6 ms·
As a general rule, the US is terrible at a lot of first-world things for a good reason: because it was the first (or close). We have crappy old subways, airpor
by crazygringo 6y ago
As a general rule, the US is terrible at a lot of first-world things for a good reason: because it was the first (or close).
We have crappy old subways, airports, bridges, skyscrapers, and so on... because we built them early, versions 1.0. And they stuck around.
Other countries had the luxuries of building their versions decades later, when the technology was 2.0 and 3.0 and so on.
So the US is stuck with both old and crappier versions of a lot of stuff, but where it still doesn't make financial sense to rip them out and replace them with the newest.
Our financial system suffers from a lot of similar flaws. E.g. by the time other countries knew enough to base their credit cards on chips+PIN, the US was still stuck with a legacy installed base of stripes+signatures. Money transfers is just one more example.
- pacaro 6y agoBanking in general and international banking, predate the US London, Glasgow, Budapest and Paris all have metro systems that predate the New York Subway There are multiple bridges that are still in use that predate European colonization of North America While the oldest airport is in the US, (College Park), Hamburg, Bucharest, Bremen, Rome, Amsterdam, Paris, Sydney all follow very shortly after AFAICT Skyscrapers is really the only example you give where the US canonically built the v1.0 I think that there are probably other reasons, my suspicion is primarily rent seeking
- alasdair_ 6y agoI’m from Glasgow. Completely random fact ahead: The underground in Glasgow was comprised of orange trains. They “ran like clockwork” and had the nickname “the clockwork orange”, which is where the Stanley Kubrick movie title came from. Allegedly.
- mayankkaizen 6y agoHoly shit! Never thought I'd get to know what Clockwork Orange actually means through a random comment on HN.
- dboreham 6y agoExcept the comment is incorrect. The underground nickname came from the movie not vice versa.
- e2e8 6y agoBased on a quick search, that does not seem to be true. The title of the movie comes from the title of the book it is based on. The book's author has given some explanations for the origin of the title that do not involve Glasgow trains. [0] It seems the name for the subway comes from the movie. There also seems to be some dispute about the usage of that name for the Glasgow subway. [1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Clockwork_Orange_(novel)#Title https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Clockwork_Orange_(novel)#Tit... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glasgow_Subway#Nicknames https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glasgow_Subway#Nicknames
- madamelic 6y agoI have always been under the impression it is because the US wasn't bombed to bits during WWII and didn't basically get to re-think infrastructure.
- Jommi 6y agoMaybe now that its getting bombed to bits because of COVID, something good might end up happening?
- riffraff 6y agoI am not sure this is true, tho it sounds interesting. Before WW2 there wasn't much infrastructure to begin with, the big highways have been built after. The metro lines from before are still there and the bridges that were built before the war have just been rebuilt in the same places (i.e. were the roads arrived and the river was narrow). Most of the big cities also still have medieval and older city centers, and we're still using roman-era routes for roads.
- issa 6y agoBased on things like the Chicago Fire and the SF Quake, it seems (at least anecdotally) clear that massive destruction has a positive effect on infrastructure down the road.
- pacaro 6y agoThe Great Fire of London (CE 1666) did this for London too
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoIn the case of banking you have to realize that US bank accounts here are often completely free, but they will charge you a penalty for anything and everything that is a result of action or inaction on your part (its always your fault). Everything is designed to maximize the chance of your making a mistake so they can charge you a fee.
- Bayart 6y ago>There are multiple bridges that are still in use that predate European colonization of North America There are bridges in use that predate Christianity.
- Gustomaximus 6y agoI dont buy this we were first to do it. Plenty of other countries do continual upgrades to subways, banking, bridges, financial systems etc. My reasons are partly these; 1) I think US tend to think of itself as No.1 nation and makes it less likely to look at other countries doing things better and looking to follow. I think this becomes a mental limitation for many US citizens and policy makers. 2) There is too much corporate capitalism. Money in politics etc. Look at the internet system where Google tried to roll out fibre and there were regions passing laws stop competitors even going into the market. Look at the prices you pay for mobile services. For the world leading free market, there is way to much corruption where markets are restricted rather than government pushing to open established markets to new business when they become entrenched. 3) Over investment in military. US could have that budget, still be the largest military by a mile and be dropping hundreds of billions in building and repairing infrastructure. 4) Too much focus on making money vs doing things well. The desire to keep building a nation seems to be gone. same in my country of Australia. You read history from earlier in the 20th century and they had a view to get things done that would benefit a nation overall. Now its 'would a rail line really pay for itself and be cost effective' type mentality that limits visionary projects. 5) Career politicians. Like other nations I think many career politicians want to take the safe route for reelections. There is endless media criticism of these guys if something goes wrong, and big projects, things do wrong and no-one wants to hear were putting up taxes this year to pay for stuff. No idea how, but we need to filter better for people that believe in what they are doing and have a vision vs popularity based vote for me campaigning. And generally vet them for brains and ability vs I always vote for this party.
- tialaramex 6y agoYour point (1) definitely. Humans are far more alike than they are different so you will be very well served by learning from the experiences of others instead of insisting on making all the mistakes for yourself, not least because some mistakes are fatal. Take US healthcare. There are a lot of models for how you can deliver universal healthcare to all your country's residents. They're all different. They all have problems. They're all better than the current US situation. They're all cheaper for a start, most of them have better outcomes by some measures, often by almost all measures. There was plenty of room for two political parties to have ideological disagreements about how to deliver universal healthcare to Americans as a result. Which examples to follow and which to reject. But the Republicans didn't do that. They decided the hill they wanted to die on (or at least, for some of their voters to die on) was the ideological rejection of universal healthcare as a goal. They would literally tell people it can't be done, despite the fact that every comparable country already did it.
- jdub 6y agoYou'll generally find the rest of the (first) world did 1.0 too. But they invest in public infrastructure, so also did 2.0 and 3.0. The USA is a very strange mix of hyper-first-world and second/third-world, and a lot of it has to do with how taxes are raised and spent.
- xeromal 6y agoThe fact that it has federal and state systems probably bears a portion of the responsibility.
- jdub 6y agoSpain has states with relatively similar state/federal power to the USA. The EU has nation states with more or less power depending where you look. Australia has states, Canada has provinces... One aspect of US taxation and funding that seems wildly out of step: Primarily local funding of schools. Way to build inequality into the system!
- vinay427 6y ago> Spain has states with relatively similar state/federal power to the USA. The EU has nation states with more or less power depending where you look. Australia has states, Canada has provinces... None of these seem like very close comparisons to the US model. There isn't the same legal independence in Spain on a number of matters, from what I recall, but I'll see if I can find a source that provides a direct comparison. For starters, Spain could actually issue centralized coronavirus restrictions and has only recently devolved this to a limited degree to the autonomous communities. A few EU countries may be more relevant, but I think the closest comparison I've found so far is with Switzerland where I currently live. However, the federalism in the US seems to involve a lot more infighting with frequent lawsuits between state and federal agencies.
- alasdair_ 6y agoThis is actually a very good point. Solely as a side note: London has an underground system from 1863 that is still in use today. New York’s subway (the first in the nation) didn’t get going for more than forty years later.
- pjg 6y agoThere is another reason. This is very specific to the way USA does things. It has to do with the role of the government vs. market. Other countries also had an antiquated payments infrastructure e.g. Cheques in Britian, Scandinavian countries etc. The government there simply mandated the dozen or so banks to come up with an instant/real-time payment system and it was rolled out in a few years US has more than 10,000 banks and credit unions. That combined with the fact that US the most "market driven" of the industrialized countries it has take a backseat approach of letting the "market" solve it There have been attempts by the "market" e.g. wallets and lately "push to card" by VISA/MC and RTP by the The Clearing House but it has realized that the Federal Government needs to come up with a standard settlement network with specifications and a protocol that "market" i.e. private companies can build upon. Given the timeline i.e. 2023-2024, it may be a little late since apps and companies building on top of P2C (Push to Card) and RTP (Real-time Payments ) are likely to corner substantial portion of faster 24x365 payments before FedNow is ready. And don't forget even if it's ready on time it'll take another 2-4 years for all the Financial Institutions to connect to it
- oblio 6y agoI wonder if there are a lot of studies of the market "fighting back" progress. Everything about the free market is predicated on informed customer decisions, and if you, as a company, can gaslight consumers effectively through propaganda (let alone lobbying...), then you've basically broken the invisible hand. Have there been studies about this? I'm pretty sure Adam Smith predates mass advertising, branding, modern marketing.
- pembrook 6y agoIt’s even less nefarious than that. To put it simply, humans are creatures of habit. In a vacuum devoid of propaganda, we will still continue to repeat the habits we have developed. Facebook or google don’t need to do any advertising to keep their audience on the platform. That pesky “g-o” you impulsively type into the address bar will do it for them! The only saving grace for humanity is that people die, and not all of their habits get passed to the next generation.
- 6y ago
- throwaway936482 6y agoAs other posters have pointed out this doesn't really hold up. I suspect it's more that since the Reagan era the USA has frequently had a self hating government, that is a government run by people that believe government itself is bad. This has led to a lot of intentional neglect and sabotage of infrastructure in the belief that "the market" will magically provide public goods. We have similar issies in the UK
- bjohnson225 6y agoEurope has many old subways and bridges too and like in the US they can be difficult to upgrade for cost reasons. (E.g. The London Underground still lacks air con on some lines because of narrow tunnels; there are parts of the network built with asbestos in the tunnels. In both cases fixing it would require closing the line and rebuilding the tunnel, so it doesn’t happen) That’s not true in banking though where many upgrades are software based and not so disruptive/expensive. The UK, and presumably other countries, did not start from the systems we have today - we moved from signatures to chip & pin, and from checks to bank transfers to instant bank transfers. My parents would write checks all the time when I was growing up, but I’m in my late 20s and have never written one in my life.
- dboreham 6y agoThere's another reason besides being first: corruption.
- bildung 6y ago> As a general rule, the US is terrible at a lot of first-world things for a good reason: because it was the first (or close). Is that really true? ATMs were first in Europe and Japan, BACS in the UK is older than ACH in the US. I think this is more about lack of coordination (i.e. political reasons) than something like a natural first mover disadvantage. German debit cards for example simply had both stripes and chip for the transition period.