3 ms·
Since all of the studies in this area have essentially been done by racists with obvious flawed methodology, yes. To the extent that IQ means anything at all (
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Since all of the studies in this area have essentially been done by racists with obvious flawed methodology, yes.
To the extent that IQ means anything at all (it doesn't, past about 100), there are much greater inter-personal differences than inter-group differences, except when one of the groups is explicitly disadvantaged by the test (e.g. the test is administered in the first language of one group and the second language of the other).
- lopmotr 6y agoReally no. Ethnicity and IQ relationship is mainstream psychology. You're expressing a science-denial opinion which is popular but directly contradicted by the experts in the field and their evidence. You're misled about intra- vs inter- group differences and your claim is actually kind of meaningless. See James Damore for a clear explanation on the phenomenon with elite selection. The upshot of it is that even small differences in group average have a big impact on representation of each group at the extremes.
- tsimionescu 6y agoSure, one of the least reliable fields of science mostly believes this effect exists. They also have one of the worse reproducibility crises, and a history of fraudulent but widely believed studies (Stanford Prison Experiment, to name just one), and entire schools of thought defeated by a priori arguments (behaviorism as a theory of the human mind). Meanwhile you ahbe neuroscientists and evolutionary biologists arguing against the plausibility of differences in intelligence in large ancient groups a priori. You have people like Stephen Jay Gould arguing against the idea that IQ is a measure of general intelligence at all. And then, just to prove a point about how warped your perspective is, you cite James Damore as an argument for a basic statistical fact. You really should avoid citing beligerantly misogynistic and/or racist people when you're trying to claim that science is on your side. Not to mention that large scale aptitude tests (rather than 'general intelligence' tests) do NOT show a normal distribution of aptitudes, rendering Damore's claims statically correct but un applicable anyway.
- lopmotr 6y agoWhat shape do these not-normal distributions have to render the elite selection effect unapplicable? You're not allowed to use any claims from psychology because you've declared the whole field unreliable.
- gitrog 6y ago> Ethnicity and IQ relationship is mainstream psychology. Care to substantiate that claim?
- farandaway 6y agohttps://www1.udel.edu/educ/gottfredson/30years/Rushton-Jensen30years.pdf https://www1.udel.edu/educ/gottfredson/30years/Rushton-Jense...
- selimthegrim 6y agoThose who live by the sword die by the sword.
- lolbert 6y agothats a whole lotta words to type when you could have typed 14 instead besides your baseless lies and slanders, who exactly do you think criminals are? those with the lawbooks criminalize everything, so we are all felons, and they then kill who they want. what does bootleather taste like? knobhead
- tauwauwau 6y agoThank you for existing, here's a totally unrelated comment for you https://mangadex.org/chapter/97419/7 https://mangadex.org/chapter/97419/7
- tsimionescu 6y agoWow... Hard-core racism, here on HN? And connecting 'accomplishments of races' with modern day policing practices... Are you even aware of the influence of black people on ancient history? Of the black Roman emperors? Of the black Egyptian Empire, one that was looked at in awe for 5 thousand years? Are you aware of the inspiration the founding fathers took from the Hodenoshone (Iroquois)? And in general, are you even slightly aware of how much circumstance and happenstance impact big historical moments? Either way, you are a perfect example of the kinds of people who invented IQ, and exactly the reasons why it was invented - scientistic veneer to justify racist beliefs, not much better than phrenology before it. And I sincerely hope you'll get to experience how the kind of policing you praise feels on you own skin. It will hurt, but perhaps it will help you grow as a human being. Edit: the above comment was heavily edited after my response, removing everything except a link to 1 study.