3 ms·
Someone is going to need to decide needs and abilities in that example, no? Would that not fall onto government in a communist state?
by collyw 6y ago
Someone is going to need to decide needs and abilities in that example, no? Would that not fall onto government in a communist state?
- chii 6y ago> Would that not fall onto government in a communist state? and this is why communism fails, because an external entity cannot possibly know the true needs of the individual, and cannot act in the best interest of every individual. Unless somehow they are a benevolent god.
- claudiawerner 6y agoNowhere does Marx or any other 'communist' author claim that the state knows or pretends to know the needs and desires of the populace, or even an aggregation of their individual abilities. In fact, later 'communist' authors specifically say that it's up to the individual to sort out their needs and abilities, and to cultivate them.
- collyw 6y agoThen you get back to the problem that I presented - who decides the needs and abilities? At least with a free market we can be honest about trying to do as little as possible in return for as much as possible, and let the market decide what your abilities are worth.