3 ms·
The 'your iPhone is an Xbox' is the Gruber approved narrative as of last week, the Apple community left defending this is sextupling down on that idea.
by refulgentis 6y ago
The 'your iPhone is an Xbox' is the Gruber approved narrative as of last week, the Apple community left defending this is sextupling down on that idea.
- misnome 6y agoOr, it’s an extremely obvious immediate parallel
- refulgentis 6y agothat bizarrely didn't appear till last week, which is odd. Before that it was 'appliance'. But I'll accept the downvotes for the churlish tone
- scarface74 6y agoYou really haven’t been around here long. I’ve been making the argument for months with the downvotes to prove it.
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoI was describing the iPad as an "app console" back in 2010 (https://tracks.ranea.org/post/1432038656/geek-luddites https://tracks.ranea.org/post/1432038656/geek-luddites). It's not at all impossible Gruber read my blog post on that back then, in fact, as it was linked around a few places. I think you're getting a bit hung up on the language -- "appliance" and "console" are trying to communicate basically the same thing, e.g., a device which on a technical level could absolutely be a general purpose computing platform but has been restricted from that by design.
- misnome 6y agoI haven’t read Gruber in years and the literal first thing I thought when the “they don’t let other people use their platform” argument was made is “Why would this not apply to any other platform, <think of another highly locked down platform> like consoles!” And even assuming the antitrust/monopoly argument holds, is there some barely-known exception to “general devices only”? I’d love it if I could load my own stuff onto consoles, but don’t see how this could be practically compelled in a way that isn’t massively impactful to _everything_, especially with security and piracy implications.
- emsy 6y agoLast time I checked I didn’t use my Switch to check emails, download the Covid App, pay in a store, download and send documents or board a flight. The smartphone is an important driver for my daily life, a console is not.
- misnome 6y agoWhy not? If it wasn’t so locked down you’d be able to install apps to do all those things.
- simonh 6y agoI’ve been saying the exact same thing for about a decade. Check my HN comment history on Algolia. Nevertheless I think Apple are making some missteps. I think they made a mistake on the game streaming service decision. Epic can go take a running jump though.