6 ms·
What I Learned from the Worst Novelist in the English Language
- jamestimmins 6y agoReally enjoyed this piece. Quite poignant and has enough self reflection to conventuals the writers experience without being self indulgent.
- jamestimmins 6y ago*contextualize
- afr0ck 6y agoI really enjoyed the writing even though it took me some time to correctly understand some passages (I am not a native speaker). I feel sorry for Burrows's case, he seems to be a great militant against oligarchy and oppression as well as a tempted writer who was not fairly reviewed by his peers.
- wombatmobile 6y agoRobert Burrows wasn't the worst novelist in the English language. The article makes that clear. The article includes Gene Weingarten's demeaning characterisation to get clicks. That wouldn't be necessary if Barrett Swanson had listened to his better instincts, and built on his portrait of Robert Burrows as an earnest man of letters. Instead, he had a bet each way, perpetuating Gene Weingarten's cruel ruse as a straw man, and negating it.
- ponker 6y agoRobert Burrows is not newsworthy without Gene Weingarten. The article would leave a massive unanswered question at its center.
- andrewflnr 6y agoYes, as I read it the unfairness and falseness of the review was the core of the story.
- wombatmobile 6y ago> Robert Burrows is not newsworthy without Gene Weingarten. Are you saying that in your way of thinking, newsworthiness only arises from a false, disparaging accusation?
- andrewflnr 6y agoIt's easy to answer that question by just, you know, reading what they're actually saying, instead of making insinuations based on the dumbest possible thought someone could have about the article.
- wombatmobile 6y agoI read the article, andrewfinr. It seems like a serious attempt to inform us about the humanity and abilities of Robert Burrows. The reason it tends more towards clickbait than necessary is obvious from the headline: What I Learned From the Worst Novelist in the English Language If the article was more of an attempt to rehabilitate Robert Burrows, who the author visited on his death bed to get the story, the headline might more candidly have been written as: What I Learned From the "Worst Novelist in the English Language" Swanson does encapsulate the insult in inverted commas, but not until para 19, when he writes: There was something regal, something monumental, in his bearing, and though I knew otherwise, I found myself thinking, “There he is. The worst novelist in the English language.” Was it really necessary, or beneficial to share that thought, if the point of the article is to debunk the insult?
- andrewflnr 6y agoThose are reasonable points that are entirely irrelevant to mine, which was about how you misrepresented ponker's position through your asinine, insulting "in your way of thinking" question. You didn't even have to stretch for a charitable interpretation: the surface reading was perfectly decent. Instead you either thought they were making some ludicrous generalization about newsworthiness for all time, or found it rhetorically useful to seem to think that. In either case your comment provided negative value.
- frostburg 6y agoI would argue that the worst English language novelist, among those of reasonable renown, was Anthony Trollope (but this kind of statement is fraught with issues, due to inclusion criteria - I'm not counting people that write for, say, Castalia House - and inherent subjectivity).
- lordgrenville 6y agoCare to expand on this? Never heard this opinion before, and I quite liked the one novel of his I've read (The Warden).
- frostburg 6y agoI find that his alleged realism is mostly a fixation with the trivial (there are exceptions, but they tend to be drowned out). Besides often reading like the compiled research material of someone doing research on historical inflation rates, the structure of his works suffered from his large output.
- sbierwagen 6y agoI'd nominate Hugo award winning author Liu Cixin.
- JohnStrangeII 6y agoI've got to agree, The Three Body Problem was the second worst science fiction novel I've ever read - to be honest, I only read 3/4 of it. But he's not an English author so he doesn't count.
- yeellow 6y agoWhich was the worst? I am not a great fan of this trilogy but I've read many worse scifi books, including some considered classic.
- JohnStrangeII 6y ago
- zwaps 6y agoOff topic: This is how this website looks when I open it: https://i.imgur.com/M1m5LJX.png https://i.imgur.com/M1m5LJX.png yikes
- skitter 6y agoOn my phone in landscape orientation, the blue popup in front of the other two popups that cover half of the screen each is so big that the closing-button is unreachable. Quite unusable.
- itronitron 6y agoAnyone that creates and that cares how their work will be received by others should volunteer as judges in competitions until they realize fully how subjective and biased the judging committees are. Since Burrows already had some experience running against the establishment (his university administration) I expect that he was not particularly fazed by the negative review.
- leib 6y agoIf you can't do, judge. I suspect some of these people are bad faith in their criticisms simply because they're bitter their own work didn't take off.
- bitwize 6y ago"But the bitter truth we critics must face, is that in the grand scheme of things, the average piece of junk is probably more meaningful than our criticism designating it so." --Anton Ego, Ratatouille
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]