3 ms·
This doesn't seem so odd to me because it mirrors common human behavior to judge things based on each step and not the total outcome. One example is when peopl
by SkyBelow 6y ago
This doesn't seem so odd to me because it mirrors common human behavior to judge things based on each step and not the total outcome.
One example is when people pushed for a ban on industries using child labor in SEA without first ensuring there was some fall back safety net that would help those children. The end result was children ending up working far worse jobs than the ones that the western industries were providing. Overall, there seems to be a judgment that any employment of a child is to be judged in isolation and not relative to what other options they have. Society has deemed it is ethically better for me to do nothing despite a child experiencing the ravages of extreme poverty than to intervene in a way that is better for the child but not good enough to meet our expected levels of treatment of children.
Another, more IT centric example, is that it is better to not fix any bugs in a known broken part of the system than to touch it and fix one bug, because you assume responsibility for all the bugs you don't fix. Not every place has this mentality, but I've seen enough which do.
So telling me that society deems it more ethical to offer a worker no option than to offer them a below satisfactory offer doesn't not surprise me at all, despite the outcome of such behavior being too painfully obvious.
Though if we were to invert this, I wonder the outcome because the world over there are enough people experiencing extremely harmful situations where even being offered what we would consider a nightmare is better than leaving them in their current situation. Consider if I wanted someone to be a 24/7 live in maid/butler(cook/cleaner/gardener/etc.) and their pay was $5 a day along with a room, food, basic clothing needed for the job, and access to a computer with internet when they have free time. There are people in situations where this would be a significant improvement in their quality of life, yet I'm not sure any one reading this would approve of me having such a live in maid/butler regardless of what sort of situation they were in before I made the offer.