3 ms·
I don't know that the living get to speak for the dead. If someone comes to your town, kills your parents and burns down your house, but then kidnaps you and ra
by pessimizer 6y ago
I don't know that the living get to speak for the dead. If someone comes to your town, kills your parents and burns down your house, but then kidnaps you and raises you as a servant, it's a bit silly to compare the comforts of your servants' quarters to the hypothetical situation you would have been in if the invaders had never come. Your parents' story is still important, and your guess about how unhappy you would have been in a world that never happened is a rationalized comfort in your current situation. Especially if you are a member of one of the local Christian elites used around the world as a buffer between the colonial power and the land and workers it needed to exploit.
Stories by the colonized about how colonization helped their people are like slate dot com headlines about "Why Getting Cancer Saved My Life."
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoAt the same time, though, a world where everyone's going around trying to avenge their ancestors is a world full of conflict and strife. There are obvious reasons it's problematic to tell people they have to forgive and forget, but I think it's a quite similar problem to tell people they shouldn't.
- merpnderp 6y ago99.99% of our 300,000+ years of history is people going around avenging their ancestors through pillage, enslavement, rape and murder. We're for the most part in a brief moment of respite from the norm, but I'm sure we'll be back to genocide and slavery before long.