4 ms·
I'm a wheat farmer in 6000 BC. I pay no attention to which seeds I use. Scenario 1): A random mutation decreases my yields. My community of 30 people can bare
by imtringued 6y ago
I'm a wheat farmer in 6000 BC. I pay no attention to which seeds I use.
Scenario 1):
A random mutation decreases my yields. My community of 30 people can barely get by on the food we grow. Some of our children died from starvation and we are down to 28.
Scenario 2):
A random mutation increases my yields. My community of 30 people can easily get by on the food we grow. None of our children are dying and we expect 5 children to be born this year. I can sell the extra seeds at the farmer's market and make an additional profit.
Absolutely zero genetic engineering is needed to improve yields. This is just natural selection. Nobody has to be aware of the process for improvements to happen.
The next step would be to just buy the best seeds available at the farmers market. It would significantly more effective than natural selection but all you're doing is buying seeds from the farmer who is selling more food than everyone else.
Calling this engineering would be insulting to every other branch of engineering. Anyone buying food would be genetically engineering their food by this definition. Seriously, what other branch of engineering requires no knowledge of it happening?
By that same logic everyone is an economist. The laws of supply and demand happen even if you are not aware of them.
I'm tired of people diluting "professional" words into meaninglessness. It's not a colloquial term and it certainly shouldn't become one.
- aidenn0 6y agoThere are records of farmers intentionally selecting for larger seeds; this was easily done by selecting the seeds on the bottom after winnowing. People would barter and buy seeds from farmers with higher yields with the intent of getting those larger yields themselves in future years. This is not natural selection. I'm equally sick of people implying that ancient people were stupid and incapable of engineering.