4 ms·
> "What worker doesn't want to have access to paid sick leave?" Becerra said. "What worker doesn't want to have unemployment insurance at a time of Covid-19 cri
by ekianjo 6y ago
> "What worker doesn't want to have access to paid sick leave?" Becerra said. "What worker doesn't want to have unemployment insurance at a time of Covid-19 crisis? What worker doesn't want to know that they'll get paid for overtime if they work 60 hours in a week or 12 hours in a day?"
Since when are we reasoning about workers starting from what they want? If we go by that reasoning, "What worker does not want to be paid 3 trillion dollars per year?". Work only exists in a narrow space between a consumer and a service. Increase the costs of running the service, and you don't have work anymore. That's not very hard to understand.
- criddell 6y agoChange want to deserve and I think you'll get the idea. A service that can only exist if workers are denied basics probably shouldn't exist.
- jquery 6y agoUber doesn’t “deny basics” any more than I deny basics when I hire a plumber and pay the plumber in cash instead of hiring them on as an employee. EDIT: Uber isn’t the “plumbing company”. It’s a marketplace for transportation solutions, and accepts job offers and then sends the jobs out to contractors who have indicated they are interested in accepting such jobs. This isn’t just a “polite fiction”, this is fundamentally how Uber operates, and why they are shutting down in California. AB5 is a terrible law and I hope it is reversed or carved out to uselessness. I see it as a net negative for the economy, and especially for the workers who will now be receiving zero supplemental income during these tough times. Uber drivers are not employees of Uber.
- rfw300 6y agoYou’ve got the wrong side of the analogy. You hiring the plumber makes you the rider in this analogy. The plumbing company is Uber. AB5 says that the plumbing company can’t just hire the plumber as an independent contractor every time your toilet breaks and send them to you to avoid giving them employee benefits.
- tathougies 6y agoBut what if the plumber is a sole proprietor?
- Aeolun 6y ago> Increase the costs of running the service, and you don't have work anymore. And suddenly a competitor that gives it’s employees regular benefits is viable! The magic of a regulated free market.
- ac29 6y ago> Increase the costs of running the service, and you don't have work anymore. This hasn't been found to be the case when increasing the minimum wage, though.
- bhupy 6y agoRight, you get price increases instead, which are a more regressive way to guarantee a basic minimum standard of living than a publicly funded safety net.
- sushid 6y agoReally? Wouldn't barely profitable businesses cease to be profitable anymore and go bankrupt Surely if we mandated that the federal minimum wage is $50, we'd see businesses go out of business left and right, correct? Why would we not see a directional change like this for smaller hikes? Do you have any sources?
- therealdrag0 6y agoIt absolutely has. Minimum wage prevents some possible jobs. There are studies showing this [0]. The fair debate is only about whether more jobs is better than less jobs with higher pay. [0] https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/7/13/20690266/seattle-minimum-wage-15-dollars https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/7/13/20690266/seattle...
- ekianjo 6y ago> This hasn't been found to be the case when increasing the minimum wage, though. Then by all means let's increase the minimum wage to 100 USD/hour, so that everyone will be happy and there will be no effect on the economy. Are you sure about your claim?
- manfredo 6y agoThe question being posed isn't wrong, it's just incomplete: > "What worker doesn't want to have unemployment insurance at a time of Covid-19 crisis? What worker doesn't want to know that they'll get paid for overtime if they work 60 hours in a week or 12 hours in a day? What workers wouldn't trade their ability to set their own hours for these benefits?" The answer, as it turns out, is a lot of workers.
- Klinky 6y agoDesperation doesn't mean it's good.
- manfredo 6y agoPlenty of people were driving for Uber and Lyft before the pandemic when unemployment was low and real wages were growing. The notion that people were predominantly driving for Uber and Lyft out of desperation does not hold up to scrutiny. This thread is being rate limited reply in edit: These drivers aren't slaves. Out if all their work options they chose ride share. Now, their options are likely going to be strictly worse. The "bar" might be low from your perspective, but it was the best option these workers. How do you think their situation is improved by eliminating (or drastically altering by removing the ability of drivers to set their own hours) this option?
- Klinky 6y agoDesperation existed before the pandemic. There is always someone willing to lower the bar, that doesn't mean it's a good thing. Edit: If the "best option" isn't a good option then there is a problem.
- TrackerFF 6y agoWork only exists in a narrow space between a consumer and a service. And to be quite frank, not all services have a right to life. If some employer/business can't meet the bare minimum of workers right, well, sucks to be them. Hopefully a competent competitor will pop up. It's downright toxic that we live in a world where consumers get cheap products and services, on the backs of either rampant workers rights violations, or heavily subsidized VC-money.
- usaar333 6y agoBut in this case you are assuming a worker wants those things. They might not need various benefits (health, etc.) as they get them via another job or a spouse. If you look at reddit.com/r/uberdrivers, Uber mandating everyone be employees is.. controversial.