12 ms·
Hiroshima (1946)
- sorokod 6y agoKazutoshi Hando, The Pacific War Research Society, Japan's Longest Day (Tokyo: Kodansha International, Ltd., 1968), pp. 11-53. https://web.archive.org/web/20110225124451/http://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/hando/hando.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20110225124451/http://www.mtholy...
- dang 6y agoIf curious see also 2018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18536235 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18536235 2016 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11750331 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11750331
- supernova87a 6y agoWhen I was young in grade school, and learned about the bomb, and its terrifying aftermath, pictures, scars, I thought that this was clearly a wrong against humanity to have been dropped on anyone. Clearly the visceral kind of "this should never happen" reaction that any average person would have. "How could we put the Enola Gay on a stamp to glorify this?" Then, in college and especially after, learning about the equal horrors of the Japanese war machine, and maybe actually more the non-horrific but relentless robotic support for the war (or obedience towards the emperor, government, etc) among the people, I realized that it actually did bring an end to the war. Which if it had continued, could have consumed far more lives. (whether it had to be this tool, of course, is certainly worthy of debate) Now, my 3rd phase of thinking -- beyond any opinion on tactics or reaction or bombs in the moment of a war -- is how do we get people to help themselves get out of the path to war? Each and every one of us, who whether by support or indifference, or tacit approval, or compounded misinformation, or ego, get ourselves into situations that we look back 50 years from now and say, "what happened?". Surely, we have the tools and desire, don't we? I hope.
- Hokusai 6y ago> and maybe actually more the non-horrific but relentless robotic support for the war (or obedience towards the emperor, government, etc) among the people That is a lot of words to say "civilians trying to survive during a war". To make it even worse, the war criminals, that ones that were part of the "horrors of the Japanese war machine" were spared by the USA after the war. Fearing an increase influence of Communism in Asia, the USA let the war criminals go unpunished. Targeting civilians while sparing war criminals is hardly a moral stand point.
- jacobush 6y agoThere’s no consensus it ended the war. Rather the opposite. The Japanese generals had larger problems to consider, such as the fact that most targets were already rubble, and the fact that the Soviets were on their doorstep.
- rbecker 6y agoThis article elaborates that the bombings probably weren't necessary: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24093814 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24093814
- valuearb 6y agoStrange, as the Japanese military mutinied when the Emperor ordered the surrender.
- jacobush 6y agoWhich in no way invalidates what I’m saying? Just a different outlook on how the war should be handled.
- eska 6y agoMy school education about this was also essentially "bombs are bad, kids". The Wikipedia article (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_and_Nagasaki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_a...) is actually quite enlightening in this matter. A lot of people seem to think that the Americans didn't try anything else before. Likewise most people don't realize how much more death there would've been on both sides if the US invaded Japan by sea.
- renewiltord 6y agoIt strikes me as odd that practically any victorious military finds all of its actions optimal. If it had not done as it did, then the outcomes would be worse. The regularity of the superiority of the action taken is fascinating. Curiously, this website has a large number of commentators that believe that luck is one of the biggest factors in startup success. Yet, in this other domain of antagonistic participants, war, the victor is always the better strategist, having seen through the flaws of his enemy. Mere luck plays no part here. A curious result to me. It appears that Man is elevated to supreme intelligence when tasked with war, and finds himself a mere leaf on air currents otherwise. Of course, I’m no peacenik. I have no problem over-bombing a population so I don’t really see Hiroshima and Nagasaki as tragedies. Since no one has an incentive to reveal the true minimum that would cause them to capitulate, it is usually a good idea when you’re almost winning to make sure you’re definitely winning. I have no problem with the death of those who would prefer my death. Just fascinated at how we conquer luck in this sphere alone.
- the_af 6y ago> I have no problem with the death of those who would prefer my death What about those who have no opinion one way or the other about your death, or are incapable of having an informed opinion, such as very young children?
- renewiltord 6y agoWell, this is a personal position so I don’t see the value in sharing it, but since you asked: I’d rather be alive and evil than dead and good. After all, alive and evil I can be redeemed and die good after a fulfilling life. If I win, presumably following generations will talk about my courage at having turned my life around and any detractors of mine will find themselves outdone by my supporters - who will either be more numerous or will have the ability to call my detractors hypocrites since they only exist by my actions. So the children will die if they must die. And they will live if it does not affect victory.
- senand 6y agoEven assuming it did bring an end to the war: was it really necessary to drop two bombs for that?
- renewiltord 6y agoConventional wisdom is that you have to prove you can do it on demand rather than it being a one and done. If you have one, it could be the last one. If you have two, you could have infinity.
- eska 6y agoAnd the first one was likely to be a dud, thereby completely removing the psychological effect from further atomic bombs, of which there was only one for the next couple months.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoWiping out one city in one single gigantic unprecedented flash was pretty convincing.
- catalogia 6y agoNot to everybody it wasn't. Some Japanese officers wanted to keep fighting even after two cities were wiped out. (Three if you count the firebombing of Tokyo, which you probably should...) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ky%C5%ABj%C5%8D_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ky%C5%ABj%C5%8D_incident As proven earlier with Operation Ten-Go / The Battle of the East China Sea, many in the Japanese military preferred spiteful suicidal attacks to surrender, even when the hopelessness of their situation was abundantly clear. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Ten-Go https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Ten-Go
- claudiawerner 6y agoAn interesting point here, in the Wikipedia article on the atomic bombings, that Japanese nuclear scientists reported to their government that the US could be expected to have between two and four more such bombs ready to go. They were under no illusions that the US had hundreds of these sitting around.
- Entwickler 6y agoI've heard the idea that atomic bombs were the deciding factor in ending the war is in large part American propaganda. The fact is the Soviets had far superior divisions (in both manpower and fire power) lined up against the Japanese in Manchuria, and shattered them within weeks. From wikipedia(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Japanese_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Japanese_War), "Tsuyoshi Hasegawa's research has led him to conclude that the atomic bombings were not the principal reason for Japan's capitulation. He argues that Japan's leaders were impacted more by the swift and devastating Soviet victories on the mainland in the week after Joseph Stalin's August 8 declaration of war because the Japanese strategy to protect the home islands was designed to fend off an Allied invasion from the south and left virtually no spare troops to counter a Soviet threat from the north. Furthermore, the Japanese could no longer hope to achieve a negotiated peace with the Allies by using the Soviet Union as a mediator with the Soviet declaration of war. That, according to Hasegawa, amounted to a "strategic bankruptcy" for the Japanese and forced their message of surrender on August 15, 1945.[39][16] Others with similar views include the Battlefield series documentary,[2][11] among others, but all, including Hasegawa, state that the surrender was not caused by only one factor or event."
- purple-again 6y agoIn the surrendering words of the emperor himself the atomic bomb is directly mentioned as one reason for the surrender.
- catalogia 6y agoWords which almost weren't heard at all because some parts of the Japanese military attempted to prevent the surrender from being published.
- edflsafoiewq 6y agoHe also says: "Indeed, we declared war on America and Britain out of our sincere desire to ensure Japan's self-preservation and the stabilization of East Asia, it being far from our thought either to infringe upon the sovereignty of other nations or to embark upon territorial aggrandizement." The Jewel Voice Broadcast should not be read uncritically.
- EarthIsHome 6y agoFor those interested in arguments about whether the bombings were necessary, there's a good Wikipedia article: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debate_over_the_atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_and_Nagasaki https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debate_over_the_atomic_bombi... I do believe the bombings were a strategic show-of-force to the Soviet Union since they were coming out of the war as a global power; USSR were instrumental in ending the war.
- missedthecue 6y agoThe fact that the military is still awarding Purple Hearts that were manufactured for the invasion of Japan tells me that it was more than justified. Japanese intelligence itself estimated 20 million casualties during an invasion.
- pmachinery 6y agoRegardless of the number, there was no need to invade Japan. It was already defeated, and offering to surrender, before the USSR joined the fight. Totally surrounded/blockaded, no allies left in the world, bombed at will, what else could it do but accept defeat?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- manfredo 6y agoOffering to surrender conditionally. Specifically, on the condition that it keep Korea and Taiwan (and maybe Manchuria, too), and that it's military government remain largely unchanged. This is was not a surrender that was acceptable to the Allies. This thread is being rate limited, reply in edit: Denying Korea and Taiwan is easier said than done. Remember that Japan essentially won the continental war against China. It's best equipped and most experienced troops are there. Japan is also in an optimal position to control ocean access to Korea. Any boats have to travel through the East China Sea, or sea of Japan to reach Korea. Both of which are in range of the thousands of kamikaze planes built for the purpose of destroying vessels that sail close to Japan. At this point, you're talking about conducting an invasion of a landmass even larger than the Japanese home islands, against better troops, and with more difficult naval access. It would undoubtedly incur substantially more losses than the 100 to 200 thousand inflicted by the atomic bombings. And to what end? A hostile military government would still be in power back in Japan.
- the_af 6y ago> I realized that it actually did bring an end to the war This may be the mainstream opinion in the US, but do note it's not the mainstream opinion in other countries. Alternative explanations include that the real purpose of the two bombs was to show the Soviets the nuclear might of the US (this view is suggested in the Hiroshima museum in Japan, but just in case you discount it because Japan is obviously not a neutral party, this opinion is also held in some countries in Latin America -- even some people in the US believe this). Even at the time, some people in the US army opposed the bombing and believed it had no military justification.
- manfredo 6y agoNecessity and justification are two different concepts. Few believe it was necessary - the United States' overwhelming industrial capacity was bound to prevail over Japan. The state of the two countries warmaking capacity was totally lopsided by 1945. Thus it was not necessary to achieve victory. That is brought an end to the war with fewer casualties, both American and Japanese even moreso, is not a difficult claim to support. Japan planned to fight a defensive war against an amphibious invasion in order to negotiate more favorable surrender terms. The Japanese estimated that this would incur 20 million Japanese casualties, and this plan was approved. Even if we assume that Japan's war machine would collapse before this figure of lives lost was reached, it is almost certain that the death toll would be in the millions. Germany, without the advantage of being a mountainous island nation and having a lower population than Japan, fought on its own soil in 1945 to the effect of several million dead. Thus, it's almost certain that the atomic bombings resulted in an order of magnitude fewer Japanese lives lost than an conventional invasion.
- hutzlibu 6y agoYes, but maybe the bombs would have had the same effect, if dropped on actual military targets (or even unhabitated land, but close enough to demonstrate the power) instead of an civilian city. (a city with military production, sure sure, but they were choosen not because of military value, but because they were relatively undamaged, so the effect of the bombs could be studied. Concern for loss of japan civilian live was never an issue)
- rland 6y agoWe had a discussion about this in high school, I think my junior year. Most of these types of discussions were very lopsided, so the teacher would usually have to encourage people to take the “bad/unpopular” position somehow. But this one was right down the line in my class and produced a lively debate. I still think about it, but my opinion hasn’t changed — it was the correct decision.
- j-james 6y agoMy Modern World History class in high school also did this. Our debate came down to whether or not directly / immediately killing hundreds of thousands of citizens was justified by potentially preventing even more dying in a subsequent invasion. The class was similarly split.
- KingOfCoders 6y agoWhile instead the high school should have taught about false dilemmas.
- renewiltord 6y agoA fascinating comparison with British steadfast resolve in the face of overwhelming force. Britons would fight on the beaches, and on the landing grounds and streets. They would never surrender, even against overwhelming odds. Truly inspiring in comparison with the robotic obedience of the Japanese who would dig in to protect their island, whatever the cost may be.
- jmknoll 6y agoI see the point you’re trying to make, and by no means am I saying that the British were without fault, but there is a very significant difference between the the British defending their liberal democracy from Nazi domination and a largely rural, largely uneducated Japanese population being conscripted into fighting a war of aggression on behalf of a totalitarian state.
- goto11 6y agoYes and no - UK was actually a colonial empire at the time of WWII and had conquered and subjugated more land and peoples than the Japanese ever managed. While the UK itself could be termed a liberal democracy, most of its subjects had no say.
- quietbritishjim 6y ago* A rousing public speech is very different from actual policy. A sibiling comment to yours make reference to a plan by the Japanese, made in secret and actually started, that was known to cost millions of Japanese lives and wasn't even meant to secure victory but just better surrender terms. Your quotation doesn't come close to showing that the British would be prepared to do something similar. (In fact I'm sure I read about a plan Churchill had to surrender if Germans did make it onto British soil, but I'm not going to search for it now - the burden is on you to show that the British wouldn't have surrendered.) * Aside from broad policy, the difference in attitude is clearly shown by actions of individual soldiers. Individual Britons in theatre would usually be prepared to surrender if their situation was hopeless, as shown by the number of actual British PoWs in WW2, whereas this was much rarer for Japanese soldiers.
- 6y ago
- kingkawn 6y agoA quote from General Dwight D. Eisenhower, “Japan at the moment was seeking a way to surrender with a minimum loss of face. It wasn’t necessary to hit them with that awful thing.” There are more quotes, but basically everything you were taught about the necessity of wiping out hundreds of thousands of people in a flash was after the fact American propaganda to justify a war crime.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "Japan at the moment was seeking a way to surrender with a minimum loss of face" Not really; some in Japan were seeking a surrender and some, notably nearly all of the Japanese military, were quite definitively not. Had the internal coup intended to prevent the surrender succeeded (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ky%C5%ABj%C5%8D_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ky%C5%ABj%C5%8D_incident), Eisenhower's quote would have been entirely false instead of a half-truth.
- kingkawn 6y agoYou know more than Eisenhower?
- gen220 6y agoThe Eisenhower quote is from 1963. He was not a general in the pacific theater, and was not involved in postwar Japan. IMO, his quote should be read as that of a politician (which he was, at that point, having served two terms as president), rather than that of a military general. It was not so cut and dry, as his words imply.
- kingkawn 6y agoSo you do think you know more than Eisenhower. Fascinating belief. The strategic bombing survey of 1946, subject to no objections about Eisenhower’s relative objectivity compared to your own, concludes that the Japanese government was well into the process of determining how to surrender, with predictable resistance from the military but endorsement by the Emperor as they were in the process of determining how to stand down. It also points out that the majority of the populace had already lost hope for the war effort, which is now the bomb’s justification. https://www.trumanlibrary.gov/library/research-files/united-states-strategic-bombing-survey-effects-atomic-bombs-hiroshima-and?documentid=NA&pagenumber=24 https://www.trumanlibrary.gov/library/research-files/united-...
- dylan604 6y ago> Surely, we have the tools and desire, don't we? I hope. Military conflicts through out the world since suggest we do not.
- ChomskyNormal4m 6y ago> horrors of the Japanese war machine, and maybe actually more the non-horrific but relentless robotic support for the war (or obedience towards the emperor, government, etc) among the people When you think of the black ships of the Perry expedition, and then forward to the Japanese attack on England's Hong Kong colony, the French colonies in Indochina, America's colony in the Philippines (and Hawaii!) - then you see the above blurb is a perfect encapsulation of the western bourgeois mind.
- antisthenes 6y agoYou've recreated the Ultimate Ideal from movie Hero (2002) 1. Mastery of a weapon and combat (the nuclear weapon) 2. Weapon not in hand, but in the hearts and minds (loyalty and devotion to the cause) 3. The ultimate ideal - the weapon disappears altogether, and the warrior is at peace with the world.
- ekianjo 6y ago> I realized that it actually did bring an end to the war. Then you have been fed propaganda. The bomb had nothing to do with Japan surrendering.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> When I was young in grade school, and learned about the bomb, and its terrifying aftermath, pictures, scars, I thought that this was clearly a wrong against humanity to have been dropped on anyone. Clearly the visceral kind of "this should never happen" reaction that any average person would have. "How could we put the Enola Gay on a stamp to glorify this?" This is captured very well in Leiji Matsumoto's "The Cockpit" anime short, where in the protagonist, a Nazi Luftwaffe Pilot, is faced with the dilemma where Nazis had access to Nuclear weapons before the Allies but ultimately told from the perspective of the Japanese and perhaps even the Hibakusha themselves as he was born in 1938 and saw the the War in Japan first hand in this lifetime. It's pretty heavy stuff but conveys how this technology should not be in the hands of Humans in their current form, as its not worth the risk of the inevitable usecases we've collectively created thus far. > Now, my 3rd phase of thinking -- beyond any opinion on tactics or reaction or bombs in the moment of a war -- is how do we get people to help themselves get out of the path to war? Each and every one of us, who whether by support or indifference, or tacit approval, or compounded misinformation, or ego, get ourselves into situations that we look back 50 years from now and say, "what happened?". Honestly, War, especially to that massive destructive scale is only capable under the Nation-State model, which is what initially got me interested in Anarchism: as a tool for effective Anti-war measures. I just fear Humanity may never truly be able to accept a Social model in which the State model is entirely absent and unnecessary before these things occur again, look how close this US vs CCP rhetoric is stoking the flames of potentially WW3 (both nuclear capable) when we have a so many ongoing crises that need the collective focus of all of Humanity to come close to even trying to solve. Sidenote: The bombing of Horoshima and Nagasaki took place after the US had effectively crippled the Japanese economy and supply lines in a nation with no natural resources of their own. Its often speculated about how much longer they could have put up a resistance, prolonging Japan's defeat, and what would ultimately create a near permanent occupation by the US, but the War effort and the manufacturing of these armaments to the level they had before was impossible by the time Fat Man and Little Boy entered the Pacific theater. Moreover, the constant conventional bombing and air raids of Tokyo by Allies (Tokyo Daikushu) claimed more lives (that still stands to this day) than both Nuclear bombs combined at the time of it being dropped, but the tragic thing being that that Hibakusha and their descendants still suffer long after the Empire fell, but still live with the horrible birth defects and health issues to this day. The way the US via GE and Westinghouse imposed Nuclear technology on them was perhaps the most cloaked dagger to Humanity I have ever seen in the reconstruction phase of all the 'axis' nations when you see how devastating Fukushima is (at the hands of TEPCO/Abe Government) that continues to pour massive nuclear contaminated water into the Pacific Ocean to this day. The lesson (hopefully) being, that no one 'won' and all of Humanity 'lost' as we probably embarked on a very dark and destructive phase of our Human Condition that we probably would have been better not knowing we were capable of as a Species. Just look at the tragic plight of the Marshall Islands in the race for other nations to be Nuclear capable as well.
- pmoleri 6y ago> Which if it had continued, could have consumed far more lives. Everything along these lines are counterfactual excercises and a nice way of justify the crime of dropping nuclear bombs on cities full of civilians. I don't buy this. And something we all know is that history is told by the victors.
- magicsmoke 6y agoTokyo was already firebombed and terror bombing of civilian cities was a tactic used by all sides in WW2. If bombing civilians is a war crime, then everyone in WW2 is a war criminal. As for the civilian getting bombed, whether the fire melting their flesh away has a hint of radioactivity is a really minor addition.
- pmoleri 6y agoThat kind of reasoning can be used to justify all kind of things that are considered crimes. Wipe out 200K in one action just to show power seems too much. I don't accept that the amount of creativity used to create weapons cannot be applied also to use them more wisely in ways that don't wipe out 200k.
- mulmen 6y ago> [...] how do we get people to help themselves get out of the path to war? Philosophically I find this revolting. Who are you, or me, or we to say what some other society should do? That should never be the goal and I don’t think anything good comes from starting with “other people are wrong, we should fix them.” I realize I’m putting hyperbolic words in your mouth here but the point is nobody should be trusted with that kind of power. > Surely, we have the tools and desire, don't we? I hope. No, I don’t think we do. And if we did they would be more devastating than nuclear weapons. The closest thing is social media.
- loco5niner 6y agoIt sounds like you are saying that it's wrong to say "war is bad, let's avoid killing each other". If true, your "philosophies" are in serious need of self-reflection.
- KingOfCoders 6y agoI thought it was settled now that the entry of the Soviet Union in the Pacific theatre ended the war, not the two (!) atomic bombs - it's a sad fact that Nagasaki is so often forgotten. The US had already destroyed mostly all Japanese cities. There was no large difference between a firestorm bombing and the bombs to Japanese cities. In Tokyo more than 700.000 buildings were destroyed and in one night more than 100.000 people killed by fire bombing. The only difference was one of efficiency. It took 280 B-29 to kill 100k people in one night in Tokyo while it took 1 B-29 to kill 100k people in Hiroshima.
- Ste_Evans 6y ago"how do we get people to help themselves get out of the path to war?" A good start would be to learn the facts. US-Japanese history didn't begin with Pearl Harbour. Edo-Japan was minding its own business before the Black Ships arrived. How many Americans know about the atrocities the US committed in the Philippines? The Japanese saw what was heading their way from the US and Europe.
- dkyc 6y agoThe pop-up advertising a 'flash sale' over the first paragraph couldn't have been placed worse.
- terrorOf 6y agoGiven what Japanese have done to other non-Japanese (disgusting experiment on people alive) as well as Pearl Habor, and also given that they do not sincerely apologize on what they have done during the war before atomic bomb, I don't think they deserve apologizing. Also as what "dang" found out duplicated article from 2016 and 2018, I feel this is kind of money-supported ad by Japanese government.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThe allies had already started to resort to obliterating whole cities and their inhabitants before Hiroshima (see Dresden, Tokyo). IMHO, this was not the result of how "evil" the German and Japanese regimes were (which seems to me to be a rationalization) but the result of 5 years of total war. I think that at some point people came to accept doing whatever it took to win and end the war. In the context of what was going on I think dropping atomic bombs to precipitate the end of the war and send a message to the Soviets was perhaps not considered as big a deal as we might think because, as said, the result was already accepted looking at the conventional bombing raids that had taken place. War is hell and total war means total hell.
- willis936 6y ago>IMHO, this was not the result of how "evil" the German and Japanese regimes were (which seems to me to be a rationalization) More than ten million killed in war crimes by Japan alone in less than 15 years. These weren’t some secret at the time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_war_crimes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_war_crimes
- gen220 6y agoFWIW, the goal of the allied bombing campaign was always to cripple the adversary nation by bombing industrial infrastructure; the doctrine pre-dated the outbreak of WW II. The invention of radar-assisted targeting thwarted this mission in the early phases of the war in Europe, and it took a tech arms race to get past it. In the Pacific, the US’s primary objective was to secure an air base within strategic bombing range of Japan. It pursued this by capturing islands and investing in aeronautics (extending the range and carrying capacity of bombers). Once within range of Japan, the Air Force tried strategic bombing at first, but found themselves unable to hit their targets. They had to fly above flak, and aim through the previously-undiscovered jet stream. They eventually gave up and turned from strategic bombing to recently-invented (demonstrated in 1942/3, mass produced in 1944) napalm. They knew it was awful, but considered it a trade of X lives now for 10x lives later. All this to say, I don’t believe that war weariness significantly influenced the decision to use napalm and atomic weapons, in Europe or Japan. If the allied powers had encountered the opportunity to use them within the first year of the war, their military doctrine would have dictated their use.
- overkalix 6y agoThis is such a remarcable piece of writing. I'm sure among americans this is already somewhat of a classic but if you haven't read yet it do yourself a favor and take half an hour to read it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dan-robertson 6y agoIf you look up the author, one of the first things a you will read is that this was judged to be the finest example of 20th century American journalism by a large group at New York university.
- gen220 6y agoIt also arguably made The New Yorker magazine. It’s identity is still strongly influenced by this piece. Each article they have published since has had to “follow” this one. Prior to WWII, its tone was more playful and humorous. The somewhat-detached, illustrative and poetic exposition originated in the war period, and resonates today.
- idlewords 6y agoIf you ever get a chance to visit the Hiroshima Peace Museum, it is a moving and worthwhile place to go. Give yourself a few hours so you can spend time watching eyewitness interviews. The main tram line through downtown goes right past Ground Zero, which never stops being shocking.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jfoster 6y agoThere is even some restored tram cars from that time still in use: https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-news-from-elsewhere-33148281 https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-news-from-elsewhere-33148281
- mholt 6y agoIf you're interested in this, I highly recommend watching In This Corner of the World. The perspective of a young woman who lives her life during the war, and her family's tragic experience with the bomb. If I'm not mistaken, it is the first anime the Emperor of Japan has gone to see personally in theaters (https://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2019/12/18-1/japans-emperor-and-empress-attended-charity-screening-of-in-this-corner-of-the-world-anime-film https://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2019/12/18-1/japans-e...). Spoiler-free analysis: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kPS2U2ijBkU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kPS2U2ijBkU US Netflix: https://www.netflix.com/title/80192244 https://www.netflix.com/title/80192244
- MrsPeaches 6y agoIf you have never read it, I high recommend "The Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima & Nagasaki" by the Manhatten Project [1]. There are some facinating technical details (in particluar the way heat reflected in the hills of Nagasaki) but in general it makes for grim reading. I was always struck by the contrast between the dispassionate analysis in the report and the final eye witness account in the appendix. I always had the feeling that they knew what they had done and knew that it was wrong. [1] https://www.abomb1.org/hiroshim/hiro_med.pdf https://www.abomb1.org/hiroshim/hiro_med.pdf
- ErikAugust 6y agoFeynman on Hiroshima is fascinating: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p018w6rc https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p018w6rc
- traceroute66 6y agoNuking the Japanese was just the culmination of rather horrific methods used by the US against Japan. Another one the US was quite keen on is firebombing (aerial incendiary bombing of urban areas). Grave of the Fireflies is a movie well worth watching that provides a depiction of the effect of war on society.
- spicyramen 6y agoI have had the opportunity to visit Hiroshima and lived in the US where I had the chance to study under professor William Perry former Secretary of Defense and responsible for many post war research. The perspective and official version that Americans have is that dropping the bomb was the right thing to do and only way to finish the war in the Pacific. The history is written by the winners simple fact to always keep in mind. This is clearly a misunderstanding of World War 2. In Europe after England and France lost their hegemony as empires, it became a race between USSR and US for world domination. The Red Army after controlling Germany were on their way to Japan, and Japanese were really afraid of it. There was a previous dispute over Kamchatka peninsula and other territories that Russians would want to claim back. US already defeated Japan in the Pacific and most of Japan was already destroyed. US sent the bomb to send a message to the World and USSR: we have this weapon and we will use it. It was in their best interest to control a Russia-free Japan than get into the same mess as in Germany.
- lordgeek 6y agoNotice the similarity with today Russia: - Run by an eternal Emperor adored by population at large (not counting few remaining intellectuals he murders every year) - Extremely religious-jingoistic national ideology as “strong spiritual braces of Russians”. Quite similar to militaristic Japan “warrior spirit of master race”. - Already invaded and conquered few smaller neighbors in the wars of conquest - On of top sources of toxic influence in every field in the modern world Countries who blindingly follow some two bit God-Emperor aggressive trash should not be surprised to eat Gamma rays for breakfast one fine morning.
- mlb_hn 6y agoGreat article. It's worth considering the Japanese reaction to the bomb - people thought it was cluster munitions or other conventional explosives leading to them taking sub-optimal follow-on steps. While the physicists figured it out, it was not obvious at the time to many people who experienced it firsthand what happened.
- hermitcrab 6y agoJapan and Germany were both utterly humbled by the war. They learnt the lessons and are now respected and vibrant democracies. UK and USA were on the winning side. This bred myths of British and American exceptionlism, which led eventually to Brexit, catastrophic handling of COVID19 and (perhaps) Trump. History often has a sting in it's tail.
- pengaru 6y agoI happen to have just started reading the book Made In Japan, and the first chapter's title is War. It's been a good read so far. I found it quite interesting to hear about the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings from the perspective of a young Japanese technician working in the war effort at the time. A lot of comments in here are throwing around terms like "war crime". I'm not well informed on this subject, but the impression I get from this book at least, wasn't one of anger and accusation of wrongdoing WRT the bombings. It comes across more as a humble acceptance of defeat, and perhaps a subtle criticism of his own nation's propaganda-washed populous, military-dominated leadership and authority, than anything accusing the Americans of committing war crimes. He describes the bombings as clearly demonstrating how far behind Japan was technologically. Up until that point he had the impression that Japanese military technology was only slightly behind the Americans, based on reverse engineered equipment recovered from downed planes. The thing I wonder is if the Americans could have just dropped a single bomb first on a relatively unpopulated area, near enough to a Japanese population center to witness its destructive force, without all the loss of civilian life. They might have surrendered after that. You still have the second bomb if they don't get the message. But I guess there wasn't exactly 100% certainty both bombs would function, and I don't know how long it would take to make another at the time - it's not like we had a huge stockpile of the enriched fissile material laying around. In any case, so far I'd recommend the book, and I haven't even gotten to the stuff about Sony yet.
- programmingpol 6y agoI highly recommend The Making of the Atomic Bomb. I listened to the audiobook last year. It starts with the scientific advances, beginning in the late 19th century, and continues up through the achievement of a chain reaction and the dropping of the bombs on Japan. The final part of the book, detailing the eyewitness accounts of the bombings, is the most harrowing thing I’ve ever listened to.
- mcguire 6y agoThe Atomic Bomb and the End of World War II: A Collection of Primary Sources https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB162/index.htm https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB162/index.htm
- mixmastamyk 6y agoThere are two "WWII - HD in Color" documentaries on Netflix right now. I recommend them if you find this subject interesting. The old one is more comprehensive, but a bit numbing in that it just hits you with fact after fact after fact. The newer one is a bit shorter, and breaks up the action with recent interviews with historians, who delve deeper on the "why" of what happened. The second one skips a few important things, so I recommend the older to fill in a few gaps even if you don't watch both.
- bamboozled 6y agoThe thing about all of this is that these bombs were dropped on children and innocents. Children on their way to school, the innocent and the weak were the victims of nuclear bombs, people were left without skin, their faces melted, bodies deformed and with radiation poisoning. Sorry but it's a disgusting and weak act no matter how you people try spin it, I can never truly get past the facts and some of the footage of the aftermath available.