6 ms·
>I do wonder what we interact with regularly that future people would have to be paid very well to even be in the same room with, and will think we were nuts fo
by mrtksn 6y ago
>I do wonder what we interact with regularly that future people would have to be paid very well to even be in the same room with, and will think we were nuts for ever thinking was OK.
I am betting on combustion engines. It is ridiculous that we have hundreds of millions of those on our streets, releasing the fumes straight into the air where we live our whole lives.
- grey-area 6y agoYes. Oil-based cars and trucks kill people in cities and exacerbate many illnesses like asthma. When they are gone people will wonder why they were ever allowed.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> When they are gone people will wonder why they were ever allowed. The engine tech may go away. The vehicles wont. CO2 doesn't cause asthma. Most particulates, at least from non-diesel vehicles, comes from things other than the enigne. Brake pads, tires, even the road surface itself. They all wear down, turning into dust, and get inhaled into our lungs. Electrification won't change that. One interesting line of research is carbon fiber fires, and increasing problem as many high-end EVs are using CF to reduce weight. One CF vehicle, on fire after an accident, will release a massive amount of very fine particulates that could drift on the wind for many miles.
- spanhandler 6y agoI'm increasingly convinced that allowing widespread use of automobiles on public roads will be regarded as one of the biggest societal-engineering blunders of all time. Between the health effects (of the cars and roads themselves, plus the secondary effects on physical activity) and the adjustments to city layouts plus extra costs eating most or all of the time-savings anyway, it's hard to see a clear upside. Granted much of that would have been difficult to discern when early decisions on the topic were being made, but that doesn't make it any less an error in its effects.
- sandworm101 6y agoLook at what city slums were like before widespread motorized transporation. The ability to live in a different area than the coal plant where you worked was a massive improvement to health. Even today, with COVID, the ability to live in suburbs vs high-density inner city biuldings is a benifit. Then there are the knock-on social mobility benifits such as being able to switch jobs without having to move your family. Or, at a lower level, not having to rent your house/appartment/shack from your employer. Many people see cars as evil today, but realize that today is not yesturday.
- iknowstuff 6y agoI highly recommend researching the Dutch street design. By explicitly avoiding freeways and encouraging biking, they save so much time (no traffic) and money (think long term health benefits of cycling, no pollution, cheaper infrastructure, lower reliance on fossil fuels, fewer accidents, more visits to local businesses) it's insane the rest of the world isn't copying them ASAP. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuBdf9jYj7o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuBdf9jYj7o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GsQQ8Ujbua4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GsQQ8Ujbua4
- maxerickson 6y agoThe region I live in has about the same land area as the Netherlands, and less than 2% of the population. Of course we don't really have traffic problems, but I wonder how we are supposed to build similar amounts of infrastructure? Should we stop living here and move somewhere with more people?
- wolco 6y agoMove closer together, pool resources and allow nature to exist in the now empty space.
- ghaff 6y ago>it's hard to see a clear upside Vastly enhanced point-to-point mobility seems like a pretty clear upside to me. Absent cars, public transportation would doubtless be better. But people would have far less flexibility in where they lived, where they went for recreation, and in many other things.
- Const-me 6y ago> Electrification won't change that True for tires and road, but EVs wear brake pads much slower, due to regenerative breaking.
- mantas 6y agoNot only EVs do regenerative braking. And then there’s old good engine braking in manual IC cars.
- cik2e 6y agoAlmost every automatic nowadays gives you a couple of gears to play with. I always downshift on curves or when braking to a stop. I also drive a hybrid and downshifting guarantees regenerative braking whereas with the pedal it’s easy to over do it and engage the pads.
- grey-area 6y agoThat's not regenerative, it wastes more fuel and produces more pollution.
- mantas 6y agoHow engine braking wastes fuel?
- grey-area 6y agoExposure to pollution caused by cars and other vehicles is strongly correlated with asthma.[0] I'm glad you mention CO2, which does cause global warming, we might want to try to fix that too before it is too late? Carbon Fibre is expensive and irrelevant, and fires from it even more so, unless you want to minimise the impact of oil based cars on health in cities. Most popular EVs don't use it. Traffic is a major source of particulates (20-30%) [1] so reducing it would help a lot, in particular diesel cars and trucks, though yes some things like rubber from tyres would only be helped by traffic reduction, simply switching to EVs would help a lot. Moving to walking, bikes and public transport for most journeys in cities is the sustainable answer I suspect we'll end up at, and from that future our reliance on individual polluting cars will seem insane. It would require a rethink of some city planning of course, but many people happily live without cars in Europe at the moment. 0. https://airqualitynews.com/2020/02/07/air-pollution-responsible-for-half-of-childhood-asthma-cases-in-barcelona/ https://airqualitynews.com/2020/02/07/air-pollution-responsi... 1. https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/news/what-are-main-sources-urban-air-pollution https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/news/what-are-main-sources-urban...
- CapricornNoble 6y ago>>>When they are gone people will wonder why they were ever allowed. Because they're FUN. https://youtu.be/-mqXXqB7SBQ https://youtu.be/-mqXXqB7SBQ Just like eating red meat. It has consequences for you health, but bacon-wrapped filet mignon, in moderation, is worth the consequences.
- grey-area 6y agoI'm happy for you to make that sacrifice to your health, I'm not happy for you to impose the health consequences on your poorer neighbours (as happens driving a car in a city).
- refurb 6y agoPeople are going to wonder why cars and trucks were allowed? A core part of our transportation network that delivers nearly every product we purchase and moves people around so they can work and have a social life. People are going to wonder that?
- grey-area 6y agoCars do very few deliveries, and hard as it might be to imagine in a US city designed around cars, they're simply unnecessary in a dense city, in fact they negatively impact everyone else. Diesel trucks do not belong in cities IMO. Yes, people are going to wonder why it was ok to kill others with pollution by driving through cities with combustion engines.
- spanhandler 6y agoDon't forget rubber tires grinding against asphalt at high speed. Or brake pad dust. We're already at the point we know it's bad to spend much time near highways (say, living within a few hundred feet of them) but haven't, as a culture, really decided to do anything about it yet. Probably because we're too all-in on 55+ MPH roads, so far as infrastructure, so the cost to fix our mistake would be too high.
- subsubzero 6y agoStaying at a rental that is next to a residential street, the city is very clean and air is great. The street has somewhat alot of traffic and I noticed that the table outside we eat on gets dirty very quickly. Like in one day a wipe on it is black and filthy from the street which is behind a hedge 20ft away.
- wolco 6y agoI lived within 100 ft of a highway and an extremely busy road. I felt sick for years.. the dust on the floor was sticky with an oil. Didn't help there was a parking garage in the building below me taking up half of the first floor. Not sure what causes that oily dust
- samus 6y agoThe balcony of the flat where I live at is unusable because of the major street next to it. There's this same greasy dust everywhere. My guess is that it is soot, covered with unburnt hydrocarbons, from car or oil heating exhaust. It's really disgusting. I have resigned long ago to not let plants intended for consumption grow there...
- jrsdav 6y agoIt's ridiculous now, yes; but don't forget that tech progress is cumulative. We likely needed those "fumes" so something better could come along and stand on its shoulders. It's pretty exciting to be living during a transition period to cleaner energy. Just as exciting is signs of tangible evidence that this movement is indeed better for our longevity and quality of life. I'm hopeful we will keep progressing.