16 ms·
Short on Money, Cities Around the World Try Making Their Own
- cameronbrown 6y agoThis seems like a horrible idea. How does nobody realize that you can't just "will" a currency into having value? A piece of paper won't produce value... At least bitcoin gains it's value from traders buying USD with BTC.
- fatlasp 6y agoUtah Goldbacks seem like an interesting alternative https://goldback.com/ https://goldback.com/
- Kaze404 6y agoYou should tell that to the folks at Japan and North America who have been using complementary currencies since the 1990s.
- Sir_Substance 6y agoLocal councils can create some value by allowing people to pay council taxes, fees and fines with the issued currency. Enough to peg it 1:1 with the USD? I'll be honest, I don't know how countries like panama manage that, so hell if I know how a council would do it. Fundamentally, this is what underwrites the US dollar as well. If you don't pay your taxes you (eventually, provided you aren't connected enough to avoid it) get arrested. You can generate your wealth in corn or software or boat building, but you have to pay your taxes in US dollars. You can't barter your boats for corn and pay your taxes in corn. Thus, (almost) everyone in the US needs some US dollars to avoid being jailed. This is the foundation upon which the value of the US dollar is built. Of course, making sure it doesn't blow up in the councils face in a few months/years time due to lax issuing controls is a different matter.
- magicsmoke 6y agoI suspect there may be a psychological effect giving these currencies value as well, considering they've only been rolled out in small towns. Imagine living in a 2000 population town like in the article where everyone is socially connected. If you refused local currency because you doubted its future value, your business could very quickly become a local pariah. Taxation is necessary to maintain the value of currency when dealing with a country of millions of people, but somewhere on the sliding scale as the population numbers we deal with decrease social factors outweigh purely economic factors. One of the biggest impacts modern capitalism has on human society is its ability to strip away all social considerations from financial decisions. In the premodern world your shopkeeper was also your neighbor, and every transaction was filled with social considerations like your relative wealth, recent hardship, or length of acquaintance. In the modern world, everything has a fixed price regardless of whether the buyer is a foreign stranger or childhood friend. Only by stripping away messy individual social connections does trade among 7 billion people operate efficiently.
- lbotos 6y agoI'm not sure if you are doing some serious meta-trolling about fiat currency or are actually sincere.
- unethical_ban 6y ago"Willing" a currency into having value is exactly what all currency is. I assume you're saying it isn't easy.
- cameronbrown 6y agoSure, and more to the point, currencies tend to be bootstrapped by some value that backs it (gold, oil or even just faith).
- Wildgoose 6y agoThe modern rebirth of local currencies was probably the Austrian town of Wörgl which having been hit badly by the Great Depression recovered magnificently after creating its own local currency in 1932. The currency was so successful it was later forcibly shut down by Austria's Central Bank. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%B6rgl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%B6rgl
- m12k 6y agoIt's amazing how well a society can function, if you ensure that the money that circulates in it doesn't leak out of it, fueling further investment and purchases. I think it's worth actually re-examining our view of globalization and global trade with this in mind.
- dkarp 6y agoI'm no economist, but wouldn't this lead to greater wealth disparity? When money leaks out, it leaks in to somewhere else. Sort of like connecting bodies of water will lower the water level of one body and raise it in another. One place will lose out and another will gain. Unless differences in local taxation/laws/amenities/other lead to wealth/poverty hotspots. With some areas vacuuming up wealth and others repelling it. Is that what this is really solving? Unable to compete on local taxation/laws/amenities/other, cities have to find another way to prevent their wealth being repelled. Sounds like just another wall though. Which can surely never last
- maneesh 6y agoLike entropy, wouldn’t this lead to greater disparity in the short term but uniformness in the long run?
- _nalply 6y agoTo stay in the metaphor, what if a group of people discovered how to create negative pressure? This means they know how to suck money out of a community, probably to enrich themselves.
- 6y ago
- misja111 6y agoI wonder what is wrong with the USA's economy, because the FED is printing dollars like never before to provide liquidity to the economy and still cities have to fall back to initiatives like this one to keep their local economies going. Where did all the dollar liquidity of those cities run away to?
- wallflower 6y agoIn the US, almost every of the 50 states must balance their budgets. They can't spend what they don't have without selling debt (municipal bonds that pay interest). They can't manufacture money as that is handled at the Federal level. https://www.ncsl.org/research/fiscal-policy/state-balanced-budget-requirements-provisions-and.aspx https://www.ncsl.org/research/fiscal-policy/state-balanced-b...
- misja111 6y agoSure, but the FED money is going somewhere in the USA. Either to banks or other companies. Those companies are located in states. So eventually the FED money flows to those 50 states. But it apparently doesn't reach local companies and people, or maybe it does but then it quickly leaks away again. I wonder why that is.
- rapsey 6y agoFED money goes into banks and stocks. Cities do not get any of that FED QE money.
- arthurcolle 6y agoFed has been buying munis
- lbotos 6y agoI haven't been paying close attention and I'm wondering if you know: Are they buying newly issued munis or buying them on the open market?
- beefield 6y agoIt is a bit weird that cryptocurrency folks talk about "disrupting" financial system when they actually talk about rolling monetary policy back to about middle ages. Come up with a currency anyone can create and there you have a real disruption.
- ogogmad 6y agoMore modern doesn't necessarily mean better. That's a fallacy. For instance, it's possible that a currency based on long chains of debt is prone to massive blow-ups. That's modern day fiat currency. In contrast, cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin are not based on debt. > Come up with a currency anyone can create and there you have a real disruption. If I've understood you correctly, something like that does exist. See Ethereum and its ERC-20 tokens.
- Legogris 6y agoIf I interpret beefield correctly, they're not talking about being able to create new currencies but rather a currency that anyone can mint. Here's an interesting one, an attempt at decentralized UBI where each individual gets issued individual "coloured coins" and participants accept currency based on a web of trust: https://handbook.joincircles.net/about/whitepaper.html https://handbook.joincircles.net/about/whitepaper.html I think this direction is very worth exploring. Today fiat currency is generated through creation of debt between banks. Most cryptocurrency is generated through validation of transactions (be it PoW or PoS). The idea of moving currency minting down to individuals in a way that can maintain a sustainable inflation is very attractive to me. The really hard part is squaring the triangle of no privileged centralized parties with censorship capabilities while neither being vulnerable to sybil attacks or locking out disenfranchised minorities from the economy. Circles is the only serious attempt at that I've seen and I'd love to see more innovation and critical analysis in this venue.
- intotheabyss 6y agoYou can create currencies that anyone can mint on Ethereum.
- rspoerri 6y agoNot sure where they are getting the wir-currency facs from. But they are definately wrong about 1/5th of swiss companies using it. 60‘000 members of wir (private&company) versus ~600‘000 businesses in switzerland cant match up with that statement.
- biolurker1 6y agoAny city can create an ethereum token and use it. That's a fundamental aspect of blockchain
- pinkfoot 6y agoMy guess is they are going to owe the IRS a lot of money. In real USD. https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/four-things-you-should-know-if-you-barter https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/four-things-you-should-know-if-...
- Taikonerd 6y agoHeh, good point. I suspect that one of the features of these currencies is that they're not taxed in practice, even if the letter of the law says that they should be(?)
- magicsmoke 6y agoThis right here shows how much the value of USD depends on the power of taxation. Even if you barter goods with no USD used, the IRS will still force you to find a way to obtain USD to pay taxes on that barter.
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoLocal currencies feel like non-malicious ponzi schemes. At some point they're gonna start to die, and anyone holding it will slowly just lose out.
- Kaze404 6y agoThis is pretty much what we're doing at https://cambiatus.io https://cambiatus.io. We have a handful of successful communities that use the platform to a very useful degree, and we're expanding the platform to be able to accommodate other community shapes and needs as well.
- stevewodil 6y agoThat domain doesn't resolve for me, https://www.cambiatus.com/ https://www.cambiatus.com/ works.
- Kaze404 6y agoThank you. We use the io domain for our stating platform so I always get them mixed up :)
- blunte 6y agoI understand that this is expressly forbidden in the US.
- Taikonerd 6y agoIs it? Nobody is stopping Tenino (the city in the article)... nor did they stop them back in 1931.
- blunte 6y agoI'm not an expert of constituional law, but Article I section 10 says: No State shall enter into any Treaty, Alliance, or Confederation; grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal; coin Money; emit Bills of Credit; https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/article-1/section-10/ https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/article-1/section-1...
- Taikonerd 6y agoHuh, interesting. I'm also not a lawyer, but I guess that means that states can't (but cities and towns can)?
- Verdex 6y agoYeah, I thought the silver surfer quarters that came out a while ago ended up with a fine: https://www.coincollector.org/silver-surfer-quarters-declared-illegal-by-us-mint/#:~:text=To%20promote%20the%20upcoming%20film,quarters%20to%20feature%20the%20character https://www.coincollector.org/silver-surfer-quarters-declare.... Although, I suppose someone has to go after them to make it a problem for them.
- hyko 6y agoThese schemes always remind of Paddy’s Bucks from Its Always Sunny in Philadelphia. They are a monetary solution sent in to fight financial problems. The solution to those problems usually lies outside issuing your own money; it instead compounds your problems. There’s probably a case to be made for them if you could find and administer an optimal currency area, which is a monumental challenge.
- wpasc 6y agoThus creating the self sustaining economy
- hyko 6y ago:D
- jonny_wonny 6y ago“I don’t understand how _finance_ works.” - Dennis Reynolds
- ksdale 6y agoI remember reading an economic history book and they mentioned that the Spanish bringing gold to Europe from the Americas stimulated the European economy, and it struck me all at once that basically none of the economic activity in Europe required gold (they weren't making intricate electronics, after all). Growing food, making clothes, tools, shelter, it all could have been done without the gold. What they needed was "money" that everyone believed was valuable in order to convince people to do work. It's the work that causes prosperity, not the gold. I think local currency can function similarly. A lot of people in small towns struggle to turn their skills into dollars, partly because the modern economy values a lot of stuff rather weirdly. Just because their skills aren't easily translatable into dollars globally doesn't mean that they can't still make their local community a much better place, provided there's a way for someone in the local community to communicate that they value the service (which they can't do using dollars, because they also don't have any).
- hammock 6y ago>the Spanish bringing gold to Europe from the Americas stimulated the European economy "Stimulated the economy" is a choice way of looking at it. What it did was create a period of inflation on a scale of size and duration never before seen. It basically led to the decline of Spain as a major world power. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_revolution https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_revolution
- ksdale 6y agoInteresting! Thank you for the link.
- dctoedt 6y agoI've just finished Stephanie Kelton's book on modern monetary theory (MMT), The Deficit Myth, which says much the same thing about any fiat currency: The issuer of a fiat currency is not bound by the same constraints as users of that currency. I'm not quite convinced (although I'm no economist), but it was an interesting "read" (audiobook). The Deficit Myth: https://www.amazon.com/Deficit-Myth-Monetary-Peoples-Economy/dp/B087KJLKCC/ref=sr_1_1 https://www.amazon.com/Deficit-Myth-Monetary-Peoples-Economy... (not an affiliate link) A good MMT primer seems to be a Vox article by Dylan Matthews (TIL he's the son of Jim Matthews, creator of the Fetch FTP client), at https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/4/16/18251646/modern-monetary-theory-new-moment-explained https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/4/16/18251646/modern...
- vonwoodson 6y agoMy grandpa didn’t get the opportunity to empathy much wisdom on my before he died. But, he did tell me “Never take wooden nickels” and that sounds like good advice to me.