted understanding.
- screye 6y agoThat is exactly nuclear energy comes in. It is impossible to actually run a grid off a renewable (esp. Solar) energy power-plant in any stable manner. Nuclear energy serves the purpose of acting as the filler for the delta between the peak and trough.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoMore accurately, the high price of nuclear, is causing its woes. Everything else is simply cheaper. It's simple economics. Nuclear just is too darn expensive. There are a lot of other arguments but $ per kwh it just does not add up for nuclear.
- lightgreen 6y agoNuclear is expensive because: * we don’t build them at scale (takes too long to build one, require much engineering efforts to build each, complex permits to build each etc) * opposition from locals/governments increase delays/risks and thus capital cost * its cheaper to train/hire engineers/maintenance workers/construction workers when reactors are the same Nuclear will be much cheaper when we start building many of them. Cannot find the source now, I recall S Korea built each next power plant faster than the previous.
- guerby 6y agoAccording to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_South_Korea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_South_Korea The three last nuclear reactors have taken up to double the time of the previous ones between construction start and producing power. The last one took ten years, instead of mostly 5 years for the previous ones.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThey are also the first power plants of a new design, resetting at least some of the previous optimizations.
- redis_mlc 6y agoDon't forget ruinous decommissioning costs, usually dumped on the public.