14 ms·
I certainly don't think the corporate doublespeak is reason to switch to Chrome, but I do think the corporate doublespeak in this announcement is just awful. W
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I certainly don't think the corporate doublespeak is reason to switch to Chrome, but I do think the corporate doublespeak in this announcement is just awful.
When you're doing a layoff, just announce the layoff, show compassion to the affected employees, and if you want to announce other changes, do it in a separate announcement. Putting stuff about the fight against systemic racism in the opening paragraph of a layoff announcement is just inviting a tidal wave of eye rolls.
- staycoolboy 6y ago> inviting a tidal wave of eye rolls. That depends entirely on how the reader feels about diversity. EDIT: I made a claim that the reader's reaction depends on what the reader is thinking, and six people claimed I was wrong, which means they can read minds. Nice. Critical thinking means removing your emotional bias from analysis.
- mulmen 6y agoIt really doesn't. I can support diversity while also not being impressed by corporate PR. I'm not sure how they are actually related at all?
- staycoolboy 6y agoYou literally just restated my point. Thank you.
- xparco 6y agoYou're welcome sir
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoHonestly, I think the exact opposite of what you're implying. If you truly value diversity, you don't use it as some sort of cover in the first paragraph of your layoff announcement.
- nilkn 6y agoIt depends on whether the reader feels diversity should be reduced to a PR tool and a mechanism of distraction, which seems disconnected from whether you’re for or against diversity as a goal for the organization. In fact, I’d think both folks for and against it would find this reductive usage onerous at best.
- ekianjo 6y ago> That depends entirely on how the reader feels about diversity. Or that depends entirely on how the reader is used to seeing buzz words the whole time used in unrelated contexts. You know, not every mundane thing is life bears relation to high ideals.
- staycoolboy 6y agoYou literally just restated my point, like the other peer posts. Their reaction depends how they feel about the term. EDIT: ...aaaaand you downvoted me. Typical.
- johnnyanmac 6y ago>EDIT: ...aaaaand you downvoted me. Typical. this isn't reddit. Even if you have downvote priveledges, you can never downvote direct replies to your own comments. so it was not them.
- SpelingBeeChamp 6y ago*privileges (just a friendly heads up)
- tempestn 6y agoYou're getting downvoted and all the replies are disagreeing with you. Is it because everyone else is misunderstanding your clear, reasonable argument, or is it more likely something to do with the way you're communicating it?
- staycoolboy 6y agoIt appears to be the former because no one addressed my point that people have different viewpoints. In my original post I stated that people would only eyeroll a reference to diversity based on how they view diversity. That's it. I thought that was harmless and succinct. People have different points of view, and no person can anticipate how another person will react. Then people tried to explain to me that I was wrong, which means: people's views DON'T actually play into how they react, which is demonstrably false. See that? In order to argue me, you have to take the position that you know exactly how everyone will already react.
- AOsborn 6y agoI don't agree. I think the whole press release comes off quite dishonest and manipulative. I'm not quite sure who the intended audience of the release is. Releasing a statement announcing the layoff of many employees while trying to position the company as "a technical powerhouse of the internet activist movement" just screams insincerity.
- zentiggr 6y agoTo me it seems not so much insincere, but incoherent. This all sounds like a bunch of grasping at big picture straws, not announcing a new actual direction. I'd be very wary of what we hear from Mozilla leadership in the next few months.
- johnnyanmac 6y ago>Critical thinking means removing your emotional bias from analysis. it also means not immediately dismissing different perspectives. It is self defeating to remove emotional bias when the statement in question is an emotional plea. That's likely the root of all the reservations you're getting in replies.
- staycoolboy 6y agoI never dismissed anything. You literally dismissed ME. sigh
- esperent 6y ago> six people claimed I was wrong, which means they can read minds No, it means you communicated badly, and your edit and replies are doubling down on that.
- tracker1 6y agoAny corporate entity making claims of supporting diversity without creating efforts to improve actual diversity which requires much earlier interaction long before hiring, is likely not really concerned about diversity but virtue signaling. This is just my own opinion. There's also the consideration that merit and talent should exceed diversity as a goal. For developers, I find that those that I would hire are roughly 10-15% of those I've interviewed. I've always paid more attention to content and character, and that has shaken itself out to include quite a bit of diversity in the end without being a goal. Maybe it's a side effect of coming from a generation online before cameras and even gui interfaces were really much of a thing. I never really cared much about someone's sexual or racial identities, only what their ideas and statements were. I almost wish we could return to those things. When I see a pull request on github, I don't go looking into the person, only the code.
- aisofteng 6y ago> Sadly, the changes also include a significant reduction in our workforce by approximately 250 people. These are individuals of exceptional professional and personal caliber who have made outstanding contributions to who we are today. To each of them, I extend my heartfelt thanks and deepest regrets that we have come to this point. From TFA.
- 9935c101ab17a66 6y ago> and if you want to announce other changes, do it in a separate announcement From TFC.
- afiori 6y agoit is still a weird suggestion. given two truths "we are currently failing" and "we decided to change course" it makes sense to bundle them into "we tried something, we must face it didn't work, there are negative consequences now, we are hopeful a new direction will save us". sometime corporate doublespeak is just trying to communicate a narrative or a vision for the future, which in terms of long term survival are often more important than clearly stated facts.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoIn this situation the corporate doublespeak just came across as dishonest, as we would somehow skip the part about the layoffs. The CEO of Carta made a post about layoffs they had there a couple months back, and the contrast with this Mozilla post is night and day IMO: https://medium.com/@henrysward/cartas-covid-19-layoff-cbb80e3e8a5d https://medium.com/@henrysward/cartas-covid-19-layoff-cbb80e...
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoYes, but that's largely because they serve different purposes. Mozilla's announcement is a press release for external consumption. Carta's post is internal and for employees, and I'm sure there was one of these for Mozilla as well, but we're not privy to it.
- vages 6y agoI have to respectfully disagree. It is common for leaders to re-state their entity's reason for being as they bring bad news. See Churchill's speeches during the battle of France, for instance. I think this opening was well-written and clearly communicated Mozilla's purpose. You can blame it for being populist, but don't hate the player, hate the game.
- tingol 6y agoWhat if we all liked this player for not playing the game?
- Jare 6y agoI would say that's the sort of impossible standard the OP was probably referring to.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ryanmarsh 6y agoI’m curious of the racial makeup of the lay-off. Are they fighting systemic racism or not?