2 ms·

Sure, it would be nice to go back to IETF and RFCs. But it seems like the discussion has wandered far afield from a Google breakup (more standard APIs/protocols

Sure, it would be nice to go back to IETF and RFCs. But it seems like the discussion has wandered far afield from a Google breakup (more standard APIs/protocols may not result from a breakup and may not need a breakup). And what I hate about Google/Facebook breakup discussions is how they seem driven by a mob of all those having complaints against these tech giants, where the complaints contradict each other (too much censorship, too little censorship, Google too few or too many products, etc) but the likely upshot on success is states gaining more leverage over these companies and using them as even more effective control/propaganda outlets.

mulmen 6y ago
The IETF and RFCs are alive and well. There is no going "back" we are still there. That's a good thing. I don't see a complaint that Alphabet has too few services. The complaint seems to be that Alphabet is killing viable businesses or products because it can't spin them off profitably. Alphabet controls some amount of innovative economic capability that is creating products which Alphabet then wastes. Conversations about breaking up companies like this are about reallocating that economic capability to somewhere it can deliver value.