4 ms·
Really? I don’t think I’ve seen anyone today with an anti-Epic take. Maybe I just haven’t gone down far enough in the comments.
by MBCook 6y ago
Really? I don’t think I’ve seen anyone today with an anti-Epic take. Maybe I just haven’t gone down far enough in the comments.
- partiallypro 6y agoLook on Twitter & Instagram. HN isn't going to be the place to find comments going against developers.
- MBCook 6y agoThe Apple sphere people I follow (mostly app developers) is giddy about this.
- judge2020 6y agoThere was a lot of debate on whether or not Apple should allow third-party app stores/easily sideloaded apps, which really shouldn't be the debate since Epic already had Fortnite on Android via a third-party launcher and went to the Play store anyways. The debate needs to be on whether or not they should take a cut on in-app purchases, and/or what that cut should be, and/or if they should allow third-party processors where the store owner doesn't see profit.
- echelon 6y agoTwitter has Apple fans rushing to criticize Epic. I'm absolutely flabbergasted the freedom disruption blinders are so strong. Why anyone supports Apple is a mystery to me. What if the web forced you to use Apple Payments? What if Microsoft forced all installs to go through the Microsoft Store? Apple took focus from the web and then extinguished openness. It's tyranny.
- bhupy 6y agoI'll try and play devil's advocate for you. Apple recently rolled out "Sign-In With Apple", which creates burner e-mail address that you can seamlessly use with 3rd party services. As a privacy-conscious consumer, this was great! On top of that, Apple forced all of its developers to support "Sign-In With Apple". This is one of the many reasons I continue to use Apple's phone and OS, because it gives me some peace of mind. Apple Payments, similarly, gives me some financial peace of mind by providing me with one centralized place where I can view and cancel my subscriptions/purchases. I can't tell you how many times I've forgotten to unsubscribe from a service that I don't use. With Apple's in-app payments system, I can keep tabs on everything. It's like a user-friendly financial reconciliation layer. Both of these Apple services place some amount of burden on the developer, and I'd even argue that the first example was pretty broadly celebrated by privacy-minded HN readers. The strongest devil's advocate argument is that the second example provides the same value to Apple customers, and that's a distinguishing feature of its platform that it ought to be able to maintain. There's a strong argument to be made that one ought to be able to side-load apps and install competing app stores on their iPhones (I tend to agree), but that's somewhat orthogonal to this particular issue, especially considering the Google Play Store action.
- echelon 6y ago> Apple recently rolled out "Sign-In With Apple", which creates burner e-mail address that you can seamlessly use with 3rd party services. As a privacy-conscious consumer, this was great! Apple spins this as privacy, but it's really a salvo they fired against other companies. Notably Google and Facebook. Apple seeks to weaponize its userbase in the war over attention. Apple wins by inserting themselves as middleman into every transaction they can. A "Sign in With Apple" user isn't your customer anymore. If you think they value privacy, you should consider the telemetry they collect on you and the conversations they record.
- bhupy 6y ago> A "Sign in With Apple" user isn't your customer anymore. Apple inserted themselves as middleman yet again. Yes, as a customer, I don't wish to provide my email / identity with every service I use. If it takes Apple being the "middleman" to have the power to control how a business interacts with me as a customer, then so be it. > If you think they value privacy, you should consider the telemetry they collect on you and the conversations they record. I used to work at Apple on their services team, and I can tell you right now that Apple has virtually no useful telemetry information that can be tied to an individual user. iOS telemetry data is tied to a periodically recycling identifier that's un-correlated with your iCloud identity.
- stickfigure 6y ago> If it takes Apple being the "middleman" to have the power ...that works right up until Apple bans you, or one of your favorite services, or just demands you pony up 30% of all the money you spend online. You think that's unlikely? In the 80s, Microsoft was the hero and IBM was the villain. In the late 90s and early 2000s, Google was everyone's favorite. During the Arab Spring, Facebook was a popular tool for liberation. Every corporation will become evil if it becomes successful enough. Give Apple centralized control over web authentication and they'll be just as ruthless as they are with the app store. We're watching a shift in public perception happen right now. The only long-term defense we have is decentralizataion, and you're fighting that. Why? So you won't get spam that you never see?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zwily 6y agoAs a consumer, I would love if the web forced Apple Pay. :)
- echelon 6y ago> As a consumer, I would love if the web forced Apple Pay. :) Forced? So you want a company to take an arbitrary 30% of my livelihood? This is why Congress has to act. Consumers don't understand the damage these companies are doing.
- scarface74 6y agoApple Pay is a standard credit card charge. You pay the same merchant fees you would pay anywhere else.
- jolux 6y agoApple Pay is just secure credit card payments. No 30% involved.
- zwily 6y agoApple Pay does not take 30% cuts, it's just a payment method. And it's by far the best purchasing experience on the web, IMO. When a vendor implements Apple Pay, I end up at least twice as likely to buy from them because so much friction is removed. (Luckily Shopify makes it easy for people so most small, boutique storefronts will support it.)
- misnome 6y agoSo anyone who doesn’t think it’s as much a slam-dunk as everyone high-fiving each other thinks is automatically an apologist? I’d love to have the option to sideload apps on my iPhone. I understood that I couldn’t do this when I bought it however, and don’t really see any compelling arguments as to why Apple would lose - there seem to be many, many arguments based on fuzzy-feelings like “I don’t like it” and “I feel 30% is too high” and “but it’s morally wrong” and “well if you imagine it this way it’s really a monopoly” and “no, I have decided that arbitrarily this would only apply to ‘general purpose’ devices”, none of which sound like legal arguments. I assume Epic is putting this up to lose in order to gamble that the law is changed in response to that suit, in which case they’d be fighting presumably against at least the lobby power of Apple, Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo and many other interests.
- echelon 6y ago> I’d love to have the option to sideload apps on my iPhone. As would developers. Computing used to be free as in speech. You could host an `.exe` file on your website and point customers there to download it. Now most people use phones and >50% of Americans are out of your reach. Don't claim that security sandboxing, privacy, and protecting users is why this has been done. With the appropriate design, users can be protected and the freedom to compute can remain. Don't push the blame on the web not being a sufficiently native platform. Cross-platform APIs could have been built. It would have saved centuries of human effort writing both Android and iPhone apps. Think of all the human innovation capital wasted. Maybe some of these people could have been solving cancer instead. Don't compare this to Nintendo. If I write a video game in C++, I can distribute it on PC, Mac, Linux, Xbox, PlayStation, Switch, Android, iPhone, Steam, and on my website. Most gamers own more than one of these platforms at a time, making it easier to reach them, but they tend to have only one type of phone. Additionally, Nintendo is not a general purpose computer. I don't do dating, online banking, taxes, or groceries on the Switch. We don't hand out Switches to school children. The App Store's unhealthy product placements and ratings led to a race to the bottom. Apps are $0.99 with a lifetime of free updates. And Apple takes a 30% cut. They dehumanize engineers and small businesses. In a time of pestilence and famine, Apple's grain silos are overflowing. Yet they take from the mouths of the very people that helped build their platform with back-breaking and thankless effort.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoI've brought lots of Apple devices, I knew what I was getting each time, and that's exactly what I wanted. I want Apple to review the applications it distributes to my phone, I want to have a very simple and centralized way to manage app subscriptions, I want strictly controlled app permissions, I want to be able to buy an iPhone for my Grandma and know she'll be pretty safe installing apps on it, I want to trust that I can properly apply security controls to the phones my company distributes to it's employees. Those are all value adds to me, they all cost money, and I'm more than happy to pay for them. It's a walled garden, and that's what I intentionally purchased when I brought my devices. These software developers and service providers have a presumption that my money is simply there for the taking, but if they want to get it, they have to come to me, and I have very intentionally chose the platform I want to use. If their services were so important to me, then they could just withdraw them from the appstore, and I would obviously have to go out and buy a different device.
- CreepGin 6y agoIt's one thing to be a walled garden, it's another to be a walled garden and forbid all other walled gardens. Will you be okay with it if Apple provides the only walled garden for the entire world? In general, I think free-form app distribution should be the way to go for any device under the general-purpose computer category. Multiple walled gardens can be spawned on top of that.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoApple doesn’t provide the only walled garden in the world. It targets a very specific high end segment, it faces very robust competition, there is no plausible way it could end up gaining a monopoly position in the market, and there is no evidence that they’re trying to do that. So yes, if the reality of the situation was completely different, I might have a different opinion. But it is not, so I don’t. > In general, I think free-form app distribution should be the way to go for any device under the general-purpose computer category. Then launch a company, provide that to the market, and see if that’s something consumers want. There are already plenty of companies that provide that though, so you might struggle to compete. General purpose computing is also not a legal category of product, nor is it really what you’re making it out to be. Playstations, Xboxes and my car stereo are all general purpose computers. The issue isn’t whether the device in question is a general purpose computer, or an embedded system. It’s whether a company is allowed to create an operating system where they can control what software is distributed to it. As iOS does not have a monopoly, I don’t see any reason why it shouldn’t be up to consumers as to whether it exists or not. Personally, as a consumer, Apple make a phone that I want to use, and part of the value I see in it is their control over app distribution.
- m000 6y agoFor real? In the HN thread about Apple removing Fortnite [1] the Apple apologists seem to vastly outnumber people who are in favour of what Epic did. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24146987 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24146987
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoYou see, some people just love their chains and digital handcuffs.
- onepointsixC 6y agoI think there's a lot more Apple users who seem to think that just because Apple doesn't have a majority of market share of users that they're not monopolistic. This of course is rubbish as the iOS store's revenue dwarfs the Google Play store, and as such any decisions they make are disproportionately impactful to any and all app developers.
- scarface74 6y agoYeah that’s kind of the definition of a monopoly.....
- m000 6y agoThere's another category, that I find even more annoying. It's the people who claim that because it is in the TOS, Apple is 100% right and their actions justified. The absence of a personal moral compass and the reliance on some TOS to tell right from wrong is alarming. What happened to "Apple may win this because of the TOS, but I don't find it right, and it shouldn't be allowed"?