5 ms·
It's a good step, but what the US needs the most at the moment is a stronger education system. Most of what we're seeing today is really just a symptom of a dee
by baby 6y ago
It's a good step, but what the US needs the most at the moment is a stronger education system. Most of what we're seeing today is really just a symptom of a deeper issue.
- TomMarius 6y agoThese conspiracies are rampant in Europe too. Why didn't the stronger education system help here?
- kungato 6y agoWho says it's stronger? It's OK at best. If you look at numbers, 200k people being in a group about some dumb thing from a country of >300mil people (I guess there are people from other countries as well) is not that much. Especially if you suppose that many of those are not seriously believing but just there for the laughs
- TomMarius 6y ago> Who says it's stronger? It's OK at best It's what the Americans point to when they discuss reforms of their education system - and I am the one saying it's not really that strong, or rather, does not seem to be the actual solution.
- buzzert 6y agoHow does more education prevent conspiracy theories? I’ve witnessed many highly educated friends (including some from outside the US) succumb to crazy conspiracy theories on Twitter. This seems more like an emotional intelligence problem than anything else.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoCritical thinking skills immunize you against the disbelief of provable facts and rational thought processes (assuming reasonable mental health state). Emotional intelligence is a component though, for sure. You need both the skills and the desire to seek the truth versus accepting whatever information galvanizes your preexisting belief and value systems. High hill to climb.
- treeman79 6y agoThat’s nonsense. People believe what they want. I’ve seen many smart successful programmers spouting off crazy conspiracy theories.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoBeing smart and successful doesn’t mean you can think critically and challenge your belief and value systems. They are mutually exclusive. Kanye West is successful, you make what you will of the rest of his personality. Quite the contrary, many successful people believe they and they alone are responsible for their success, despite their contribution being less than that of others.
- belltaco 6y agoI agree with your point, but Kanye West has known mental issues.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThe same could be said for a non insignificant amount of the population. It’s far more common than one might think, and it’s important to internalize to understand the environment one is operating in. https://www.cdc.gov/mentalhealth/learn/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mentalhealth/learn/index.htm (Control-F “How common are mental illnesses?”)
- rdiddly 6y agoGP's statement was "You need... the desire to seek the truth" instead of reinforce what you already believe. In other words you, or let's say people, will choose, based on your desire, or let's say want, to believe one way or another. Your statement was "People believe what they want." You're both saying the same thing.
- rriepe 6y agoPeople who believe in conspiracy theories are more likely to be critical thinkers. People who can't think critically never believe in conspiracy theories. They believe the official story every time. I've never understood this argument against conspiracy theories. Conspiracy theories are the ultimate form of critical thinking.
- qzx_pierri 6y agoProper research, learning to find good sources, critical thinking skills, etc.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> of a ten year old Anyone who has the skills to find /pol/ and interact on that board has the digital skills needed to find true information. You don't just stumble upon that.
- Barrin92 6y agothere is no evidence for this. Achen and Bartels in Democracy for Realists[1] go through a lot of research that shows that education does not aid in combating disinformation and may in fact make the situation worse. One notable example is climate change. Among Republicans in the US belief in climate change actually declines with increasing education.[2]. Higher education or reasoning facilities don't stop misinformation because misinformation isn't the result of a literal lack of information, it's a rationalisation strategy of adopting fact to preconceived beliefs, and if anything highly educated or capable people are more likely to be able to justify their assumptions. This even literally shows up in the QAnon slogan which is "question everything". Conspiracy theorists virtually never lack the ability to critically think, if anything they think too critically. [1]https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691169446/democracy-for-realists https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691169446/de... [2]https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/11/14/upshot/climate-change-by-education.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/11/14/upshot/climat...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jmchuster 6y agoI think it's more that "question everything" mainly becomes "question everything that doesn't line up directly with my beliefs". And then you also get a feeling of superiority, of having secret knowledge/understanding, when the things that you are questioning are widely held to be true.
- raincom 6y agoYou are onto something very important. No one can be expert in every domain. So, one has to trust judgments of the people from other domains and institutions. However, if people with authority (not institutional authority) conflate science with policy positions, these 'authoritative' people and institutions lose their authority. That's how conspiracy theories emerge. Authoritative people and institutions have 'abused' their positions.
- Ericson2314 6y agoHere's a tentative conjecture. People in power, in the West, are disproportionately lawyers with humanities skills, or business types with no skills (lol). As our society increasingly fails, knowledge of math and science is increasingly important to convey truth. Politicians have long repeated repeated what experts tell them (when they are telling the truth), but now that they are repeating something they cannot well understand themselves, it just comes us stale / on faith alone.
- raincom 6y agoLawyers are paid to defend their clients. Every politician is a lawyer by trade. What do they do? Defend the sectional interests of their sponsors. That's what we see in the West: general interests are subordinated to the corporatist/sectional interests. This is the expected result, anyway; it is just a matter of how long does it take to reach the state of "sectional interests taking over general interests".
- Ericson2314 6y agoI'm sorry but this just reads as vague pessimism to me > Lawyers are paid to defend their clients. Every politician is a lawyer by trade. No, that would be true if "people paid to defend their clients are Lawyers". Lawyers offer a specific service to client, distinct from bodyguards and others who provide defense. Politicians do want to get reelected, but there are many ways for that to be. Nothing about politics is inherently sublimely, or sleazy things like ALEC inevitable. It rather the due to very specific problems in the US such as terrible voting systems. > This is the expected result, anyway To whom?
- wan23 6y agoYou need the right type of education. Being a highly trained engineer does not necessarily help, but you don't see a lot of historians falling for this type of stuff.
- an_opabinia 6y agoIf there were billionaire historians today you'd be hearing about their conspiracies.
- geofft 6y agoThe existence of the term "Polocaust" would like to disagree with you. A lot of this, I think, is driven by people badly wanting or not wanting things to be true. Religious history is another good spot where you can see highly-trained researchers buy into their community's biases, but in the last many years, we've gotten better as a society at acknowledging that religion is the sort of thing that can go sour like this. We haven't gotten good at acknowledging this about other forms of allegiance to a community. Most of the QAnon stuff is driven by patriotism gone sour, and with the benefit of hindsight, we've absolutely seen historians write to fit their worldviews, but we're not as good at seeing it in real time, when it matters.
- ineedasername 6y agoNot a silver bullet, but some focus on Informal Logic would at least help people to identify a claim, the premises for the claim, and typical fallacies.
- mindcrime 6y agoWhile I agree with that sentiment (and as you say, "not a silver bullet"), I despair over something I see more and more lately: people who do have at least some understanding of logic, and make "logical" arguments... but they've chosen the outcome they want to believe in advance, and are just using logic to rationalize / justify their belief. And yes, that's more or less exactly what logic is in a sense... except the people I'm talking about skip the part about checking the base premises they are building their argument on - because they so badly want to arrive at a specific conclusion.
- ineedasername 6y agoYes, "knowledge" is so broad that even if you have lots of learning you can choose subsets that support your predispositions. That's an understanding of human nature we've had for some time, giving rise to things like double blind randomized studies and the (too often ignored nowadays) need to reproduce results. But in less scientific environments (everyday life) we don't have easy workarounds for that aspect of human nature. I don't know the answer. I don't know how you get people in general to plow through emotional reactions first and then give in to them only after a thoughtful process. Education seems to help though, and lacking some other solution it seems a reasonable thing to focus on. Yet even that is now more of a political issue than it has ever been.
- lowdose 6y agoScience gives us a very sharp razor blade to separate emotions from facts. Even in western societies only 5 - 10% of the population is trained about people like Karl Popper and their knowledge.
- lordnacho 6y ago> How does more education prevent conspiracy theories? I’ve witnessed many highly educated friends (including some from outside the US) succumb to crazy conspiracy theories on Twitter. Degrees are often conflated with education. People need to be able to think critically, something that is only partially practiced at a modern institutions. There's plenty of people who can tell you the facts of some field without being able to explain what a theory is, or how evidence works.
- Ericson2314 6y agoOne issue is the truth of late in West has been more statistics and less theory based. Never mind that theory alone and statistics alone are both recipes for bias (either flat out fictional narratives (Freud) or p-hacking and over fit crap (bad science). At least when we erred on the side of theory, it was more "catchy" and better fit our narrative brains. Theory-based truths also derive more from subject-matter-specific reasoning, whereas statistics based truths derive more from subject-matter-agnostic reasoning. I started reading this https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/08/01/the-sociologist-who-could-save-us-from-coronavirus/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/08/01/the-sociologist-who-cou.... It does seem like Ulrich Beck was on top of lots of this stuff first.
- tempestn 6y agoI'm guessing most people you interact with are highly educated, and therefore most people you see spouting conspiracy theories are also highly educated. If you sampled the whole population though, I'm pretty confident you'd find a lower percentage of conspiracy theorists among college grads than the general population.
- heavyset_go 6y agoMedia literacy in the US is god awful even among the STEM educated.
- e9 6y agoCan you give me an example of crazy conspiracy theory that some of your highly educated friends succumbed? Just curious, thanks.
- buzzert 6y agoConcrete example: The slightly more frequent instances of fireworks in neighborhoods across the country leading up to 4th of July being a “psy-op” by the police targeting neighborhoods of color. This was believed by a Canadian friend who has a PhD, who is also addicted to Twitter.
- throwaw4y-plate 6y agoThis is the result of yesteryear's failures. It isnt the kiddos who are getting sucked into this stuff, and I say this as an early stage graybeard.
- sjroot 6y agoThis isn't exclusive to older people, either. Regardless, it will be even more dangerous when these people reproduce and raise their children to believe this stuff.
- demadog 6y agoAnecdotally I know several Gen Z-ers in their early 20s that are college educated and half believe in these conspiracy theories. May be more of a psychographic than demographic reason.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- KerryJones 6y agoMany of my high-school friends (I'm a millennial) are definitely being sucked into this.
- ianleeclark 6y ago> It isnt the kiddos who are getting sucked into this stuff, and I say this as an early stage graybeard. I would hesitate to say this. There have been emergences of qanon adjacent conspiracies popping up out of tiktok, the Wayfair one being the most obvious example.
- throwaw4y-plate 6y agoThis is sad to hear, if true.
- sjroot 6y agoBingo. It is not Facebook's responsibility to determine what is fact or fiction, and it is a bit terrifying that we increasingly rely on them (and other companies in this space) to do so. People need to understand how to question, investigate, and challenge the sources of information they consume. If we can't do that, in the US or otherwise, then we are doomed.
- polyomino 6y agoFacebook should teach people how to do that.
- sjroot 6y agoNo....no they shouldn't. I'd rather that responsibility fall on parents and teachers.
- vkou 6y agoIs it Facebook's responsibility to push paid political propaganda into my feed? Because I get no shortage of that, mostly from the Trump campaign. Right now, they absolutely do discriminate on the information they feed me - most of that discrimination comes in the form of "Did the author of the information pay us?"
- sjroot 6y agoThat’s their entire business model, so yes it is their responsibility. Their obligation is to advertisers that want to target very specific (or very broad) groups of people. If you don’t like that then close your Facebook account.
- vkou 6y agoAh, so Facebook has no moral obligation to control posts on whether or not they are true - just on whether or not they get paid to show them? I shudder to think of what a world will look like, where the only things known to the public are things that their authors paid for. That'll certainly be a great improvement to the status quo. People wring their hands over the fifty cent army, but I suppose the five-hundred-thousand-dollar-a-day political ad spend is just something we get to shrug our shoulders at.
- spamizbad 6y agoQAnon followers tend to skew older. It’s not something teens or 20-somethings are interested in.
- hhs 6y agoThere’s a long history of this issue in the US. If interested, in 1964, Richard Hofstadter wrote about this in detail in his book, “The Paranoid Style in American Politics”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paranoid_Style_in_American_Politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paranoid_Style_in_American...
- threatofrain 6y agoEventually good education will need to confront convincing fake videos. This will be an increasingly technical war where policy can only go so far.
- refurb 6y agoI assume HN is probably one of the better educated and critical thinking populations, but there are no lack of conspiracy theories that pop up on here.
- TaupeRanger 6y agoReally? I'm curious if you can find an example?
- belltaco 6y agoThere were some QAnon believers on here that weren't even downvoted. Not to mention a lot of misinformation about the need for Covid lockdowns.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 6y agoSome of the people falling for this are products of the education system of the 1960s and 1970s. The latency on "educational reforms" is enormous. > Most of what we're seeing today is really just a symptom of a deeper issue. Well, a whole cascade of deeper unresolved issues, plus a very modern Bernays-derived system for injecting nonsense into people and getting them to proliferate it.
- seamyb88 6y agoI agree. But there is an education war, rather than it being failures in honest attempts at providing a system. How many of QAnon are billionaires, millionaires or acutely wealthy? Yet they follow their billionaire leader with the belief he is working for them. Inequality needs stupidity to breathe. So, the ruling classes actively ensure that working class people have as little access to education as possible. The wealthy doctors, scientists and experts are the enemy. But the wealthy racist who is equally as stupid, is your friend. Absolutely, the largest part of the battle is education. But until we obtain the power to fight for it, we ain't gettin it.
- BurningFrog 6y agoEven if true, that takes decades to have any effect.
- steffenfrost 6y agoMister Educated applauding the curtailment of speech.
- nine_k 6y agoCurtailing is not a good idea. Clearly marking it, might be. Much like you can buy all manner of food supplement, but they don't pretend to be drugs, because they are marked with "efficacy is not clinically proven". (Even if "objectively" some of them are efficacious.) But this ends up with an unsexy task of picking a conspiracy theory to pieces and marking unconfirmed pieces as such, logic contradictions as such, etc. I'm very grateful to people who take take the time to do that. But definitely there are fewer such people than conspiracy theory outlets. It might be great to have a central repository of such analyses and refutations, crowd-supplied and peer-reviewed, like Wikipedia. The Lesswrong site could be part of it, but it has its own ...biases. TVTropes can be surprisingly useful for learning about and detecting common narrative devices used to drive the narrative and fiction, as opposed to trying to describe reality. But a level-headed, balanced site with systematic analysis of conspiracy theories either does not exist, not not publicized nearly enough.
- pointillistic 6y agoIf people here give up on free speech, all is lost. This and other groups are just a symptom. The reason these groups flourish is because the legacy media (aka MSM) has lost all trust. Should you also ban NYT for the Russian interference conspiracy theory? If the legacy media deal in conspiracy, you should expect a reaction on the periphery of the political spectrum.
- belltaco 6y ago>Should you also ban NYT for the Russian interference conspiracy theory? If the legacy media deal in conspiracy, you should expect a reaction on the periphery of the political spectrum. This is QAnon's very first post. https://i.imgur.com/ycdpCmS.png https://i.imgur.com/ycdpCmS.png Can you point me to any NY Times article that is even remotely close to this level of BS?
- pointillistic 6y agoyou can't compare some web forum to a paper that pretends to deal in actual news. Defend free speech above all or it is a slippery slope. and this is country sliding down that slope as we speak.
- belltaco 6y agoI mean, you were the one that compared them and came up with saying why should it not be banned. And now you argue against yourself. shrug
- pfdietz 6y agoI suggest strong criminal libel laws.
- Lammy 6y agoThe "deeper issue" is the underlying racial tension in America swept under the rug in the wake of 1960s civil rights laws. No reasonable person would think you can declare "racism is illegal" and it will instantly go away, right? So where did it go in the USA after 1968? Here are some clues: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=gentrification%2Csegregationist%2C%22local+control%22%2C%22civil+rights%22%2Cenvironmentalism%2Cenvironmentalist%2Cintegrationist&year_start=1900&corpus=15&smoothing=2&year_end=2008 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=gentrification...
- Joeri 6y agoStudies have found no significant correlation between intelligence and bias blind spot (inability to detect bias in one’s own thinking). Smart or less smart makes no difference in rational behavior. http://careymorewedge.com/papers/Scopellitietal2015BiasBlindSpot.pdf http://careymorewedge.com/papers/Scopellitietal2015BiasBlind... Education may help, but it needs to be focused specifically on bias blind spot reduction. There is some evidence mindfulness training is effective. Mindfulness is presently not taught in traditional education. https://medium.com/inclusion-insights/mindfulness-bias-literature-review-3e4a9993cb41 https://medium.com/inclusion-insights/mindfulness-bias-liter...
- perl4ever 6y ago>Smart or less smart makes no difference in rational behavior. What does "smart" mean then? You write like everyone knows what the definitions are of the words you use, but the way you use them makes it clear that they all need to be defined before any understanding could happen. I am completely apathetic about expert opinion and "studies" when I get a glimpse of some sort of community that just assumes everybody agrees on axioms and definitions.
- thewarrior 6y agoThis is an interesting question. I began using the internet at an early from 8th grade when things like Facebook didn’t even exist. I remember spending a lot of time reading about the reptile conspiracy, 9/11 conspiracies. I actually spent a lot of time seriously considering whether some of this information was true. The internet turned me into an atheist inspite of growing up in a religious setting. Blogs on the internet were much more aware of the impending financial crash in 2008 and the fact that Iraq did not have WMD. It takes a while of using the internet to learn how it works and the fact that any random lunatic can start a blog. My heuristic these days is that 80 % of mainstream opinion is true. The real world is quite complex and the internet is wonderful for doing your own research.