3 ms·
I was a chemist in my past life, but not a soap chemist, so no doubt someone will be along to correct me. At a high level, soap is soap. They are basically mo
by refurb 6y ago
I was a chemist in my past life, but not a soap chemist, so no doubt someone will be along to correct me.
At a high level, soap is soap. They are basically molecules with a greasy end (long carbon chain) and a polar end (ionic group). The molecules form stable micelles that looks like little cell membranes almost, with the greasy ends pointing inward and the polar ends pointing outward (in contact with water, which is polar).
That allows the soap to combine with greasy molecules you are trying to clean away. You're basically suspending the grease in water using the soap molecules.
Now, there are a ton of different soap though. The polar functional groups can be carboxylic acids (typical homemade soap, hydrolyze fats with lye), or phosphate groups (now banned as the phosphates end up in waterways and cause algae blooms) or sulfates (the most typical last time I looked). There are no doubt others I'm not as familiar with.
Now soaps all do the same thing, but there are important differences. So this "hack" works in terms of providing a soap and killing the foaming with baking soda (we used this trick in the lab all the time to break up foams and emulsions). The baking soda can also act as a water softening agent.
That said, dishwashers are usually made for specific detergents because you don't want build up from leftover soaps and you also don't want to corrode any metal parts.
So this works, but probably not as good as actual dish detergent (but it might not matter if your dishes aren't that dirty), but you are taking a risk that continued use might gunk up your machine. Or maybe it won't.
- pedantsamaritan 6y agoI think most dishwasher detergents switched to enzymes to replace phosphates: https://www.cnet.com/news/appliance-science-how-dishwasher-detergents-digest-food-stains/ https://www.cnet.com/news/appliance-science-how-dishwasher-d... That article implies the enzymes do some work, so that surfactants/soap can carry away the tougher components (protein and starch)
- Scoundreller 6y agoI could believe the enzyme bit. Soaps require 3 things to work well: sheer force, concentration and temperature. The higher the better for all 3. Dishwashers can’t do consistent sheer force unless the sprayer hits your dish just right. So makes sense that their cleaning agent will use some other mechanism just requiring application/soaking and not sheer force.
- twic 6y agoDishwasher powder is also extremely alkaline, i believe. I (cosmetically) ruined an aluminium Moka coffee pot by putting it through a dishwasher.
- refurb 6y agoNothing cleans quite as good as strong alkaline. In the lab, we'd use a 50% lye bath and it strips off everything. If you want to add a bit of punch, you can add some 30% hydrogen peroxide as an oxidizer. Caution is needed as mixing a strong oxidizer and organic material is a recipe for fire or an explosion.
- Scoundreller 6y agoYah, lye won’t just clean, but also help make new soap from anything fatty!
- rstuart4133 6y ago> Nothing cleans quite as good as strong alkaline. Depends on what you are cleaning. Most oven cleaners are strong alkalines, often sodium hydroxide. They work well enough on grease, but neglect it a bit and the heat turns the grease into a char that nothing short of a steel scraper and lot of elbow grease will remove. (On reflection, that char may be a combination of what was grease and protein.) In any case, alkaline cleaners and soaps won't touch it. But allow to ammonia at it for 12 or so hours (it doesn't have to be wet - just exposed), and it just wipes away. The usual technique is to put the stainless steel fittings in a garbage bag, pour in a cup of cloudy ammonia, and tie off overnight. (If you want to have working nostrils afterwards, open bag outside.) It even works on the glass door. Open so it's flat, cover with paper towels, soak paper towels in cloudy ammonia, hide outside for an hour so the smell doesn't take you out and burnt on crap wipes off. I don't the chemistry is, but it's magic. It would be interesting to find out what the chemistry is, actually.
- refurb 6y agoYes, there can be a lot of additional ingredients added to dishwasher soap and I had heard of enzymes before. I have to admit I'm a bit skeptical of their effectiveness. Enzymes can usually be denatured pretty easily and if they are in a solution of hot detergent, I'd be amazed they'd stay intact enough to actually do what enzymes do. That said, there are enzymes that are pretty robust, so I could be completely off base. Edit: I am off-base, apparently there are super stable amylases that can survive 106C water.[1] [1]https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1570963913003427 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S157096391...
- twic 6y agoI speculate that bio laundry powder would be better than dish soap, as that has similar enzymes in. No idea if it's similar enough, or if there are other things in laundry powder that would be a problem. Oh no, hack trouble: https://www.idealhome.co.uk/news/washing-machine-hack-242903 https://www.idealhome.co.uk/news/washing-machine-hack-242903
- jaclaz 6y ago>At a high level, soap is soap. Very well said. Anecdotally, many years ago we were using in a tunnelling project what was called in jargon "shampoo" that was essentially some form of high concentration surfactants, they are used (injected in little quantities with water) in rock drilling mainly to prevent the bores to collapse (in order to later be able to insert the explosives in them). The stuff was pretty much inexpensive (bought by the barrel), I diluted it 1:5 and made an exceptionally good liquid soap to wash car, trucks and equipment. Then, diluted 1:10 and with added sawdust (we had on site a small carpentry shop) and little sand (the fine one we used for concrete) and some lemon juice the result was an as well very good hand wash paste for the workers.