4 ms·
So why don’t we laminate or whatever our glass so it does what car glass does? Saving money?
by Waterluvian 6y ago
So why don’t we laminate or whatever our glass so it does what car glass does? Saving money?
- crististm 6y agoYes. The reason is we don't expect to have as many similar explosions that would make laminating glass necessary everywhere. If we'd expect that, then we'd have bigger problems in the first place.
- redis_mlc 6y agoBeirut has been at war for decades, so it's one city where residential and commercial laminated glass would have made sense.
- avh02 6y agoAs a Lebanese who lived in Lebanon for 5 years (far away now, happily) - I always found it amazing that glass facades were being built on the newer buildings. For a country/city that's known for the occasional explosion it definitely doesn't seem like a good idea (as this event has shown). That said, even regular windows were launched into people's houses (along with their frames) so I guess it wouldn't necessarily help here. Laminating the glass would probably help for your regular/occasional explosion, but not for this, as you'd just have a giant pane smack you hard i guess.
- sukilot 6y agoCar glass is pebbled so it crumbles on impact to minimize damage.
- chii 6y agoit would be (very) expensive to make laminate glass bottles.
- pjc50 6y agoQuite hard to laminate a surface that isn't flat-ish. Bottles etc are just blown. And they're disposable anyway, no point in making them several times more expensive for a rare situation.
- bradstewart 6y agoSeems like using tempered glass for windows in addition to things like shower doors where it's required (in the US) now could help as well. Will still shatter, but won't splinter. I guess that process is also expensive?
- mindslight 6y agoAll architectural glass should be tempered, by safety codes. This is to avoid the problem of non-tempered (annealed) glass only breaking into a few large pieces, creating heavy sheets that will give someone deep lacerations. When you see a window instantaneously shatter into many tiny pieces, that is tempered glass. The energetic breaking of tempered glass still creates a lot of splinters though.
- bradstewart 6y agoWhat is "architectural glass"? Only the bathroom windows in my house are tempered glass. > The energetic breaking of tempered glass still creates a lot of splinters though. Interesting. I guess my only real experience with tempered glass was dropping a shower door while installing it. It absolutely shattered into a million pieces right away, but they weren't what I'd describe as splinters. More like little cubes without particularly sharp. Unless there were also splinters everywhere, and I just didn't notice in the mess of my bathroom.
- mindslight 6y agoIt has to do with the size, but I don't know the limit. Smaller windows aren't going to matter, because pieces won't be large enough to be dangerous. A sliding glass exterior door is always going to be tempered glass, as well as glass tables and shelves. Tempering also makes the glass more impact resistant. I broke a shower door too, while cleaning it. There were definitely splinters mixed in with all those cubes (and some in the hair on my arms). I'd imagine the physics is similar to when you snap a piece of uncooked spaghetti while holding it close to its ends - sometimes you end up with a small energetic middle piece that flies away.