5 ms·
The missing piece of the puzzle is that we never meet the idiot manager in the story. She's in an organizational situation where her team has oversight over a
by shadowgovt 6y ago
The missing piece of the puzzle is that we never meet the idiot manager in the story. She's in an organizational situation where her team has oversight over a team in the government implementing on a project but does not have the ability to directly set policy, constrain goals, or otherwise apply direct managerial leverage. The idiot in the story is the guy charging full speed ahead with a deployment of a product that is already known compromised. Matt Cutts, meanwhile, is the head of her department, and also has no managerial oversight over the team she just called federal law enforcement on.
Because she is incentivized to make the product as good as possible, not hit deadlines and satisfy arbitrary legislative targets divorced from software engineering reality, it never occurred to her how much s* she was going to cause for the people in the direct chain of management by getting the FBI involved. It's probably the right thing to do... Ultimately, the software was compromised by domestic terrorists and the threat was real. But she's basically just wrecked any goodwill she had working with this department for the foreseeable future (especially if it turns out that somebody in the management chain that she has oversight over has actually managed to break the law due to negligence ;) ).
- pdonis 6y ago> The idiot in the story is the guy charging full speed ahead with a deployment of a product that is already known compromised. Ah. That makes sense.
- phkahler 6y ago...the team she just called federal law enforcement on. That's interesting, I didn't see it as reporting the other team to law enforcement. The law breaking was anticipated to be done by people outside government. The whole raise your right hand thing seemed weird (perhaps a formality) unless you think she was implicating specific people. In that case it makes more sense.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt's not precisely that she called law enforcement on them, poor choice of words on my part. It's more that, if you will, she turned the "eye of Sauron" on the project. If the team she had oversight on thought they were going to meet deadlines with open security holes, having the FBI actively looking at what they're doing pretty much torpedoes that hope.
- rrobukef 6y agoIt seems like the team wanted it torpedoed as well. Every higher up was aware but tied in bureaucracy. The team basically washed their hands and tried to deliver in order to pass the buck. Messing with things codified in federal law seems like a very poor career choice.
- throwaway33222 6y ago>The missing piece of the puzzle >the software was compromised by domestic terrorists and the threat was real The missing piece to me is that she says, specifically, that it was under attack by white supremacists. If you know anything about WS types, they are profoundly anti-intellectual. Anyone who has the technical chops to compromise software would almost certainly be labeled a secret jew/antifa/etc. Frankly I find "white supremacists threatening to hack my unreleased federal platform" as absurd as Budweiser claiming mormons are going to steal their trade secrets. Perhaps the reason her zeal was encountered with groans is not that she is brave and strong but rather because she made a mistake, and now procedure requires people to go through tedious motions. They groan because in the public sector they can't simply sack her for incompetence. From what she writes of Matt's response, she completely misinterprets things like this all the time. I posit that this is a natural reaction of ordinary people to a woman who is simply not capable of interpreting reality correctly. No doubt the FBI will agree, and she will claim they are some secret sympathizers. Her boss is an idiot, the fbi are secret terrorists, the list will pile high to the sky. People like her live their whole lives never encountering reality.
- fwsgonzo 6y agoWhat on earth is this? Are you serious?
- Aeolun 6y agoWe have literal 17 year olds hacking the twitter account of Obama and a ton of other high profile people. How can you possibly believe that a bunch of white supremacists are not a threat? You need only one marginally competent one to wreck your entire platform.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoI would also say that assuming that white suprematists are inherently stupid is wrong. It takes a certain amount of rough intelligence to go against the modern norms (I.e. to justify your beliefs to others, to read just the right books) to keep these beliefs. Thinking they are “just” idiots is an entirely wrong take if you are trying to play against them. It’s like saying that Putin is an idiot because he’s against gay rights in Russia. But if he was really stupid he would probably be dead by now.