9 ms·
I read the statement and think Google used and then and abused their service, but at the same time, publishing a database of people's net worth strikes me as be
by visarga 6y ago
I read the statement and think Google used and then and abused their service, but at the same time, publishing a database of people's net worth strikes me as being pretty unethical. Would they have been able to handle a GDPR request? Why didn't they put their own and their families info up there first?
- throwaway189262 6y agoMakes it even sadder that Google now scrapes all of it and provides the information themselves
- gberger 6y agoIn Sweden, Finland, and Norway, everyone's income tax records are public. Is that unethical?
- mayankkaizen 6y agoMy immediate reaction would be, "yes, it is unethical for many reasons". But again, I heard the social welfare system in these countries is best in the world. So may be I shouldn't complain. However, if I don't want to disclose my net worth and if law is on my side in my country, then Google making my data available is definitely wrong.
- raxxorrax 6y agoI would say it is clearly not unethical, but it can still be a bad decision. I would say it is a disadvantage for everyone in low or medium income regions.
- markalexander 6y agoEthical is a bit of a wide term but I’m sure it’s easy to construct situations that are problematic. E.g. an abusive ex partner can check whether you’re likely to have switched job, even from the most basic info. If tax paid is revealed then you can work out what government benefits a person might be on, including those relating to health and disability. Isn’t the implementation in Norway such that the press have special access not afforded to individuals? That also seems pretty questionable.
- Phaedor 6y agoEveryone have access but you have to log in with your ID and the ones you check can see that you checked them. You can check 500 people each month. Your scenario seems pretty far fetched to me since this information will be published in October for the previous year. It contains the income and tax for the whole year only. It would be pretty difficult to know the information you suggest from the limited, delayed records. As a Norwegian I fully support our system with public tax records.
- op03 6y agoInteresting. Hadn't heard about this before. Curious about how it is used by the public. And can businesses login and check too?
- Phaedor 6y agoArbitrary businesses cannot access it no. However the press can gain special access for a small fee. This means that when the lists are published there are always a lot of news articles about how much various public people earn. There are limitations on how they can use it though, and they cannot publish the whole lists.
- op03 6y agoInteresting. Thanks for posting about it.
- markalexander 6y agoI’m not sure how delayed records would stop you working out disability status or any other sensitive status that affects tax paid. The tax regime for any given year is presumably public info. People are notified but that’s hardly going to stop someone seeking to upset you as in the example scenario. Though as I understand the press can do mass lookups with no notification. Don’t you find that disparity concerning? The idea that the government gets to decide what counts as ‘press’ is already something people from countries that don’t operate that way would consider objectionable. Let alone giving them the power to decide who should be 'outed' for their tax affairs. To be fair, that's perhaps more an issue of this particular implementation, rather than fundamental. But it's an example of how it can be used to entrench the establishment.
- xlii 6y agoIn the transcribed hearing founder makes it clear that it's more about educated guess based on publicly available information. Net worth and not the owned assets which is completely different number (as celebrities usually have rights to their personal brands which are not transferable). In general this in theory could be challenged, but mostly based on the name and photos and not about inferred information. This might get even worse since a lot of celebrities are using stage names which might be protected as a brand but go unprotected as a personal information.