19 ms·
With AI-generated vocals and music, I think we're about to see an explosion in works created. I don't know that it's wise to invest in copyright catalogues righ
by echelon 6y ago
With AI-generated vocals and music, I think we're about to see an explosion in works created. I don't know that it's wise to invest in copyright catalogues right now. We're going to be able to create nearly unlimited music with famous vocalists (and entirely generated ones!)
Check out the Tupac Shakur voice on https://vo.codes https://vo.codes
It's kind of broken, but it took zero effort. And that's the direction we're headed.
r9y9 on Github has amazing results synthesizing lyrics. Better than vocaloid at this point.
Look what people are making:
https://www.reddit.com/r/VocalSynthesis/comments/i3egph/even_stronger/ https://www.reddit.com/r/VocalSynthesis/comments/i3egph/even...
https://youtu.be/3qR8I5zlMHs https://youtu.be/3qR8I5zlMHs
https://youtu.be/2X3Rqo6JVmg https://youtu.be/2X3Rqo6JVmg
https://youtu.be/noJHHN39ZCw https://youtu.be/noJHHN39ZCw
https://m.soundcloud.com/r9y9/sets/dnn-based-singing-voice https://m.soundcloud.com/r9y9/sets/dnn-based-singing-voice
My prediction is that in ten years, music copyright is going to be very different than it is today. We'll still have live artists putting on performances, but we'll also have entirely virtual artists like Gorillaz (with neural-backed lyrics) and recreations of Tupac, MJ, Elvis, and so on.
- jhardy54 6y ago> It's kind of broken, but it took zero effort. What does "zero effort" mean? I'd be surprised if you told me that Tupac's voice was recreated without using any copyrighted material.
- echelon 6y ago> I'd be surprised if you told me that Tupac's voice was recreated without using any copyrighted material. This fascinates me and opens up a wholly new can of worms. Technically, it's mostly Linda Johnson's speech data, which is in the public domain. Most voice models incorporate this as the base for learning how to transform phoneme to spectrogram, spectrogram to waveform. They'll then transfer learn on top of this. Could you tell the difference between Tupac and an impersonator? What about 10% Tupac, 90% impersonator? What if it's really 1% Tupac, 9% impersonator, 90% Linda Johnson? Or no Tupac at all? Can anyone tell the difference? Where did the copyrighted data go? Is there any left?
- jhardy54 6y ago> Could you tell the difference between Tupac and an impersonator? Probably not, but learning to impersonate Tupac isn't "zero effort" (and I'd imagine that it required access to copyrighted material). To be explicit: copyright is awful and I'd like to see it abolished. It's important to realize that nifty stuff like Tupac vocoders are not "zero effort" and require public access to data that intellectual propertarians want to have monopolies on.
- trash3 6y agoGood luck proving that.
- jhardy54 6y agoYou've missed my point. Please see my other comment.
- riantogo 6y agoAn explosion of work created doesn’t mean popularity. You can go to YouTube and find endless user generated good work. Popular (and hence valuable) music is the one that they system curates and puts in front of you (radio, shows etc.). In fact most people don’t even take a deep liking to a song in their first listen. But the system ensures repeatability which is a key factor in success. Then there is the social aspect of everyone liking it together.
- echelon 6y ago> An explosion of work created doesn’t mean popularity. 100% agree. I like the indie genre better than pop, though even that's somewhat manufactured by labels as you say. I recently found some incredibly underrated Zelda remixes that are jaw dropping and have barely been heard at all: https://youtu.be/4r9S2yEiuME https://youtu.be/4r9S2yEiuME So I agree with your argument. A new factor in the equation, however, is how much cheaper and less labor intensive it becomes to create new music. If you make it so that anybody can produce vocals, that changes the game for a lot of genres (eg. EDM). But these techniques won't just be viable on vocals. Everything is going to be easier to create. Melodies, instrumentals, the full stack. That's going to have a profound effect and definitely rock the boat the incumbents are riding.
- mynameishere 6y agohave barely been heard at all 1,601,808 views. That's about 1.6 million more views than I would expect from "Zelda remixes". So we both see artistic injustice in the world, just from a different angle. I will grant you it is better than 1982's "Pac Man Fever" though I suspect that made more money.
- coldtea 6y agoBut it's not as good as "Power Pill Pacman" which has 1/10 the views: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnURWFxwmk0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnURWFxwmk0
- coldtea 6y ago
- lordnacho 6y agoYeah, it's only a matter of time before everyone has an AI composer on their phone continually creating works they are likely to enjoy. I wonder if it will feel formulaic.
- echelon 6y ago> creating works they are likely to enjoy This! This is the future I want to live in and help create. People are going to have all sorts of media tweaked to their interests. The system will have to be smart enough to introduce novel changes in interest so that it never gets boring, or so that people's interests can be expanded. If we're careful, we can characterize and destroy the filter bubble while we're at it.
- grawprog 6y agoI have to say, this sounds awful to me. Living in a tiny bubble world surrounded by only things I like honestly sounds horrible. How can you appreciate the things you like if you never have to experience things you don't like? Life isn't supposed to be a constant pursuit of cutting out any unwanted or negative things. It's about experiencing things in general. A world like you describe sounds pretty bland and lifeless to me.
- Kiro 6y ago> Life isn't supposed to be a constant pursuit of cutting out any unwanted or negative things. It's about experiencing things in general. Says who? My goal is 100% to cut out all unwanted things. Even going so far that I only want things that I know bring me joy. Automate all chores and stop doing anything that I have the slightest doubt about. I'm at a stage now where I don't care if I never experience anything new. I could die happy continuing doing what I'm doing for the rest of my life.
- echelon 6y ago> I have to say, this sounds awful to me. Living in a tiny bubble world surrounded by only things I like honestly sounds horrible. This sounds like the anti-rock and roll argument wearing a different cloak. > How can you appreciate the things you like if you never have to experience things you don't like? I doubt this would remove all displeasure and pain from life. We're a long way away from dopamine drips and AI overloads. > Life isn't supposed to be a constant pursuit of cutting out any unwanted or negative things. Life isn't supposed to be about anything. We're apes on a mote of dust in an infinite void. > It's about experiencing things in general. This increases diversity of experience. It's something new. People aren't going to stop making music because it got easier. That strikes me as a Luddite argument. > A world like you describe sounds pretty bland and lifeless to me. The world gets better every year. These arguments are, frankly, a nostalgia for youth. Times change.
- giancarlostoro 6y ago> It's kind of broken, but it took zero effort. And that's the direction we're headed. "thug life" is kind of a horrifying one to hear. On another note it would be interesting to have a sort of test for these sort of systems, if they can say x sentences without screwing up, they can say almost anything. A "turing" test if you will.
- coldtea 6y ago>It's kind of broken, but it took zero effort. And that's the direction we're headed That's not the same as artist connection to the audience (which is a big thing even for pop music), or popularity. We've had such schemes for ages, even without AI (e.g. 3D or anime artists with songwriting teams behind them) but outside of a few cases (mostly in Japan) they're irrelevant...
- smabie 6y agoHow about gorillaz?
- coldtea 6y agoI'd say Gorillaz fit into the "outside of a few cases (mostly in Japan) they're irrelevant.." thing I wrote about... A single case, so not enough to generalize of any major demand for this sort of thing. And they played off the people knowing it's Albarn behind the scenes (who was already popular with Blur).
- tomc1985 6y agoGod, I hope not
- dehrmann 6y agoI find that take on the future of music depressing. A big part of music is how shared it is. This is why I love piano bars and people singing along with every song. This doesn't work with everyone listening to personalized AI-generated earworms. To your point, while the value of old songs usually drops over time, I don't see new music, AI-generated or not, driving it down more. A familiar song takes you back to a different time and place, and there's no substitute for that.