19 ms·
TSA considers new system for flyers without ID
- rolph 6y agothe thought TSAcaptcha for air travel came to mind about halfway through reading.
- gruez 6y ago[ ] I'm not a terrorist
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoI think that just ensures John Connor would be safe on a plane.
- komali2 6y agoBush era South Carolina passed a law, and thus created a related form, that required terrorists to register themselves as such at the DMV. I used to have it on file somewhere, now it's buried in an old hard drive. Would love to have one again. Would love even more to do a FOIA request to see if they ever actually got any filled out.
- alasdair_ 6y agoIt reminds me of the paper forms I'd have to fill out when entering the US on a UK passport. The forms would ask questions like whether or not I was a nazi that participated in the holocaust.
- outworlder 6y agoThey still ask that. They will ask those questions whenever you need a visa issued or renewed. I wondered if anyone has ever said yes to the genocide questions.
- akiselev 6y agoTheir purpose isn't to get accurate information, they're there to give immigration authorities an easy legal way to kick someone out for something that would otherwise require a higher standard of evidence. I.e. anyone answering yes to that question is obviously a red flag but a former SS officer who writes in no can be kicked out by proving he knowingly lied on the forms due to his past as an SS agent without proving he was involved in or knew about the atrocities, which could be a lot harder.
- skocznymroczny 6y agoThat's one of the fields on the visa form for non-US citizens actually.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoSame thing for a lot of the security clearance forms. "Check here if you have ever tried to overthrow the US government", etc. Mostly an IQ/reading comprehension thing -- like, an actual spy who isn't a moron is going to leave it blank -- but I've heard a defense of it that's something to the effect of "well, you never asked, so I never disclosed [X]."
- refurb 6y agoIs this website really arguing that you should be able to fly without identifying yourself? I'm a big proponent of privacy and not identifying yourself to government official unless needed, but it seems like proving identify to fly is a pretty reasonable rule.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI disagree. I am mildly ok with them ensuring there are no bombs on the plane. I don't see a reason why government needs to know I am flying to WI. If I think they don't need to know why, why on earth would I want to volunteer the who.
- thephyber 6y agoAre you under the impression that the government doesn't already have access to this information from the airlines? Showing an ID card at the airport is about verifying the person getting on the plane has the same identity as on the reservation; it's not about being able to track you -- that's already done much more efficiently. I agree there's a difference between intending to volunteer this info, but I'm pretty sure you have to use your legal name on your flight reservation in the USA, so the tracking is done whether you show your ID card at the airport or not.
- refurb 6y agoThis is true, at least for international flights. Unlike many other countries, the US and Canada don’t check your passport when you exit the country. That’s because the airlines give each government the passenger lists for each flight and it’s linked back to your entry.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIt is generally not reasonable for traveling domestically. Imagine having to show ID to take the bus/metro. Sounds absurd? Well, think of the children.
- 6y ago
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y ago"A traveler who shows up at a TSA checkpoint would, it appears, be told they have to install the mobile app, pay a fee through the app (which presumably would require a credit or debit card or bank account), complete the in-app questioning, and show a “pass” result from the app to the TSA staff or contractors in order to “complete screening” and proceed through the checkpoint." Install an app that does god only know on your cell. Hard pass. I keep debating just downgrading to dumb phone, but something always stops me ( right now it is playing with Pinephone ). This, naturally, does not change the actual outcome ( can't fly without complying with TSA demands ), but I thankfully do not fly a lot these days.
- sokoloff 6y agoMost people don't fly a lot these days... That's still not an excuse for allowing TSA expansion of authority beyond that which is reasonably essential for their function.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI agree completely. I do feel a little ashamed that I abdicate my responsibility to resist this idiocy, but I am also pointing it out as a matter of fact. The few times that I do fly, I opt out.
- IgorPartola 6y agoDo you simply show your phone screen to them? Seems like a bit of a security flaw, given that I can just mock up a “pass” screen and show it to the TSA agent, no?
- breck 6y agohttps://beta.sam.gov/api/prod/opps/v3/opportunities/resources/files/902095c2eb274282b84047c261898e45/download?api_key=null&token= https://beta.sam.gov/api/prod/opps/v3/opportunities/resource... The system shall be able to generate both a human-readable and machine-readable result. i. The objective is to display to a Transportation Security Officer (TSO) that a passenger has a “pass” or a “fail” status ii. A machine-readable form factor should include the capability to be read by TSA’s Credential Authentication Technology (CAT) machine, e.g., a PDF 417 barcode or a Checksum format 1. Data in the machine readable zone would include Name, DOB, and Gender to facilitate real-time Secure Flight screening So I guess the machine-readable output could include some verification that it was not just a "PASS" JPG. It actually is a decent enough RFI. I've had to fly (accidentally) without an ID a few times and it is kind of annoying. I'd be happy if I could have used something like this instead.
- mnm1 6y agoThis will be a disaster as is usually the case with government outsourcing duties to the less qualified private sector. Surely there must be a "law" named after this by now. Realid itself is a clusterfuck. I tried to get a driver's license with it. Presented all the paperwork. Was told my signed lease was not acceptable proof of residence and that it would be impossible. I'd have to get a regular driver's license or come back at a later time, pay again and more this time for a second license. Fuck that. What a clusterfuck of stupidity. I'll try again when it renews, assuming the pandemic in the US is completely done. Or not. It's just a fact of life that to fly from state to state, one needs to carry a passport now. In a "free" country. How ridiculous.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoWhat annoys me about realid is the time it takes to make it. It takes weeks ( as opposed to being able to get one the very same day at dmv ). So average user is told tuff noodles, while average person who uses fake, working id has criminals working 24/7 to ensure easy access ( https://www.fox5ny.com/news/shipments-of-nearly-20000-fake-drivers-licenses-seized-at-chicago-airport https://www.fox5ny.com/news/shipments-of-nearly-20000-fake-d... ). And when you point it out people say something along the lines "Well, that's why you need realid!". It gets depressing fast.
- kube-system 6y agoMust be your state. I got my REAL ID on the spot at the DMV.
- curiousgal 6y agoRight, the people who still don't allow you to board with an excess ounce of water or makeup suddenly care about making air travel a pleasant experience.
- 082349872349872 6y agoIt is somewhat depressing to watch American Graffiti, or for that matter soviet movies, and see people just going out to the boarding stairs and getting on the plane like they would a bus.
- wil421 6y agoIn some places it still happens. Around 2004 I boarded a plane with stairs in Cancun. My wife’s Aunt and Uncle have been serial travelers for decades. One time her uncle forget his briefcase in the 80s. She convinced the counter person to get someone to take his briefcase to the taxing plane. The pilot opened the window and a maintenance guy threw him the briefcase. When the pilot handed him his briefcase he said I don’t know who you are or how you pulled this off but it’s impressive it worked. The uncle had no idea he left it until that point.
- option 6y agoI bet that those responsible for 9/11 couldn’t have hoped in their wettest dreams that Americans will be subject to random strip searches and patdowns in their own country for decades to come. Terrorists and US gov response made that happen. Time for the citizens to ask - whether that response was right. “Those willing to give up a little bit of freedom to gain a little bit of security deserve neither and will soon lose both”
- DangitBobby 6y agoI wonder how many people have quoted this in defense of refusing to wear a mask.
- option 6y agowearing the mask is much more about respect/protection for others than for the one who wears it.
- DangitBobby 6y agoThat's true, though you shouldn't entirely discount the protection it provides to you as well.
- freeone3000 6y agoI'm sure people have also quoted this in defense of not wearing a shirt at a restaurant. Not everything is absolute - the degree matters. Having to wear a mask in public during a pandemic is a much lighter imposition of liberties than a habitual search of possessions and belongings, and arbitrary "random" strip-searches when one boards a flight.
- DangitBobby 6y agoMy thoughts are this: The statement sounds powerful and appealing. But if you think about what it means, really, it turns out to be an extremist viewpoint with little meaning. People who give up freedom for security don't "deserve" neither. We give up freedom for security all the time, and we are often better off for it. I would argue that without security you cannot have freedom; some security is necessary to achieve a free society. How free are you if you must constantly look over your shoulder to see if someone is coming to take what you have or hurt who you love? So sure, we can talk about the trade offs and whether we should require IDs at the airport. But the quote, I think, is a misrepresentation of the stakes.
- mLuby 6y ago> The main reason for the TSA to outsource the questioning of travelers and scoring of answers is to evade the rules applicable to collection and use of personal data by Federal agencies. … The nominal “fly/no-fly” decision will still be made by the TSA, not the contractor. But that “decision” will be a rubber-stamp approval or disapproval based solely on whether the app shows a “pass” or “fail” score, or whether the would-be traveler doesn’t have a suitable smartphone or is otherwise unable or unwilling to complete the app-based process. You hear the drug trade is really lucrative but you're not allowed to sell drugs, so you send your money to a contractor that sells drugs, they give you more money back, and you technically haven't "sold drugs." Somehow, thinking breaks down at the boundary between systems, because inexplicably the constraints or guarantees of the consuming system do not propagate to the providing system. TSA could and should be (made) identity-agnostic, with its mandate to protect vehicles and occupants. Immigration is what should care about the individual that's being allowed into the country.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoNot always. For things that matter, government is perfectly capable of instituting harsh penalties for trying to game the system and boundaries between systems ( check sanctions and OFAC regulations with their strict liability; no messing around, the end result is what matters ). I am certainly not suggesting they should do it the same in TSA, but it is more of an indication that flying is not an issue here.
- closeparen 6y agoBureaucratic policies do not specify what is ethically or legally permissible, they specify how an organization has decided to do things. Contracting with an outside organization whose policies are more suited to the task at hand is usually easier than refactoring the bureaucracy you live in.
- rsync 6y ago"You hear the drug trade is really lucrative but you're not allowed to sell drugs, so you send your money to a contractor that sells drugs, they give you more money back, and you technically haven't "sold drugs."" I believe you have just described "banking".
- gruez 6y agoSo according to the request for information[1], it looks like the TSA wants a system that can validate an identity exists (given name, date of birth, address, phone number) and that the identity belongs to the person using the app. The first part looks pretty trivial, given the enormous corpus of databases out there (credit reports, public records, etc.), but what about the second part? Presumably you'd need some sort of database linking identities to photos, and validate that photo against the user's selfie or something. The question is, where would that photo database come from? State DMVs? If your photo is in the DMV database, wouldn't that also mean you have a drivers license, and therefore could use that rather than the app? What's preventing someone from impersonating someone else by scraping the internet for "similar" faces to their own, finding the associated id, and claiming that they're that person? [1] https://beta.sam.gov/api/prod/opps/v3/opportunities/resources/files/902095c2eb274282b84047c261898e45/download?api_key=null&token= https://beta.sam.gov/api/prod/opps/v3/opportunities/resource...
- ehasbrouck 6y agoI think the TSA's theory is that if you can answer questions about the data in the Accurint record about person X correctly (i.e. your answers match the Accurint record, even if it is erroneous), you must be person X. That's the essential assumption behind the current IVCC scheme, except that it is operated by the TSA rather than a contractor.
- banana_giraffe 6y ago> If your photo is in the DMV database, wouldn't that also mean you have a drivers license, and therefore could use that rather than the app Perhaps today, but if the REAL ID rules ever actually kick in, just having a driver's license won't necessarily be enough. It got pushed back from an Oct start date to some unspecified future date. There's been some press about this, but when these rules do go into effect, I suspect there will be stories about people that have trouble taking their flight.
- davchana 6y agoI believe in California, that unspecified future date is Oct 01, 2021 (for boarding planes). https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/driver-licenses-identification-cards/real-id/what-is-real-id/ https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/driver-licenses-identification...
- Nasrudith 6y agoBetter idea of course - abolish the TSA. I mean harshly enough the pandemic proves they don't really care about tens of thousands of lives so their justification for existence is even more moot - on top of their ineffectualness.
- rootsudo 6y agoThe IDEA of the TSA is to standardize all port security, not just the x-ray of your stuff and making you wait in line.
- supercanuck 6y agoYou don't need a Federal Agency to do that.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI disagree, it's a federal jobs program under the guise of security theater.
- clairity 6y agoit would be totally ok to be a federal jobs program if it actually provided unintrusive security. rather, the problem is that it's corrupt, funneling large amounts of tax dollars to private enterprise for no benefit and a boatload of individual slights. instead, the tsa should turn half of the nearly 50K screeners into canine teams roaming all the ports, letting people walk through with just an electronic bag screen.
- dmitrygr 6y agoThe reason you can fly without any ID (even today - try it) is that feds cannot stop citizens from freely moving in the country (see multiple filings from TSA in various cases, incl, for example, Gilmore v. Gonzales). They do not like acknowledging this but you can do it. The procedure is secret and they refuse to explain it (even to the court), but you can do it. i've done it just to see how it would go a few times. It works. You do need to press them on it a bit. This fee approach will not work for the same reason: it is an impediment to free movement (fee). You can read more here: https://papersplease.org/wp/2015/04/09/why-did-the-tsa-prevent-these-people-from-flying/ https://papersplease.org/wp/2015/04/09/why-did-the-tsa-preve...
- rsync 6y ago"The procedure is secret and they refuse to explain it (even to the court), but you can do it." I think you're overblowing this ... as it is neither secret nor unexplainable. Any ticket agent at any airport knows exactly how to process a frantic ( mom + 2 kids ) who forgot her ID at home and the flight leaves in 75 mins. The ticket agents, the security personnel and the gate personnel all know how to deal with (forgot ID at home).
- mynameisvlad 6y agoSo... Please explain it then. Or link to a document from the TSA that explains it. Just because it's known by a lot of people doesn't mean it's not a secret. The ticket agent might not even know the full system, just what they have to do to get that frantic mom and 2 kids off their back.
- rsync 6y ago"So... Please explain it then." Enter airport. Walk to departures agent of your airline and explain that you forgot your ID and there is no way that someone can bring it to you, or that you can retrieve it, in time to make the flight. You get extra screening and a specially marked boarding pass and you get on the plane with everyone else. My wife did this as recently as 12 months ago. SFO->MSP. YMMV. IANAL.
- komali2 6y agoThey claim that requiring a REAL-ID to fly is illegal, and link to this PDF (https://papersplease.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/IDP-form-415-19MAY2020.pdf https://papersplease.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/IDP-f...) which appears to be a sort of letter from The Identity Project attempting to explain that what the TSA is doing is illegal. So, I don't know if I buy that it matters. If I show up on Oct 2, 2021, without a REAL-ID (i.e., a pre-realID california driver's license, which is what I have because DMV lines are fucked and appointments are fucked too), I think I won't be able to fly, no matter how much I wave a PDF in the face of TSA officials.
- jedberg 6y agoAs a side note, not sure where in CA you live, but I had to renew my license last month (it expired) so I went and got a realID. I waited two minutes in line without an appointment and was completely done after 25 minutes. The whole process was efficient and I never came within six feet of another human. I did all my paperwork online which gave me the cut in line pass, and I went to a special "License only" DMV. There is one in San Jose, and probably others throughout the state.
- komali2 6y agoSan Jose? I'll drive down and try this. I'm in San Francisco. Last time I went to the downtown one, saw a line around the block, went to Daly City, saw the same, and gave up. I tried scheduling appointment and they were booked out for something insane like 6 months lol. So I just renewed my Texas ID online in 5 minutes, slapped my California address on it, and called it a day. The other day I got pulled over and the cop wasn't too happy about it though, said I had to carry my CA id to demonstrate that I'm allowed to drive in California. Silly but whatever.
- jedberg 6y agoUnless you have a reason to go, your wait at an SF DMV will be less than the 1.75 hour trip, unless you like driving. :) https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/field-office/san-jose-driver-license-processing-center-dl-only/ https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/field-office/san-jose-driver-l... They even have graphs with historical wait times so you can time it for a low point. But the big key is filling out the paperwork online. That is what gets you the cut in line pass. I passed a 30 minute line with that.
- gumby 6y agoThis is an encouraging step in the right direction, though I wonder what data this external service might capture. I have never heard an explanation of why the name of the ticket holder should matter. The stupid thermometer tests always make me think of this so-called requirement.
- deathanatos 6y agoI'd add one more: * The WiFi in the airport is hostile? No Fly. I once tried to rely on a mobile boarding pass to get through security. The process required Internet access, and I wasn't able to pull it up. It wasn't until I was on the other side of security (via a paper pass) that I realized the airport WiFi was falsifying DNS results, and that was preventing me from pulling up the pass on the mobile device. But handling "DNS server is reachable but being actively man-in-the-middled" wasn't a code path the developer had thought of (I know I wouldn't have…). I needed to open a browser and agree to some inane ToS or watch an ad, or something, before I could get unadulterated Internet access.
- nine_k 6y agoI think that the only reason to use airport wi-fi is when you arrive from abroad and don't have a local SIM card yet, and your existing SIM card is for a plan that does not provide data roaming. Otherwise, the mobile internet is vastly superior. It's even superior when it's the slow and expensive international roaming data plan. Airport's wi-fi can end up equally or more expensive and slow; I tried, both in Europe and in the US.
- Xavdidtheshadow 6y agoI really like that I can add boarding passes to Apple Wallet and they're available totally offline. There's not a lot Wallet is good for (adoption is too low) but it's great at Boarding Passes.
- remarkEon 6y agoI absolutely never do this. Maybe because I'm paranoid, and especially if I'm flying internationally, I never, ever, feel comfortable handing my mobile device to security or Immigration. I still get a paper one every time.
- aaomidi 6y agoYou can access boarding pass while your phone is locked.
- tfolbrecht 6y agoIf anyone's curious, the current system is laughable. I flew after getting my wallet stolen in a smash and grab. Questions: Name DOB Family members names Home address Nearby landmarks All public info. If there's nothing going on behind the scenes it's just more security theater.
- Mary-Jane 6y agoI got home from a business trip a couple years ago, unpacked my bags, and found the switchblade I'd lost a few months prior. I went through security twice with those bags...
- sneak 6y agoTSA, in various testing, misses between 60% and 90% of weapons. Hundreds of pistols fly every day in the US, with no major issues. We could easily abolish the TSA with no major harm.
- pgo 6y agoSimilar thing happened to me, I had 1/8 ounce weed in my hand bag I unknowingly packed, flew in from Los Angeles -> China -> India. I went through rigorous security checks with police dogs and fully body scanners at both LA and China. I panicked when I opened my bag when I reached home.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoHoly shit dog, that could have fucked you hard; your panic is justified.
- etxm 6y agoI was curious what the process was ~4 years ago for this so I “misplaced” my ID flying from SF to LA and the first agent at the beginning of the line looked me up on LinkedIn then they did a bag inspection and they let me through (I had a pass on my phone). It was very ... lenient.
- hatenberg 6y agoIts funny that this is worse than China's social credit score, there at least you know you are on the shitlist. Much these days boils down to "Like China, but worse technical execution and privatized to some contractor (who is probably a family member)"
- floatingatoll 6y agoNon-US folks who are wondering what Real ID is, and why this site seems to hate it so much, the United States is best considered in the context of the European Union but with US internal politics regarding data sharing between the federation and its member states. There are fifty member states with full privileges and around ten member states with reduced privileges. The federation issues government IDs in two ways. First, the federation government issues federation IDs in the form of passports. These are accepted as proof of identity only, and grant no additional privileges beyond proof of residency within the federation. Second, each member state issues their own photo IDs following their own independent processes. These are neither proof of citizenship to the federation’s border control, nor to other countries, and data sharing agreements historically did not exist between the states and the federation. The member states of the EU issue passports as the state ID card, and requires each member state to accept those passports as approximately equal to their own for most intents and purposes. The US federation also requires its member states to accept both any member state IDs and also federation passports. “RealID” is an effort by the federation to be able to determine from your state ID card whether you are a federation member. It defines a minimum burden of proof of citizenship that states must require and verify, and presumably share with the federation, in order to issue an ID card with a federation membership indicator. For political reasons, many member states and many citizens do not believe it is appropriate for the federation to make this demand of the member states. I believe this is in contrast to the EU, where data sharing between authorities of member states regarding federation passports is required by the foundation, but I’m not 100% certain. I hope this helps. Please treat this as a teaching example and do not make immigration, travel, taxation, or citizenship decisions based on it. I am not your lawyer.
- anonunivgrad 6y agoJust a minor nitpick: A US Passport is more than proof of residency. It’s proof of citizenship. When you get a job in the US, your employer needs to check your citizenship. A passport alone does the trick. Otherwise, you need both an ID and some other proof of your right to work, like a birth certificate (birthright citizenship), naturalization card, or a work permit of some kind from the US government (green card and such).