5 ms·
Oh for god’s sake. “Failed state”? Seriously? Rolling stone has done great reporting on serious problems, but this is just insane. If the US is a ‘failed st
by zepto 6y ago
Oh for god’s sake. “Failed state”? Seriously?
Rolling stone has done great reporting on serious problems, but this is just insane. If the US is a ‘failed state’ then so is every other state.
- IntelMiner 6y agoWhat points in the article do you specifically disagree with?
- avs733 6y agothat the facts lead to a conclusion he doesn't like.
- pzone 6y agoThe UNESCO "wealth of the 1%" sloganeering is one pet peeve of mine. This is the data where the article derives the claim "the top 3 richest people owning more wealth than the bottom 160 million." The way they get this eye popping number is by summing up all financial debts and subtracting them from total financial assets. What this ends up doing is overwhelming the sum with the roughly $1.5 trillion in student debt. Unlike a mortgage or car loan, which trade financial debt for financial assets, student debt is an investment in human capital. According to this UNESCO data, the very poorest people in the world are American lawyers and doctors fresh out of medical school. These people have a great deal of non-financial wealth. But according to this methodology, such a person with $300k in debt plus 300 people with $1k in reported assets equals a total of zero. Running the numbers this way is great for shock value but it doesn't make any sense if you think about it.
- spanhandler 6y agoI agree things are fairly bad in a lot of ways, and very bad in some ways, but "failed state" does have a specific meaning and applying it to the US is pretty hyperbolic. It's fuzzy like anything that describes human stuff, but the US is definitely on the not-failed side of that fuzzy line. Heading toward it? I dunno. Maybe. Probably not. But maybe. There now? Certainly not. Our Federal government might be doing a piss-poor job but it has not stopped being able to assert sovereignty in meaningful ways, domestically and internationally, or to continue to deliver government services to a significant extent. If those things had happened we'd know it. "Governing very poorly"—even somewhat maliciously—is not what it means for a state to have failed. Maybe it's being used... I dunno, poetically? But that doesn't seem to be the case, in context. Some of the stuff in the article's interesting but a lot of the rest is similarly overblown. Declaring China's ascendance (it sometimes explicitly says China but then other times seems to use Asia to mean "Asia, but mostly China") is fashionable and might end up being true but is far from settled history, to pick on another part, and I'm guessing the "D-Day versus gun deaths in 2019" stat is mostly suicides, which seems disingenuous to me, in this context—while of course it is interesting and meaningful in others, I think they're trying to mislead with it here. I'm left-wing as hell and probably agree with most policy positions and general opinions the writer holds, so this should be right up my alley, but the piece isn't great. A better-written version of this with exactly the thesis and overall journey might even be something I'd really like! It's a mix of a pretty good cataloguing of disparate bad-sounding stats and figures about the US, many bad/misleading instances of same (any time there's a bad-sounding—or good-sounding, for that matter—stat missing any frame of reference, I get twitchy, and this has plenty), some dull and overstated predictions about the future, and some lazy narrative-building. I hate these kinds of articles when the right does them, but I almost hate them more when "my" side does them. I know that's bad politics because people respond to this sort of thing, but I just can't stand writing this transparently manipulative, at great cost to honesty and accuracy. The best parts are when the writer's focusing directly on the COVID response. Those are alright. A few other bits are OK for a few sentences in a row and could form the seed of good, if thoroughly unoriginal, articles on their own.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoIt sounds like you would give the article a B- Not exactly a train wreck then.
- spanhandler 6y agoMmmmm.... call it a C-. Some paragraphs are train-wrecks. There's about 1/3 of an only-semi-interesting but not-actually-bad article in here if you cut it down, maybe.
- nouveaux 6y ago"It's a mix of a pretty good cataloguing of disparate bad-sounding stats and figures about the US, many bad/misleading instances of same (any time there's a bad-sounding—or good-sounding, for that matter—stat missing any frame of reference, I get twitchy, and this has plenty), some dull and overstated predictions about the future, and some lazy narrative-building." I see what you're saying. To me, this article is not about building a case for America's failed state. It's an argument for the perceived loss of American leadership around the world. Given that conclusion, the stats he chooses are exactly the ones on people's minds around the world. Talking to my friends in China and Singapore, the George Floyd protests often come up as the US descending into chaos. There are comparisons to Hong Kong. Regardless of the faulty perception outside of the US, that perception shapes our leadership abilities. This article perfectly reflects what I've been hearing from overseas.
- zepto 6y agoThat’s fair, but I personally lived for more than 30 years overseas before moving to the US, and am in contact with plenty of people outside the US. My experience has been that people’s perceptions are mostly reflective of what they read in the press. They were grossly inaccurate and misleading when the US was perceived as a magnificent success - most of the problems we have now were already apparent then. But they are also grossly misleading when representing the US relative to other states now. There are ‘failed states’ inside the European Union for example, and pretty much every one of the problems the US has are reflected elsewhere too. It is obvious that things are a lot worse, and that serious problems have gone unresolved, etc. I live in the East Bay and stores were looted only a few blocks from here. Similar things happened during the riots over Oscar grant at when I lived in another part of the East Bay. There is no descent into chaos. It’s not surprising that it seems like that if you live in China or Singapore, where the penalties for rioting are draconian. You can make argument either way as to whether the riots represent something healthy or unhealthy. But it is simply not true that US is descending into chaos. It’s not even true that this is some new thing. But of course if the media present it that way, then people will think that.
- aww_dang 6y agoBoth sides may be able to agree that the COVID crisis is being used to usher in new norms. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/07/covid-19-the-great-reset/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/07/covid-19-the-great-re...
- Craighead 6y agoHave you seen: Hong Kong, Belarus, Turkey, Greece, Spain, Russia, China, Mexico, UK, Zimbabwe, or Egypt within the last 10 years?
- booi 6y agoSuccessfully trying to rig an election by killing a constitutionally guaranteed service that the government itself is responsible for? What would you call that
- ojbyrne 6y agoAssuming you’re talking about USPS, “successfully” seems premature.
- donatj 6y agoTrying to do an election by mail, last minute, when we haven’t really any infrastructure in place to prevent mass mail-in fraud seems just as much a vector for rigging to me.
- JKCalhoun 6y ago> mass mail-in fraud Source?
- xaqfox 6y agoHow many sources would you expect if there is no possible way to detect the fraud, unless the perpetrator confesses to committing it? Previously mail-in ballots were generally limited to specific conditions in order to limit the effectiveness and opportunity of this type of fraud (e.g. coercion and voting for others). That said and in my opinion it should be left up to the states to decide, but I also think there are better alternatives to limit the spread of covid (e.g. early voting by letter of last name; increased number in general and availability of outdoor polling locations; drive-thru polling locations; ticketing system where they message you when you are next or near next in line). I would also agree with federal grants to states to help fund such initiatives that actually provide a way to limit these types voting fraud that mail-in ballots do not.
- nouveaux 6y ago"Trying to do an election by mail, last minute" It seems like you're implying that there is some negligence or conspiracy. No one could have predicted that United State's Covid response would be so poor. That realization only came about in May when we tried to reopen too early. Mail was delivering fine 6 months ago. Can you cite any sources that study the infrastructure problems of the USPS?
- nine_zeros 6y agoThe denial sometimes is just unreal. What do you think other failed states are like? America is as much a failed state as corrupt democratic governments in Turkey, Thailand and Russia.
- nick_kline 6y agoYes, how can it not be obvious? Look at our continual failure to make even simple plans for cv19 and execute them nationally? It's partly the president's fault but we have multiple failures, and the situation makes clear our underfunded public health system's weakness. It can be done, look at how well other countries are organizing and dealing with it.
- chii 6y agounder ultra-liberal capitalism, the cost of funding public is not profitable - and by that i mean the value created cannot be captured by an individual/entity, but is instead spread across society (aka, a common goods). This idea is deeply seated in the minds of those who would bear the highest cost burden (the medium to high tax bracket payers). For them, it is "cheaper" to pay their own way, than to "subsidize" the healthcare of the "poorer" people (even tho it's not that much, and they don't see the value lost to private healthcare companies).
- aww_dang 6y agoHas this issue been unduely politicized in the context of an election year and a bitterly contested presidency? Which national plans would be possible within the context of the constitution? The US is literally a collection of states. When central dictates were issued by the president in the form of travel bans, partisans predictably cried "racism". It seems inconsistent or even hypocritical. Perhaps the "unraveling" is more a function of bitter partisanship?
- nick_kline 6y agoPerhaps you aren't familiar with the US separation of powers between the states and the federal government. In the US, just like we have federal food inspectors (and some statewide ones too), a federal dept. of health, federal standards for roads, a federal center for disease control, it's silly to suggest we couldn't benefit from federal standards for covid-19 safety (we have something called OSHA). We could also make use of the existing federal laws to force companies to make ppe. There's rarely any PPE in the local stores in my area. I'm left to buy random questionably sourced masks on amazon. All it would take is an order from the president to vastly improve this situation on PPE. It will apparently be left to the next one to actually make a plan and deal with it.
- throwaw4y-plate 6y agoLiving in TN right now, it's looking pur-ty rough.
- elefanten 6y agoYou are correct and it's disheartening to see multiple replies asserting non-arguments against your observation. In political science, "failed state" has some commonly accepted definitions (eg- unable to project power and defend borders), none of which apply to the US even when accounting for the terrible mismanagement of COVID-19. But like with some other terms, there's a group of theorists (usually not political scientists) who are diluting the word and throwing it around politically. In terms of the underlying reality, the US very much a functioning state.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoYes, those two words appear in the article. Just once. I feel like you are cherry picking when you call out those two words and dispense with the other 4000+ The author makes numerous excellent points.
- zepto 6y agoI agree with this. Most of the criticisms of the US have merit, and are serious. The part I think is problematic is this piece of hyperbole. I honestly believe that when people say things like this, they are contributing the problems we have as a world, even if they make a bunch of other good points. The value of an argument is not judged by then number of good points that are made. It is judged on the conclusions.