5 ms·
Did anyone notice how cheap this is? Ten gigawatts at AUD $16B is roughly the same as 1 GW per USD $1B. Compare that to, say, a nuclear power plant, where a sin
by jiggawatts 6y ago
Did anyone notice how cheap this is? Ten gigawatts at AUD $16B is roughly the same as 1 GW per USD $1B. Compare that to, say, a nuclear power plant, where a single 1 GW plant might cost five to ten billion after all of the approvals and the interest on the loan.
If the price estimate is correct, Singapore would be crazy not to do it. The only issue I see is the risk of cable cuts and future geopolitical changes.
Unfortunately, within Australia, coal is currently so cheap that even low-cost solar can't really compete.
- jeffbee 6y ago1 GW per billion dollars is dirt-cheap compared to solar power in America, too. Thinking of two of the largest PV installations in California. One was $2.4 billion for 550 MW and another was $1 billion for 130 MW.
- cbo100 6y agoJust pointing out the article had already converted AUD$22B into US$16B. (Not sure if that was updated since you posted) Still using your other numbers, seems like a bargain, even at US$1.6B/GW
- hokkos 6y agoThat is a 10GW solar array, at 22% capacity factor, so comparable to 2 VVER-1200 with a $12B contract like Rooppur, also the solar panels/batteries will last 20-25 years and the VVER 60.
- toomuchtodo 6y ago> also the solar panels/batteries will last 20-25 years and the VVER 60 The solar array and battery storage (all of which can be recycled today with existing recycling techniques) will be built on time, begin generating on time, and will generate no nuclear waste nor require fuel (besides sunlight) during its operating lifetime. It takes over 10 years to build a VVER-1200 reactor [1] (any fission reactor, really), if you can even get the reactor to the finish line. [1] https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/NN-First-VVER-1200-reactor-enters-commercial-operation-02031701.html https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/NN-First-VVER-1200-reacto...
- alex_young 6y ago> will generate no nuclear waste Very important point, especially when we're considering costs. What are the lifetime costs associated with storing the spent fuel? In practice, the only way to get reactors built, is for the public to 100% subsidize the long term consequences.
- devdas 6y agoOr recycle the fuel.
- alex_young 6y agoSure, that would be an option. Thus far even the US government is not exploring this option, mostly due to very high costs, but also due to weapons grade byproducts of most existing reprocessing methods.
- roenxi 6y ago> The solar array and battery storage (all of which can be recycled today with existing recycling techniques) will be built on time, begin generating on time... Steady on, that is a prediction for a project where data is light. The most comparable experience Australia has to this stuff is the Basslink which broke in 2015-16 and triggered a major energy crisis in Tasmania. And I think technically means that 50% of Australia's major undersea cables have been involved in an energy crisis. This is a major project. It is not yet clear it will be delivered on time and on budget. It is very a very exciting project nonetheless.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoMaintenance and redundancy of HVDC transmission capacity is a more tractable problem than cost efficient storage & reprocessing of nuclear waste and nuclear generator decommissioning at end of service life. Basslink was mismanaged, and that's a tractable problem as well. Could this project be late? Of course. "Nuclear generator late and over budget"? No.
- coverj 6y agosorry, could you dumb this down a little? how does this affect the price/GW? (I'm not questioning it does, I'm saying I don't understand the rest of what you said)
- msandford 6y agoI think the idea is that 10GW of solar only produces on average as much power as a 2.2GW "normal" power plant. So during the best parts of the day you're getting all 10GW. At night you're getting 0GW. On cloudy days you're getting less than 10GW. If you average it all out over a year you get about the same amount of total energy output from the 10GW solar plant as you would a 2.2GW traditional power plant. So once you do that it goes from $1/watt to more like $4.50/watt. And it starts to look about the same as nuclear if in fact you can spend $5b and you get 1GW. One nice thing about nuclear is that it's super steady 1GW 24/7 vs the solar needs to have battery storage too, and those batteries aren't free.
- coverj 6y agothank you for the explanation!
- bobthepanda 6y agoThis project has battery included as well though. Given that solar's cost trend has been going ever cheaper and nuclear's has done pretty much the opposite, solar will probably win out long term.
- msandford 6y agoOh that's my mistake then! I read the article looking for that but I didn't see it. I guess I didn't read it thoroughly enough. I do agree that over the course of the next 10-50 years renewables + storage is likely to be cheaper. What I'm not sure about is if "the grid" will be cheaper or if we'll end up seeing the renewables self-ownership spiral that causes folks to disconnect from the grid, driving prices up for everyone else on the grid, thus causing more people to disconnect, etc. When renewables are cheap and your house's usage is fairly well known (see years of smart meter historical data) then at some point it becomes economically feasible to be your own grid.
- nl 6y ago> Unfortunately, within Australia, coal is currently so cheap that even low-cost solar can't really compete. That's only true for existing power stations. For new coal stations there is no way to make them competitive with large scale solar or wind. The levelized cost of power from new coal plants is calculated to be between $76 per megawatt hour and $205.60 per megawatt hour depending on black vs brown coal, if you include a risk premium on financing and whose estimates you believe. In 2017 the Victorian government signed a 12 year deal for $50 to $60 per megawatt hour for a wind farm, and the new Golden Plains wind farm will be under $50/MWh. Adding storage costs a bit more: between $83.40 and $129.30 per MW/h for pumped hydro storage, or $138/MWh for batteries. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-09-12/is-renewable-power-cheaper-than-coal-nuclear-malcolm-turnbull/11495558 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-09-12/is-renewable-power-ch...
- waheoo 6y agoSolar went negative last summer. So that's not totally accurate.
- gok 6y agoIt's US$16B, and 10 gigawatts is nameplate. 25% capacity factors are typical for solar PV, whereas nuclear would be more like 90%. So it would compare more accurately to a ~2.8 GW nuclear power plant.
- dwd 6y agoSingapore is one of Australia's links to the Internet so additional cables for power would possibly follow the same route.
- bamboozled 6y agoIf you mean coal based power is currently cheap within Australia, it's absolutely the opposite, electricity prices in Australia are some of the highest in the world: https://www.globalpetrolprices.com/electricity_prices/ https://www.globalpetrolprices.com/electricity_prices/
- qtplatypus 6y agoHousehold power prices are not the same as the wholesale rate. Indeed sometimes the wholesale rate is negative. South Australia is $73.25/MWh
- bamboozled 6y agoI believe South Australia has the most wind, solar and battery storage though.
- dctoedt 6y ago> the risk of cable cuts and future geopolitical changes The two risks are intertwined: A hostile state in the region with modern submarines (gee, I wonder who that could be?) is likely to be perfectly capable of cutting the cable — which would give the hostile state the ability to hold Singapore hostage, perhaps in support of exerting power in the Strait of Malacca maritime choke point and/or in the South China Sea. If I were Singapore's leaders, I'd want at least one Plan B.
- api 6y agoSufficient gas peaker capacity? The solar might be cheaper, but if it got cut you could fire them up.