5 ms·
How are they proposing to account for someone's networth, vs say things in family member's name that they really own, or things in trusts that the person contro
by bawolff 6y ago
How are they proposing to account for someone's networth, vs say things in family member's name that they really own, or things in trusts that the person controls, etc?
I dont know how high end finance works, maybe its an already solved problem, but it seems a lot easier to define incoming income (which is already challenging) than it is to define net worth.
- gorgoiler 6y agoThe state takes a cut of growth already either as income tax or capital gains tax. They take another cut when you spend it, in the form of sales tax. Now they want another cut even if you’ve already been taxed on making money and prior to you then spending it. New taxes are a scourge on democracy. They implement yet another confusopoly designed to hide details and trick voters. Just add a new, higher income tax and CGT bracket already.
- ac29 6y ago> The state takes a cut of growth already either as income tax or capital gains tax. This is true, but capital gains tax is only assessed when assets are sold. So, asset-rich individuals can acquire massive wealth, and instead of selling it, just borrow against it and sidestep any capital gains taxes. A direct tax on wealth is an attempt to change this in a way that income taxes and capital gains taxes can not, no matter the rate.
- naveen99 6y agoHow does borrowing sidestep taxes ? You still have to service the debt... so now you owe interest and taxes on interest.
- RestlessMind 6y agoYour cost of borrowing can be much lower than the cost of taxes you incur when you sell your assets to finance your needs. As an example, Zuckerberg secured a 1% mortgage for his house[0]. Assuming his house was worth 15M, to procure that much cash by selling his FB stocks, he'd have to pay 20% capital gains tax (and state taxes on top). A nice explanation here[1]. [0] https://www.cnbc.com/id/48220824 https://www.cnbc.com/id/48220824 [1] https://themortgagereports.com/21788/why-mark-zuckerberg-has-a-mortgage https://themortgagereports.com/21788/why-mark-zuckerberg-has...
- naveen99 6y agoTaxes are 1 time, mortgage interest is annual. You still have to pay off the principal + interest... at some point you will have to sell shares and pay capital gains anyway... leverage comes with its own risk. That’s why you don’t gamble with borrowed money.
- RestlessMind 6y agoBut you can invest those one-time taxes and generate far more returns than the interest costs. Historical S&P500 returns are 6% per year, where as we are looking at only 1% mortgage rates for a billionaire.
- naveen99 6y agoSuppose there were no taxes. When would you stop taking on additional leverage with a 1% loan given historical returns of 6% ? I guess kelly criteria puts it around 2.5x. Now suppose you are already there, but now you add back taxes. Do you pay taxes or lever up ?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThey propose to kick the can over to the Franchise Tax Board. The bill instructs the board to regulate "abusive transactions whose aim is to change the nature of an asset from public to nonpublic" or "assets held within trusts or other entities", and the extent of the guidance on how to do it is that regulations should disregard "any feature of an asset" which decreases the value of the asset. (https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201920200AB2088 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...)
- bawolff 6y agoThat sounds horribly vauge and ripe for abuse.