4 ms·
My anecdote data. I'm living in Kazakhstan and there's an interesting observation. We used to have lots of cockroaches in houses, especially when houses were no
by vbezhenar 6y ago
My anecdote data. I'm living in Kazakhstan and there's an interesting observation. We used to have lots of cockroaches in houses, especially when houses were not very clean. It was, I think, before 1995. It seems the same with our post-USSR neighbour countries (Russia, and so on). I used to live in such a flat, where lots of cockroaches were running in the kitchen at night. I remember as a child that we tried different chemicals to fight them, but with little success. And it was similar for many other people.
And at some point they were just gone. From everyone's house. It was not just one day, but we just understood that there are no cockroaches around.
It's still possible to find them somewhere, I guess, but that's a rare event. Something's changed.
Some people think that's because chemicals finally became effective and eradicated them. And some people think that's because of cellular networks which appeared everywhere around that time. I never found definitive answer, just speculations.
- thefounder 6y agolol! You still find cockroaches around regardless of wi-fi or 4g signal
- partyboat1586 6y agoClearly he doesn't. Do you?
- arcturus17 6y agoI live in Madrid, which is a fairly clean city compared to other places I’ve lived. We have loads of roaches, especially in the summer. We also have absurd 4G and Wifi coverage. I can only connect to the 5ghz Wifi band at home because 2.4 is saturated by the neighbors. There are still roaches where I live... Funny thing, in the house where I grew up, I saw the same phenomenon as GP. We had constant roach infestations in the kitchen, and after years of different chemical treatments, they were suddenly gone for good. Always attributed it to an effective chemical or a random biological process. Still see them in other places in the city nevertheless. Why are we even entertaining this on Hacker News though? Show me the papers, GP’s anecdotes or mine are worthless.
- partyboat1586 6y agoBetter to counter an anecdote with an opposite anecdote than to downvote or shutdown. To some people being shut down proves they are right. Countering like you did provides a natural way to show the weakness of anecdotes.
- pas 6y agoI live in a city with WiFi and 4G (and 5G in a few spots) and roaches. I just checked the 5G map. I saw roaches where there's 5G. So if it makes some difference, it's not much.
- jiggawatts 6y agoIt's cockroach-specific poisons. The building management probably deployed one of the new ones. They're incredibly effective compared to the older style, as much as 500x better. The problem with cockroaches is that they'll eat a small amount of something, throw it up, and then avoid it. Even if you just barely kill one, it'll just die, and its hundreds of children will replace it. Modern poisons are tasteless, odourless, and aren't directly poisonous, so the cockroach doesn't feel bad and doesn't throw up. It can't learn to avoid it. These chemicals are designed to be converted into a poison by an enzyme in the body of the cockroach, slowly. This means that the chemical is basically harmless to pets, humans, and other animals, but lethal to this one insect species. It also allows the roach to consume hundreds of times a lethal dose before starting to succumb to the effects. When it does eventually throw up and die, any other roaches that consume the vomit (I know, eww, but apparently this happens) are eating the precursor, not the poison, and once again can easily consume many times the lethal dose. This has a multiplying effect on the efficacy, as roaches will often throw up and die in their nest, poisoning their entire brood. As anecdotal evidence: I had WiFi and 4G in my previous apartment, but roaches everywhere. I deployed the roach bait gel, and they vanished. My new apartment has 1 bar of mobile reception, but there are no roaches anywhere because here the building management gets an exterminator to put out roach poison gel. That's probably why you've seen the roaches disappear: the marvels of modern chemistry, not physics!
- tootie 6y agoI live in NYC which may be both the roach capital of the world and the most thoroughly saturated with RF signals. I can assure you, there is no correlation. Roach killing chemicals have definitely gotten more effective, but also they're starting to proliferate again due to the warming environment.