9 ms·
To be completely honest, if Canonical ever wants the theoretical "year of the Linux desktop" to happen, they need a way to get proper cloud accounts working. A
by jeroenhd 6y ago
To be completely honest, if Canonical ever wants the theoretical "year of the Linux desktop" to happen, they need a way to get proper cloud accounts working.
A big part of the value of Apple's ecosystem is iCloud. Microsoft has done the same thing with the syncing and cross platform capabilities of their Microsoft Accounts.
Most Linux users today don't care much if they need to create separate email, cloud storage, backup storage, password recovery and application store accounts. That's because many Linux users have a preference for one service or even self host.
Normal people aren't like that. A desktop without a cloud account is like an Android phone without Google apps or a theoretical Apple phone without Apple apps. Technically fully functional and customisable via sideloading, but ultimately pointless because nobody wants to go through that. Just ask any regular Jane or Joe on the street if they can set up IMAP email on their phone; I bet they just use Gmail or Outlook.
It's not the Linux power users Canonical wants to attract; it's regular users. Their requirements are different from yours or mine. The Ubuntu Core website specifically says it's built for business. It's focus is on configurability and enterprise deployment, making it closer to a managed Windows 10 enterprise network than something you run on your laptop at home. Lockdowns and gatekeeping are practically what the service is intended to do.
- coreblocks 6y agoHonestly I think it’s simpler than that. The Linux desktop experience is just terrible... I have never successfully installed a Linux distro without having to fiddle with some boot flag or some config file. Every major Linux desktop environment has been unreliable at best. Software support is fragmented across dozens of distros. I think WSL has been the biggest win for Linux on the desktop, but ironically it’s on windows.
- unixhero 6y agoWhat year is this? Linux desktop experience is fantastic in 2020. It has been for several years. That's bordering FUD you're spreading.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoMy experience aligns far more with parent's than yours. The Linux Desktop experience is still pretty garbage.
- symlinkk 6y agoLet’s hear some specific examples.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoInstalling software that isn't in your distro's repo, either because it is too new, too old, or was just never adopted by a maintainer, is usually a pain in the ass. Software routinely requires tiresome google searches that largely land you in out of date non-documentation in order to get basic functionality (like say, drag and drop) working. Getting help from the community is basically impossible because whatever you're trying to do you're "using the wrong software/distro" or "don't really want that". Oh yeah, and any time you bring up these sort of things someone like you shows up to do their damnedest to dismiss these complaints. Often by comparing these problems to similar problems in Windows, as though that is somehow changes anything.
- Shared404 6y agoI'm thinking it's been a few years, and/or you and the parent decided to install arch/gentoo instead of ubuntu/fedora.
- Firehawke 6y agoMy experiences with Debian have been pretty clean outside of needing to pre-prepare the binary blob package for the ethernet and wifi drivers on the slightly older laptop that I wanted to install it on. This was expected due to Debian's stance on non-free packages on the install media. Pretty much any other modern distro install has gone 100% cleanly with no prep-work needed.
- 6y ago
- michaelmrose 6y agoThe only cloud accounts users care about are logins for all their web based services which are synced by Firefox or Chrome. They already have for example an email any web based services that come with Ubuntu are just something the people who actually use Ubuntu have to click through. Normal people who by and large do not actually use Ubuntu would probably be more likely to sign up for such options if they are the default option but no more likely to actually use them. The comparison to side loading is particularly badly made. On mobile platforms you need a platform specific account to install even free apps because ultimately also the way you consume paid for content. Linux desktops all come with a platform specific app store that requires no particular integration because it is used to consume free content. Paid content is consumed in the web browser. Games are largely consumed via steam. Paid apps are a harder sale because of the Linux desktops 3% market share and major apps that do offer support not wanting to give 30% to and platform. Only people trying to make hundreds of thousands to millions of small sales via access to the massive ios or Android markets are willing to give up 30%.
- swiley 6y agoMy “cloud account“ is on linode and it’s cheaper, less of a hassle, and more feature complete than Microsoft’s/google’s/apple’s offerings.
- jakear 6y agoNope - setting up an iCloud account is filling in a username and password. Your approach doesn’t even come close to being anywhere near that easy.
- swiley 6y agoIt also requires buying an iPhone and almost none of the features work with your desktop (unless it’s a mac) so IMO that’s not so easy.
- skinnymuch 6y agoIt doesn’t require buying an iPhone. Nor a Mac.
- tinus_hn 6y agoActually there is a web version of most of the service and also a native Windows client.
- sevensor 6y agoFor my money, the year of the Linux Desktop was 2008. It's just that nobody noticed. Since 2008, Linux has had the best combination of performance and hardware support on older machines, and the advantage has only grown since then. Windows and MacOS keep falling further behind in usability on machines older than four years, and that's the only hardware I would purchase for personal use. Why throw your money away on planned obsolescence, on an OS that keeps getting worse and worse, when you could use Linux on an older machine and have things keep getting better and better?
- kunai 6y agoIn terms of usability, yes, but the problem with Linux in recent years has rarely been usability, it's the lack of workstation-level applications that are readily available on Windows and MacOS. As long as Linux lacks native support for Autodesk, Adobe CC, Office 365, FL Studio, Pro Tools, etc. and dozens of other niche programs by ISVs it will never approach the mainstream with any sort of widespread appeal. Currently Linux on the desktop is suitable for people who are aware of these limitations and either circumvent (through technical means such as WINE, which are opaque to the typical end-user) or tolerate them, acknowledging the limitations and doing nothing to mitigate them while embracing Linux's strengths as a web and educational medium (think Chromebooks). I legitimately have tried going Linux-only several times in my life and I've just come back to Windows every time. I know it's not ideal from a security perspective, a privacy perspective, etc. but there is just zero competition with Windows in terms of a software support perspective. Windows' backwards compatibility and range of software support is a masterclass in how to enable productivity. Even MacOS doesn't come close, with how frequently Apple breaks stuff that's expected to be supported (32-bit app support, Rosetta, etc) and how frequently they change architectures (68k > PowerPC > Intel > RISC, vs Microsoft with 32-bit Intel > 64/32-bit Intel)
- the_af 6y agoThat seems like a moving goalpost to me. First, it wasn't usable. Then, it didn't have drivers. Then, it crashed a lot. Now it doesn't have Autodesk stuff? For the record, my mom doesn't know what Autodesk is. A "desktop" for me is where you can play movies, edit documents, browse the net and check email.
- xfer 6y agoThere are millions of people using Google sites on browser(no apps) on windows. There is no silver bullet "make it cloud ready" to make Linux desktop happen.
- the_af 6y ago> A desktop without a cloud account is ...ideal? Desktops have always come without a cloud account in all computers I've used since my first Commodore 64. The thought that a cloud account is somehow a requirement for a "desktop" environment seems so alien to me I can't even begin to see what our ideas of computing have in common. An internet connection is required, sure. But a "cloud account" is the invasive thing I try to avoid or remove, each time more frequently, from my home computers.
- lmm 6y agoNormal people don't know or care which cloud accounts they're logged into. I don't think I've ever heard of anyone talk about a (personal) Microsoft Account as a positive. People care about syncing their photos between their computer and their phone, sure, but neither Microsoft Cloud nor Canonical's whateveritis does that. People don't know how to get their emails from these extra accounts, iCloud included. These OS-cloud-account systems may make sense for businesses but they absolutely don't help home users.