6 ms·
> Uber and Lyft say drivers prefer the flexibility of working as freelancers What would prevent Uber and Lyft from continuing to let employee drivers set their
by criddell 6y ago
> Uber and Lyft say drivers prefer the flexibility of working as freelancers
What would prevent Uber and Lyft from continuing to let employee drivers set their own hours?
- bpodgursky 6y agoBecause benefits like healthcare are gated on the number of hours worked. Uber isn't going to (and can't possibly afford to) pay healthcare for someone who drives 2 hours a week.
- criddell 6y agoSounds like something universal health care could fix. It seems crazy that access to health care is connected to your employment status.
- munk-a 6y agoYea - this is a real employment advantage up here in Canada. Due to lifetime healthcare Canadians tend to cost less in emergency procedures over their lifetime and employers don't need to worry about standard healthcare for employees (drug coverage is still a thing and WorkSafe (basically OSHA) can still end up costing a lot for on-the-job accidents though).
- ars 6y agoUniversal healthcare is not the only way to fix that.... You could use the existing healthcare exchange, and just give people a certain percent of their salary that can only be used to buy healthcare. Then let them buy as they choose.
- three_seagrass 6y agoThe difference being the employers have buying power for all their employees and can keep costs down, as opposed to individual buyers on the exchanges. The problem with switching healthcare in America is that any new system that doesn't allow Americans to think, "I've got mine, you can worry about you" is difficult. Whether that's forced exchanges where everyone pays the same or universal healthcare (where everyone pays the same).
- alextheparrot 6y agoThe existence of employment tied health insurance isn’t that surprising historically. Some of the first companies to offer healthcare were risky jobs where the job could cause harm and then it became more standard as a non-wage perk under wage controls enacted during the second world war. This timing also coincides with the rise of modern medicine as we know it today (Labor, eduction, and R&D intensive). The truly crazy part is that core issues with the system weren’t addressed over the last 70 or so years. Not working should not mean that I’m only able to participate in health-seeking behaviour if I’m wealthy enough to maintain my own health care coverage. Not to mention conflicts of interest, had a former classmate who’s an ER doctor tweet that he saw a patient who’s chronic condition was causing emergency healthcare needs because insurance was paying for treatment every 4 weeks when the doctor prescribed every 3.
- three_seagrass 6y agoYou're right. Health insurance was originally fought for by the unions, which was why they are historically provided by employers in the US. Other nations underwent similar demands from their people, but it ended up being tied to government provision, not corporation. With employee unions being neutered in the past century, and exponential privatized healthcare cost increases, you start to see broad swaths of employees go without insurance in the US, while other countries nationalized their healthcare to keep costs down and continue providing it to their people.
- henryfjordan 6y agoThat's not a reason why Lyft and Uber couldn't just reclassify everyone. That's a consequence of the reclassification, but that's a distinction those companies don't want to make because they'd prefer their drivers be confused. Even if you drove 2 hours a week, there's still 1 reason to prefer being an employee over a contractor: Minimum wage. Uber drivers might only make peanuts once you factor in gas, car payments, and all the time they wait between rides. At least an employee driving 2 hours a week will get a fair paycheck.
- carlosdp 6y agoI highly doubt Uber or Lyft will allow an employee on their payroll to work for only 2 hours a week...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- henryfjordan 6y agoWhy not? They currently do just that...
- twblalock 6y ago> Why not? They currently do just that... Right now they do that for contractors. After the drivers are reclassified as employees, things might change.
- henryfjordan 6y agoThings might also stay the same. There's inertia in the current system and the drivers clearly value their flexibility. Why would things change?
- twblalock 6y agoBecause operating costs increased substantially because of the requirement to provide benefits to workers.
- Cookingboy 6y agoNothing, but since now they have the added cost of health insurance, minimal wage, etc, it would make more sense for them to arrange pre-set shifts for the drivers to optimize for supply/demand based on time of the day. Some drivers would like that arrangement, especially if that's their full time job. But some drivers who do this for supplemental income may not be able to meet the demand of the new fixed schedule set by Uber/Lyft.
- munk-a 6y agoI think Uber & Lyft are just using flexible hours as a red-herring. They certainly can offer flexible hours to full time employees - no where does it say "Americans shalt work from nine until five so sayeth we the founders". They're just griping that they need to start paying benefits.
- Cookingboy 6y ago>They certainly can offer flexible hours to full time employees - no where does it say "Americans shalt work from nine until five so sayeth we the founders". I don't think you understand how a business like this works. For a customer serving business, they need to make sure they are staffed appropriately. Would it make sense for a restaurant to offer all of their staffs "flexible hours"? Is it ok for the waiter to show up at 3am when he has trouble sleeping and just get paid doing nothing? It's not about 9-5, but it's about when the customers show up.
- munk-a 6y agoSorry, I'm really confused, how is moving from contractors to employees supposed to make covering certain periods of the day harder for uber? Normal businesses with normal benefits that hire for off-normal shifts generally pay higher for those shift slots or find an employee that values that shift higher than mid-day and employers absolutely can have an expectation of business hours and fire people for failing to meet that. They can also choose to allow their employees to work more flexible hours but this choice is entirely disconnected from contractor vs. FTE. In the service industry in particular (as you noted above) showing up to work outside of core hours isn't likely to result in any productive work - maybe that waiter could run inventory or do some prep (and actually 3 AM isn't insanely early if you get a big breakfast rush) but that's entirely disconnected from uber saying: "Darn - we wanted to give them flexible hours, but now that they're employees I guess we can't let anyone work after 5PM" that's just BS PR from the company.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThe same reason it doesn't work in other industries: if you pay everyone the same wage and let them pick, everyone will work the quite shifts. This is doubly true for Uber: why would I work a shift when I have to actually drive places and burn gas when I could insist on doing shifts I knew no one would use the service?