4 ms·
Modern VDSL can reach around 200mbps at distances something around 3-5 km from exchange. DSL obviously lower but possibly similar to Starlink. All that said yo
by dzhiurgis 6y ago
Modern VDSL can reach around 200mbps at distances something around 3-5 km from exchange. DSL obviously lower but possibly similar to Starlink.
All that said you can those speeds with Starlink anywhere, for much less than installing a phone line.
- yencabulator 6y agoPossible != commercially available. I talked to the guy doing DSL installs in my area, he says 5 Mbps max if you get lucky. Starlink is leapfrogging the cable/telco industries by not needing the same infrastructure.
- shaklee3 6y agoNo, it's not. So far you don't know anything about the price or the actual speeds that will be offered. So far all we know is that the latency numbers that were promised of sub 20ms are clearly not going to happen.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> So far all we know is that the latency numbers that were promised of sub 20ms are clearly not going to happen. What? How do we 'know' that? This is only a beta, and we don't know how carefully the testing was done, and we don't know how far away the servers were from the ground stations. And some users already managed results of 20ms.
- shaklee3 6y agoBecause the speed tests show it, and there are no inter satellite links. In fact, because of the limited coverage in a very specific area, is highly likely that what you're seeing is on the lower end of latency for the final system since they will have more hops.
- Dylan16807 6y agoBeta speed tests show that this is the best they can possibly do? And I think you're being ridiculously unfair about hops there. If you're in a situation where your data could spend 20ms on starlink's network and 40ms on the ground, and they route it so it spends 30ms on starlink's network and 15ms on the ground, would you complain about that? It seems clear to me that the 20ms number was about how much latency is unavoidable on starlink, the number you get without extra hops, because hops should be pure benefit. It's not like 20ms was supposed to include the path all the way to arbitrary servers, because that's blatantly impossible with the Earth being 130 light-milliseconds around.
- shaklee3 6y agoYou are arguing against exactly what Elon had said at launch. I'm not being unfair with a beta. I've lived this industry for a while; latency will go up with congestion. Let's revisit this comment in a year.
- Dylan16807 6y agoWhich statements of his am I arguing against? Also if buffers are configured to be very small then congestion does not have to add more than a fraction of a millisecond of latency. Bufferbloat is endemic but it is not unavoidable.
- shaklee3 6y agohttps://www.shacknews.com/article/118663/spacex-starlink-20ms-latency-is-designed-to-run-online-games-claims-musk https://www.shacknews.com/article/118663/spacex-starlink-20m... He said 20ms, and you are saying it'll be higher, and that's okay. You can't just shrink buffers to get rid of queuing latency. You introduce new problems with scheduling when doing so.
- Dylan16807 6y agoI'm not saying it will be higher. This first generation of satellites doesn't even have inter-satellite lasers. So those extra hops will never be an issue. It's a moot point. The 20ms number is about the first generation. But some day, when those links exist, if data goes halfway around the world via satellite, it would be stupid to say "gotcha! longer than 20ms!". That's a complete misunderstanding of the context, and complaining about something that makes the data go faster. If someone was going to use multi-hop results to 'disprove' 20ms, they don't even need data. Just look at the speed of light. Bam, already disproven! But that's because it's not what the 20ms number was talking about. He wasn't promising to violate causality.
- gsich 6y agoMore like 1-2km. I don't know which "modern" VDSL you mean.
- manicdee 6y agoIn lab conditions with cat5 cable perhaps. In the real world, the copper in the ground or on the pole is close to a century old, and probably qualifies as cat2 if you are lucky.